Subject: Interesting item from the RV-9 list.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/24/2006, 9:08 AM
To: AA-me


I picked the following up off the RV9 list. The author,  Gary Newsted,
has a sube and his responses are to some objections raised by a Lyc
driver. His
reasons for going with the sube: cost of ownership, smoothness and
robustness. His reasons are very similar to mine. Is the Mazda
superior to the Sube? I think so. On the other hand he ordered
a complete engine
package from a single vendor for a known price. I can't. Hmmm. No, not
for me.

I notice he promotes the sube by giving rides.
Judging from the pix on the website, they use thick rads and a typical
cowl designed for an air cooled engine. I think Paul's cowl and cooling
arrangement is vastly superior. I am anxious to see how it flies in a 9A.

Van lists an empty weight for the 9/9A as 1043/1050 his weighs 1190 but
he lists lots of interior amenities. Gross wt is 1750.

Performance. Not very impressive.

Eggenfellner lists the 4 cyl NA package as $17,995. They directly
support the RV 6,7,9 and Glastar among "many others."

>> The finished weight of your RV9A,
>
> 1190 lbs, including full IFR stack, BMA EFIS, in-flight
> entertainment,
> extensive upholstery, cherry wood trim, excellent cabin heat,
> autopilot,
> dual batteries, fully redundant fuel and electrical systems, and of
> course
> an outstanding powerplant.
>
> Typical 4-cyl (non-supercharged) cruise is 165/170mph at approx
> 7.5gph
> mogas.  I've also posted miles per gallon and cost per mile and hour
> to
> illustrate real world economy. [on EGG website
http://www.eggenfellneraircraft.com/]
>
> Fastest 4-way GPS for my own bird is 186mph at 7500'.
>
> No it won't hit VNE, because we have yet to figure out how to defeat
> the
> laws of physics (we're working on it).  Dragging radiators through
> the air
> will always come with a penalty, but all things considered, the
> tradeoff is
> well worth it.  Read through the web site and you'll see things in a
> different, real world, light.
>

He talks about the smoothness - lack of vibration and shake.

>There are far
> more
> factors to compare than performance alone.  Take a ride in one and
> you'll
> see that very clearly.  This is why our pilots love them.

Cost:
>Total
> cost of
> ownership cannot be beat.

Vibration and shake:
>> if you were to bolt your prop directly to the crank of your EGG and
>> run
> it a
>> prop RPM (vs. 3,4 or 5K RPM) then you'd see IPS number closer in
>> line
> with Lyco
>
> Not true at all.  The Subaru has 7 main bearings on an 18"
> crankshaft and
> has no significant counterweights because of its symmetrical design.
> It is
> extraordinarily well balanced.  Also fact, our redrive contributes
> more
> vibration (not the other way around as you suggest).  It has a
> floating
> countershaft and four helical gears.  These show up very clearly on
> a
> spectrograph.  But even with the engine running at twice the
> crankshaft RPM
> as a conventional aircraft engine, we have achieved a very low level
> of
> vibration, not to mention quiet.  It's hard to hang a price tag on
> the
> value of quiet...
>
>> conversely if we put a re-drive on a Lyco it would go way down to.
>
> No, the added gears, shafts, and bearings all contribute their own
> vibration signature.
>

He promotes the sube by giving rides.

> Nothing pleases me more than giving the unknowing a ride in my
> plane.  That
> always does the trick.  With over 800 customers and as the second
> largest
> supplier of engines for RV's, it's only a matter of time before more
> people
> break away from the myths.  We are lining up a Subaru fly-by for
> Oshkosh
> 2007.  We've got around 40 customers so far.  Should be fun.

Doc Custer
Retired software engineer and sometime Audiologist
Building RV9-A. Fuselage


------------------------------------------

All one need do is go to a few air shows and count
the Subes. I go to several big ones each year.
Sun n Fun, OSH, Arlington and Copper. If 800 were sold where are they?
I could never find more than 3...  mostly in Eggenfellners booth
while there are at least a hundred Lyc powered RV's at OSH. We
had seven rotary powered aircraft at OSH the year before last.
Typical five or more  rotaries show up at Sun n Fun.

We shall see how many show up at OSH in 2007.

Tracy burns about the same amount of fuel at 165 MPH but goes
217 MPH top speed in the Sun 100 race normally aspirated at
500 feet AGL (Florida).


Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.