Subject: Goose Cooling and Exhaust
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/18/2006, 8:49 AM
To: AA-me




> Paul and group:
>
> After a little break trying to absorb the hundreds of variables related> to cooling my engine, I've hopefully made a little more progress.  I
> finally ran out of cardboard making radiator mockups 8-}
>
> A major factor for me is the difficulty vs benefit ratios of different> cooling schemes.  Custom vs stock radiators are another.  I'm
> fascinated by the radiators in the trailing edge flap concept, but this
> would have a high difficulty ratio, with wing modifications, 2 custom> coolers, complex plumbing, etc.
>
> It appears that stuffing all the radiators inside the cowling may be
> the most workable solution in terms of me actually finishing this
> project.  Other Goose builders have been reasonable successful with
> this approach.
>
> This leaves the following major options:
> 1.  One larger right (hot side) water radiator (about 9x14x2), a
> smaller left radiator (total >400 cubic inches) with ducting around the
> left side to the oil cooler
> - see attached crude drawing, which is a TOP view -  (please ignore the
> residual trash at the bottom of drawing)
> - this may work because the smaller left water radiator can allow
> enough space for the oil cooler ducting to sneak around  the side (need> about 3"x10" area)
> - the  oil cooler would have to have a bunch of cowl exit slots in the
> upper and  lower cowling, which are moderately complex, and a potential> obstruction to exit air flow
> - plumbing 2 radiators is always an issue.
> - this results in a moderately-wide cowling (about 28")
>
> 2. 1 oil cooler up front, and a single water radiator on the left
> (cool) side, exiting out the cowling (as per Paul's cooling article)
> - this results in a very wide cowl (about 32"), due to the corners of a
> big radiator and the size of the duct needed to feed it (about 60 sq.> inches area)
> - also requires a bunch of cowl exit slots
> - the duct would be right  up against the spark plugs
>
> 3. Two equal sized water radiators up front, and an oil cooler
> somewhere else.
> - this give a smaller frontal area for the water radiators (using
> 9.5x11x2 cores)
> - this will work using 2" cores, but if some volume could come from a
> thicker core (3" evaporators), then even a smaller frontal rofile is
> possible
> - oil cooler options discussed below
>
>
>
> Oil Cooler
> A single oil cooler would work on the left side of the engine, with
> some difficulty.  Another consideration that seems viable is to place> the oil cooler on top of the engine.  I can get a 10x11x2" core either
> on top of the redrive, or on top of the block, as per the pics.  This> could be fed by a separate intake, similar to the implementation
> previously posted on the SeaHawker that broke a wing.  A long duct from
> the very front intake might  also work, but would have more resistance> and would have to navigate around obstructions. It would not require a
> boundary-layer offset, however.
>
> A top cooler seems to have the advantages of:
> - a single, (and off-the-shelf) cooler
> - no asymmetry issues
> - simple, wedge-shaped ducting
> - the exit of the radiator could be open to the air in a low-
pressure> area
> - small and narrow frontal profile (see pics)
> - simple cowling modifications
> - note the pictures have a 16" diameter disk at the prop flange,
> consistent with Paul's recommendation for cowling exit airflow sizing> (12" prop spinner size not shown)
>
> and disadvantages:
> - some complexity of a separate intake duct feeding a wedge diffuser
> - the duct intake would  have to be elevated up and out of the boundary> layer  (1-2"?)
> - a front cooler location would have to feed past the alternator (not> shown)
> - a location over the redrive would have to duct over Tracy's redrive> plate, and would be closer to the exhaust system
>
> Exhaust
> Either of the oil cooler  options allows for a side-mounted, 6"
> VAM-type muffler, about 8" in length.  The factory strongly recommends> the exhaust goes straight up, which would  work with a straight pipe or
> fishmouth.  See the pics of the (very crude) mockups.
>
> The zoomed out view gives an idea of how a side profile of the cowling> might  work with a top oil cooler.  The front views show where a
> top-front or top-rear oil cooler might impact the frontal area.
>
> Hopefully this is progress in the  right direction.  As always,
> comments are greatly appreciated.
>
> Scott Gettings
>
> -----------------------------------------------
> I still say this is your best bet Scott.
> It will clean things out from under the cowl.
>
> The fundamental problem is an effective cooling system,
> considering the diffuser ducts and scoops, is a high
> volume system.
>
> The exhaust ejectors along with the prop will suck air
> at takeoff and climb when you need it.
>
> The modern large frontal area thin radiator will work
> well at low speeds where you need the cooling.
> If necessary there is plenty of room for electric fans.
>
> This is the least technical risk cooling system.
> It will work from the get go with no expensive changes.
>
> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
>
> ------------------------------------------------------
> Scott, Rino has the right idea with that prop extension.
> Last picture in the attachments.
>
> This will allow extending the sides of the fuse back
> at a more favorable angle.
>
> Also his alternator mounting will reduce the frontal area
> of the cowl.
>
> -- > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
>

Thanks, Paul.

Rino has done some great work.  He has twin alternators, even.  The
prop extensions are standard fare for the  Goose.  He also used the
straight-up exhaust, which is recommended by the factory.  Rino has hadno cooling problems at low engine and air speeds so far.

I've spent a bunch more time studying this matter and looking at how
things might fit.  Unfortunately, there simply isn't enough room to getthe exhaust pipes to drop down either in front of or behind the bridgeto serve as augmenters (as per your drawings).  So whatever radiatorscheme might be best, it really can't depend on the exhaust system.
Scott Gettings

Too bad. In theory it was the way to go. Cools the exhaust gases
and the coolant radiators.

It is a composite airplane... you can't just pooch it out
in that area to clear the exhaust?
Promise the seller you are not going to sue them :)

On the other hand why not just copy Rino?
Does he live up North?

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


Hey Paul,

Yes, Rino does live up north.  He had previously reported no cooling
problems at moderate power settings, but I see from his post yesterday
that he is now having some water temp issues.  He uses thick evaporator
cores up front, and also has a turbo and intercooler.  I've seen his pix
and schematics -- it is amazing he shoehorned all this stuff into the
cowl and pylon.  There are definitely aspects of his work that some of
us are copying.  However, I have not seen any Goose or Seahawk that used
ducting to its limits.

Based on everything to date, it seems that I should use bigger, thinner
water radiators up front with appropriate ducting into (and out of if
possible) the cores.  This could work with either a slightly smaller
radiator on the front/left/cool side, and a duct to an oil cooler on
this same side, or symmetric radiators up front (about 9.6x16x2") and
the oil cooler "somewhere else" (as per above).  This would be simpler
than Rino's installation and much more in line with best practice
recommendations.

As much as I've studied this (including your great 3Ds), the oil cooler
and ducts just do not want to work down inside the pylon -- especially
with exhaust augmenters.  In fact, the factory said they experimented
with an oil cooler in the pylon for years, and were never happy with the
results.

BTW, with split water radiators plumbed in parallel, it seems that it
might be very easy to end up with mismatched flow.  I wonder if this
contributes to some people's cooling issues?  Should I plan on
instrumenting the pressure drops on each side to assure this is not the
case?

Scott Gettings


Ejectors AKA augmenters  really work. Plenty of airplanes have been
built that have used them successfully.

Who knows how the factory did it.  A lot of mistakes
can be made.  Until I see some pictures
I can't really comment on it.

I hear this all the time. "I already tried that idea and it
did not work." After you investigate you find the implementor
did not really understand how to do it and did it wrong.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.