Congrats. Paul. This is a big step forward. Amazing isn't it how
the shape seems obvious now, but we (no one) could come up with it
over all these years. I would love to see a Tailwind version with
sections. Jerry
So far we have been trying to stuff a liquid cooling system under
cowls designed for air cooled horz opposed engines.
There are some real kludges out there with two rads and
a pile of spaghetti plumbing.
I am real excited about this new cowl. Perhaps we can find some
body that can make them and sell them. I mentioned it to
Will James but he is pretty busy.
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Paul, I'd be interested in producing them if
there's enough interest.
Things are progressing on the Nc Mill, but slowly.
I'm currently
waiting on some precision machined parts which are
becoming a bottle
neck.
Anyway, we'll see if there is enough interest in
the mean time.
Jarrett
I think you would make money for years to come.
Will James charges about a $1000 I think for his cowls.
Cooling always has been a big hassle. The right cowl
would go a long way to solve that problem.
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
I think $950 for a cowl is unreasonable. The James cowl for the Lyc
RVs is the same price ($950) but you get some snazzy machined parts; a
much better deal but still pricey. For the rotary you only get
fiberglass. Really turned me off.
I have been adding up the estimated component costs of the rotary
firewall forward. If we (the rotary movement) are not careful we will
not be price competitive with the Lyc. Sure we know the rotary is a
superior engine (except for BSFC). But that in itself is a hard sell.
Given the same price, the relative ease of installation, and the ready
availability of almost any kind of accessory, most builders will opt
for the rotary. Mistral has priced itself out of the running in my
firm opinion; we shall see.
For me, the primary reasons for choosing the rotary, in rank order,
are:
1. Robustness
2. Low cost
3. Reduced vibration and shake
4. Fun, interesting, educational, challenging, etc.
Different builders will have different reasons. One of the first
things that attracted me was #2 (that Scottish blood again! Is Tracy
Scottish?) and #3. #4 was not even on the horizon (actually a
negative: delayed first flight).
The home built aviation market is so thin that it is impossible to get
rich in it, regardless of the price charged. Using component
fabrication and sales to support a hobby (machinery purchase, flying
expense, whatever) is a reasonable goal. If you don't enjoy doing
whatever for the sake of doing it you aren't doing yourself or anyone
else a favor, in my opinion. At least that is what I found out about
myself, and it seems to be true for everyone. Chasing a $ is a
mistake; follow your bliss. Poor but happy is much better than rich
and unhappy. For myself I intend to price anything that I might
fabricate in the future using Henry Ford's strategy: price it as if it
were being mass produced, i.e., cover the cost of materials plus a
very little. If we succeed in making the rotary a viable option, maybe
Mazda or some other mass producer will offer an
aviation/marine/whatever option or parts. Wouldn't it be nice to be
able to buy an engine with p-ports, oil pan, etc. from Mazda? And a
really effective tuned muffler that would fit under the cowl? How
about an almost all Al engine? I could go on and on. Not likely, but
possible.
With regard to the cost, if the total becomes too high I will change
my mind and go with a Lyc. Before I started seriously investigating
the rotary, I started accumulating Lyc parts, so in a sense I have
already started. I would regret loosing the robustness and smoothness.
Conventional wisdom is that an aircraft with a Lyc will bring a higher
price than one with an auto conversion. So if the $ become unfavorable
I will have an unpleasant decision to make.
Doc Custer
Retired software engineer and sometime Audiologist
Building RV9-A. Fuselage
Well put Doc.
I don't know about not getting rich. Tracy, Van and Klaus
are doing REAL well :) You have to look at it long
term. You are not going to break even for a couple of years.
Maybe 5. Exp aviation is a real stable biz compared to some other
bizes I know about. Take large screen TVs for an example :)
Mazda could wake up any day and do a Honda :)
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.