can anyone shed some light on the flow characteristics of an axial
supercharger?
What is the plus/ minus argument?
How does it compare to the Lysholm whipple charger we looked at
recently?
I understand axial flow compressors as an ex jet jockey, but as part of
a gas turbine; Pumping air into a car engine is a different matter.
Has anyone on here had experience with this type of blower?
If it is anything like the 'latham' axial flow of the fifties, it might not
be too impressive; but, who knows?
jesse farr, soddy tn
Jesse,
Thanks for those pictures.
The axial-flow supercharger for the RX8 is billed as a refinement of the
Latham supercharger of the 1950s:
http://www.axialflow.com/history.htm
The guy took the Latham concept and supposedly refined the aerodynamics of
the fan blades, giving them airfoil sections rather than just being flat.
How much difference that makes is anyone's guess.
The Latham is the only previous example of an axial-flow supercharger for
piston engines that I could find with a quick search, so it's kind of a
unique product as far as superchargers go.
But how does it stack up to centrifugal or positive-displacement blowers?
Just relying on my very basic understanding of axial flow compressors in
turbine engines, I would say that it probably has to spin at high rpm to
achieve compression -- like the centrifugal. Probably five to six times
engine rpm. This means it will be poor at making boost at low rpm, again
like the centrifugal.
So I think in general the axial-flow unit could be comparable to a
centrifugal compressor, maybe a little more efficient, due to the straighter
airflow. I'm not sure on this point, though.
The axial flow compressors are great in jet engines because they are much
smaller diameter than centrifugal compressors, so the engine can be slimmer
and the airplane aerodynamics better.
There are a couple of good articles in Wikipedia:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axial-flow_compressor
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jet_engine
When it comes to superchargers for piston engines, the centrifugal
compressor works well for a traveling airplane, where you will be mostly
cruising at a steady rpm. So the axial would probably work well here too.
But for acro you need instant power response, and here the positive
displacement superchargers like the Lysholm and Roots would seem to be
better. They are not quite as efficient as the centrifugal or axial -- but
it is like magically adding cubic inches. If you boost to twice the
atmosphere, you will in effect have an engine of double the displacement,
everywhere in the rpm band.
There is a further distinction among positive displacement compressors --
those with internal compression rations, like the Lysholm, where the air is
compressed inside the housing, and the Roots type, where the compression
occurs in the outlet duct.
Again Wikipedia has a good article on supercharging:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jet_engine
I was surprised to learn recently that the rotary engine has been used as a
compressor -- it is a positive displacement compressor just like a piston
compressor. I have no idea of its efficiency, but if you wanted to, I
suppose you could have a supercharged rotary engine, in which the
supercharger is itself a little rotary.
Regards,
Gordon.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.