This has been going on for fifteen or twenty years
Gordon.
He keeps saying next year something is going to happen
and something never does. We were going to have small
light weight powerful rotary engines three or four
years ago.
Did not happen. In the past seven years there have
been several broken promises. We have emails and
magazine
articles to prove it. We also have email from a very
good
engineer that is an ex employee.
You would think after all this time the Skycar would
have
flown with a person out of ground effect. It is not
that
hard to do given computer control, HP and weight
claims. It has
not happened. The reason it keeps going on is the
public has a
short memory and shorter attention span. Why do you
think Bede
is still around after defrauding so many people on the
BD5? As
charlatan this guy makes Bede look incompetent.
The experimental aircraft market is the happy hunting
grounds of scam artist. A couple of years ago we
were going to have this low cost 200 HP turbo prop
engine
that burned only 10 gallons an hour. It disappeared.
When people desperately want to believe in something
they usually do. The more radical the idea the more
they
want to believe in it. The logic and reason part of
the brain
disconnects. Further data input is futile. Communism
and
radical Islam are good examples. Who doesn't want 70
virgins. (Only a one month supply for me in my youth
:))
I digress.
The guy is insincere to the core. It is
all about selling stock because stock holders have
no legal recourse. If you sue... the company declares
bankruptcy and the principles walk away. SEC has
already
found him in violation. He sold more stock and payed
the fine.
He also started another company called Freedom Motors
that failed to deliver promised rotary engines.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
paul,gordon
here is the sec's press realease:
http://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases/lr17987.htm
and the original complaint:
http://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/comp17987.htm
a couple of interesting points from the complaint:
13. As of late 2002, MI's approximately 40 years' of
development has resulted in a prototype Skycar capable
of hovering about fifteen feet above the ground.
20. For example, the Skycar, according to Moller,
would allow any person to travel at speeds over 400
miles-per-hour in the uncluttered airspace above the
roadways for about the same price as a luxury
automobile. In MI investor newsletters, Moller
projected that 10,000 Skycars would be sold by the end
of 2002.
21. In reality, the Skycar was and still is a very
early developmental-stage prototype that has no
meaningful flight testing, proof of aeronautical
feasibility, or proven commercial viability.
28. Moller also misled investors with statements
suggesting that MI owned valuable intellectual
property and patents related to the purportedly
cutting-edge Skycar technology. In solicitation
materials and communications with investors, Moller
routinely misrepresented MI's patent holdings,
claiming that the company "held" 11 domestic patents.
He also falsely claimed that these patents were
valuable, and justified an expectation of an increased
share price for MI's stock.
29. As late as May 2002, in MI's initial Form 10-SB
filing, the company again falsely claimed that it
owned 11 domestic patents.
30. In fact, eight of those eleven patents were
expired patents in which MI had no ownership interest.
For the remaining three patents, MI has ultimately
acknowledged they have no value.
gary
Gary, Paul:
Thanks for the info. I understand that this project has been going on
for some time and there have been optimistic projections that inevitably
failed to materialize. But this really is not unusual for any kind of
scientific or technological development.
You could say the same thing about medical research and their failure to
find a cure for cancer after all this time and many promises. But what's
the point? The truth is that big technolgical breakthroughs take a lot
of effort and much more time than we think.
Okay, Moller has promised rotary engines for sale for a few years now
and the delivery date keeps slipping. That can also mean that he doesn't
want to release a product before it is ready.
As far the SEC comnplaint is concerned, anyone can make a complaint
about a publicly traded company -- and thousands have. Every major
public company has a long list of complaints. A lot of these complaints
are generated by stock manipulators and short sellers who want to hurt
the stock price and then profit from the decline. That doesn't mean
there is anything to those complaints. The regulators presumably look
into them and if there is something there, the company is sanctioned. I
may not have all the info, but I'm not aware that Moller has been
sanctioned for any serious violations.
And what about the performance of the Skycar prototype? Come on, I think
it's pretty impressive that the thing has even gotten off the ground.
Look at some defense projects that eat up billions of dollars and don't
even get that far. Another issue is that FAA rules prohibit the Skycar
from even flying without a tether at this point. This thing doesn't fit
any template in the cookie-cutter bureaucracy and that is holding things
up. Lots of people who build their own airplane know this feeling -- you
can't fly until the feds say so.
But really, I'm not interested in passing judgement one way or the
other. I will just say that Moller does not strike me as some sort of
flim-flam man. He has been a successful innovator and entrepreneur for
decades. And say what you will about the Skycar, but it is a visionary
concept. I would bet that eventually it will fly -- and could end up
revolutionizing personal transportation.
I emailed the company yesterday seeking some technical info on the
engines and ducted fans and got a prompt reply this morning from the
general manager. He included a nice technical paper on the skycar, which
I have attached.
Regards,
Gordon.
You don't know him like I know him.
Not that difficult of a problem. Almost off the shelf
auto pilots would work. If he was serious it would have
flown 20 years ago. There is no such FAA requirements of tethers
on experimental aircraft in the US. Check out the very similar
X prize.
http://www.xprizecup.com/#
http://www.xprize.org/
The pdf is too big to publish. I won't give him the PR anyway.
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Scam or not Gordon I don't see how this is going to revolutionize flying. By
their own claims they have a machine so woefully under powered that the risk
of failure of one of eight engines, even in ground effect, does not warrant
the risking of a test pilots life.
The FAA is not holding them up, they claim that the FAA rules do not apply
to them as they are tethered.
Once certified who could afford to buy one let alone maintain one ? Eight
certified engines to buy and maintain regularly. What aircraft engineer is
going to want to work on them with all their unique engines and systems (try
finding a guy for a certified Rotax). It would be cheaper to have a turbine
helicopter.
They forecast 6000' per minute climb rates and 400 mph cruise speeds, cool
but those are huge numbers that no one else can match and again who could
afford the fuel for that ?
I really don't see how this all adds up to reality.
John
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.