Subject: New Questair style motor mount.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/29/2006, 7:25 PM
To: AA-me



This is for those people that want to save a couple hundred
on a custom oil pan and use a stock oil pan. This is near
identical to the way the Questair bed mount is done for the
air cooled Cont. IO-550 AC engine. This bolt pattern is for an
RX8 engine but the same idea is used for a 2nd gen or 3rd gen
engine.

What does everybody think of this? In particular what
do you think Jerry? Does it add so much to the cost that
a custom aluminum oil pan is still worth while?

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,
Yes!  I like this one!  This is much better than structural supports
attached to the oil pan.  This is a big move toward
standardization.  I
have two possible suggestions:
1)  IF, the side channel material is not available as off the shelf
4130
channel, use 3/4 x 1.5 tubing counterbored on the bottom side and use
Torx flange head bolts.

2)  Make a standard variation of  it with the rear beam extended a few
inches on each side for a four point mount.  This would be useful for
those who can't make a hard point on the firewall.

Make it three suggestions:

3)  Could possibly use off-the-shelf rectangular tubing for the main
beam also.

Let's try to standardize this basic configuration into as few
variations
as possible so Jerry (or someone) can manufacture them as readily
available items.  We need to get away from custom fitting everything.

This now gives us a standard structural part for attaching
radiators, etc.

Aubrey

Metric 6 mm socket head screws are much cheaper and you can
get ball end hex screw drivers. Makes it much easier
to screw them inside the Schertz beam.

It is easier and better to make a hard point on the
firewall. A four point tubing mount would be more expensive,
over kill and be in the redundant constraint category.
It takes FEA to analyze them. Goes against my engineering
sensibilities :) Not elegant.

The advantage of the ball joint rear is the down thrust
can be easily adjusted for max speed or max MPG at cruise.

The rectangular tubing is more expensive and heavier and not high
enough at only 1.5 inches. I considered it. It needs to be two
inches deep to properly support the Schertz beam. The 4130 sheet
thickness required here is only .049" thick. The flange width
shown is only .625" wide.

Most RX8 are going to need a custom oil pan anyway as the stock
oil pan has real breathing problems and we all could use
more quarts to delay oil heating on take off.

This is primarily intended as a money saving option for those
cheap skates out there :) I am not sure if it would really
be any cheaper.

Paul Lamar

Aubrey,  From my perspective their is nothing less custom about this
arrangement when compared with the oil pans.   It still has to be
built by someone one at a time. I don't think it will be easier,
cheaper, or more structurally sound than the oil pans. But I have no
objection to making it,    Jerry


Paul,

In the oil pan mount designs such as the S-bean and this new style are the
oil pan bolts subject to pure tension or are any of them  experiencing a
shear force at all?

Doug Fir

In normal use they see no tension or compression other
than that due to tightening torque. The engine sits on
the beam. G forces in a turn are straight down.
There is a small shear force due to thrust.
At a 600 pounds of thrust (absolutely worst case)
the shear load is 100 pounds on each of six bolts.
600 pounds at 200 FPS (136 MPH) is 218 net thrust HP.
Engine HP would be about 275 HP. Prop eff. 80%.
Below that speed the prop loses thrust due to
the prop efficiency dropping off. Above that speed
thrust  drops off steadily due to fixed amount of HP.
HP is thrust times speed. Thrust must go down as speed
goes up.

A pan bolt is 6 mm that is .236 inches in diameter.
Area is .0139 square inches times 60,000 psi or
835 pounds per bolt in shear or tension in theory.
Six 6 mm bolts (.236" dia.) will take 5,000 pounds in shear
in theory at a stress level of 60,000 psi.
Those are cheap bolts. Grade 8 bolts are over 100,000 psi.
Now Butch tells me you must derate these numbers for
single shear so lets say they are only half that or 2,500
pounds shear total or 417 pounds per bolt.

Now if you pull six G's inverted the bolts will see about
1800 pounds total or 300 pounds per bolt in tension
assuming the engine prop and gear box weigh 300 pounds.
Your seat belts better be tight as you will also weigh
about 1200 pounds.

Check my arithmetic. In an earlier message on a similar subject
I made mistakes. Nobody caught it so far. Also get the book and
check my physics reasoning :)

BTW much of a bolted joints resistance to shear is the friction
force between the two parts clamped together. Bolted
joints are a whole engineering discipline in and of itself.
The above analysis ignores this contribution.

Way back in the old days of car racing we did this kind of
reasoning and we found out we were using bolts that were too big.
If you used the right size bolts the mechanics would invariable
torque them off.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.