Subject: The dreaded Mr. M and patent infringement
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/9/2006, 11:48 PM
To: AA-me


>   Paul,
>   While I don't follow it, a friend sent me Moller's
> latest letter to
> stockholders or presidents letter...whatever.
> Well schzam, it appears that Moller has decided that
> he'll use the
> latest catch item ethanol fuel. All this isn't any
> different from the
> usual B.S. The interesting item is Moller's claim
> that he plans to use
> compounding to improve the mileage of the roto-power
> engines! (patent
> pending of course) Seems to me that his spies have
> been watching the
> ACRE newsletter. (as usual)
> Bill Jepson
>
> I know who they are and yes they are on here. Paul M
> himself
> was on here for awhile. The patent won't hold up in
> court even
> if the patent office is dumb enough to grant it as
> turbo
> compounding the rotary has been on the ACRE web site
> in one form or another from the get go for the last
> few years
> not to mention a few NASA tech papers on the
> subject.
> I also discussed  it 30 years ago with David E. Cole
> now Chairman
> of the Center for Automotive Research U of Mich. and
> Don Sherman
> was present.
>
> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

  paul,

You are right about the basic idea of a turbo compound
rotary long being in the "prior art" and thus being
un patentable. patent # 4,742,683 by Teledyne covered a
diesel cycle or stratified charge turbo compound
rotary, it is already expired (Filed:August 18,
1986). Of course if you peruse the patents long enough
you find plenty of dubious "improvements" of various
"prior art" which have been patented. so in fact I'm
sure Moller may be able to get some sort of patent
claiming an improvement, say "an exhaust tube length of
1.678 times the diameter of the turbine inlet feeding
the compound turbine to improve resonant frequency"
ha ha. anyway, that's the sort of thing you see in
modern patents all the time, which in effect have no
practical enforcement.

I really enjoy researching patents from the 60's and
70's but the closer you get to modern times the less
they seem to offer any real innovation. Of course the
basis of patent ability is novelty and obviousness to
someone skilled in the art, 95% of these modern
patents hardly seem to me to meet either
qualification. and I'm just an amateur engineer, i
studied financial economics in school, I can only
imagine that a real engineer reads these modern
patents and thinks they are very obvious (and
un patentable)

gary

Hey thanks for finding that Gary. That is REALLY
interesting.

Paul Lamar



The game is to make the price of the license less than fighting the
patent. It's discusting. -Jeff

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.