Tim, let me be brutally frank with you. You are going to kill
yourself! George Lucas is NOT an aircraft designer.
Hollywood is NOT Boeing. Please pick another type of engine
to do it with. I want nothing to do with this project.
Paul Lamar
Good call Paul. You can see the headlines...
LA based father of three dies in fatal crash of Wankkel power
experimental
aeroplane.
Eye witnesses reported a strange engine noise and then a fire ball
as the
experimental aircraft smashed into the set of Lucas films Star
wars. The
NTSB reports that the center of gravity shift caused by a the slide
throttle
being pushed to the open position caused the home made experimental
aircraft
to pitch down uncontrollably. No wreckage of the plane, other than
the
destroyed wankel engine, was ever recovered, but the resulting fire
consumed
an movie prop (a wooden mock up of the films X wing space fighter).
The Builder Tim's family were shattered by their loss, and have
moved into
a carboard condo on the east side, after failing to make payments
on the
house following the death of the breadwinner.
Tim, getting a model X wing to launch as a rocket is simple thrust
(but way
cool) .You getting a model X plane to fly is a real achievement,
and even
cooler. Getting killed by an instable hombuilt with an approach
speed over
130 MPH is just plain dumb, and stuffs up things for everyone. Even
if you
ever get this thing to fly without your termination, it is going to
scare
you shitless, so you put it in a museum and wonder if you might not
have
been better off with a practical plane you can enjoy for years.
How about moving from scale to semi scale. Maybe the facetted
cockpit and
R2d2 on a varieze.
Mark W
Everyone,
Owch! OK at this phase of his project it is evident Tim is going to
run
into some serious design problems and cooling is the least of them.
Flying
with dubious pitch control will be the most serious one. If that is
worked
and the hollow ribless wings don't deform in flight then I agree
with Matt
and suggest some small jet engines. Start with 'Jet Beetle' for
information
links. Forget about fooling around with auto engines, PSRU and
props. If
this is just a "Can it be done Project?" then a 1/2 scale or full
scale
plane can be made and flown by remote control over an uninhabited
area.
Crazier things have been made and succeeded. Look at "Monster
Garage" TV
show. Actually don't. It is a total waste of resources for mindless
entertainment:)
Perhaps the aerodynamics of the X wing might surprise everyone and
we will
all learn something that Bonanza designers didn't. Forget about
where the
idea originated from. Where do any ideas come from?. Buck Rogers was
zooming
around space using laser guns years before they showed up in the
REAL
world. One design point puzzles me though:) Wasn't R2D2 smart
enough to
fold Luke's X-wings into common dual wings when it entered a
planet's
atmosphere?
Doug Fir
You have a point Doug.
I always wondered why a space ship had wings at all. What good are
wings in a near vacuum? Maybe to hold roll and yaw reaction motors?
Etc., etc. Clearly Lucas is in the entertainment business, not some
engineering discipline. Looks good though.
Doc Custer
Retired software engineer and sometime Audiologist
Building RV9-A. Fuselage
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.