Subject: Aluminum wing as a heat exchanger
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/3/2006, 8:48 PM
To: AA-me


        Paul
        I am building a Bear Hawk which has a aluminum wing.
        I was thinking if you attached .375 O.D. .250 I.D. tubing to
   the under
        side of the wing skin running from the front spar to the rear spar
        and coupled the .375 O.D. to a 1" I.D. tubing running parallel
   with the
        front and rear spar to make a large heat sink and let the
   aluminum wing
        radiate the heat. How hot do you think a wing would get? The
   Bear Hawk
        has 222 sq ft. of wing area. I figure it would require 16 .375 O.D.
        tubes, 30 inches long (8 for the upper skin and 8 for the lower
   skin)
        for each wing. The heat exchanger would weigh 17.25# if it were
   made
        from "M" cooper tubing for each wing. Plus a little over 1.6 gal of
        coolant per wing. If the wing didn't get to hot and cause
   problems from
        expansion, and heating the fuel takes, the cooling drag could
   be reduced
        considerable.
        Just an idea and thought I would throw it out to see what every one
        thinks of the idea.
        Would the boundary layer prevent any significant cooling?

        Here is how you can compare. Calculate the surface area of
        radiator exposed to the air and the surface area exposed to the
        coolant. That will give you a rough idea if a skin surface radiator
        will work. The Schneider cup people did this surface rad trick in
        1930 and had a lot of trouble. Also Lockheed tried it
        with the P38 for the inter coolers and also gave up
        and went to a conventional inter coolers.
        -- Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

        Paul,
        Peter Garrison did an article on exactly this idea with the
   calculations
        of available surface area etc...
        His conclusion was that it won't work. If you have a laminar flow
        airfoil also, things just get worse due to boundary layer
   effects. It
        always seems like this might work though, too bad. A real plumbing
        nightmare though.
        Bill Jepson

   ------------------------------------------------------------------------
   I'm sure that if it could be made to work, someone, somewhere would
   have
   done it successfully by now. I always wondered if the exhaust heat could
   be used to de-ice the wings-2/3 of the heat energy of the rotary goes
   out the exhaust. Wouldn't you just need to get the wings over 33
   degrees
   to de-ice them? Just wondering, I've got no intention of  ever flying in
   ice on purpose.

   Brian Trubee




I was thinking on the same lines Brian, If it would work It would reduce
the cooling drag, give us more room under the cowl, and the heat on the
wings would be an advantage in cold weather. The large mass of the wing
would take time to warm up, So extended taxi time and  climb out time
may not be a problem. I may setup a 1/10 scale model of a wing and test it
Ed Pogue
Bear Hawk 648


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.