>
> You don't know him like I know him.
> Not that difficult of a problem. Almost off the shelf
> auto pilots would work. If he was serious it would have
> flown 20 years ago. There is no such FAA requirements of tethers
> on experimental aircraft in the US. Check out the very similar
> X prize.
>
> http://www.xprizecup.com/#
> http://www.xprize.org/
>
> The pdf is too big to publish. I won't give him the PR anyway.
>
> --
> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Scam or not Gordon I don't see how this is going to revolutionize flying.
By
their own claims they have a machine so woefully under powered that the
risk
of failure of one of eight engines, even in ground effect, does not
warrant
the risking of a test pilots life.
The FAA is not holding them up, they claim that the FAA rules do not apply
to them as they are tethered.
Once certified who could afford to buy one let alone maintain one ? Eight
certified engines to buy and maintain regularly. What aircraft engineer is
going to want to work on them with all their unique engines and systems
(try
finding a guy for a certified Rotax). It would be cheaper to have a
turbine
helicopter.
They forecast 6000' per minute climb rates and 400 mph cruise speeds, cool
but those are huge numbers that no one else can match and again who could
afford the fuel for that ?
I really don't see how this all adds up to reality.
John
John,
Those are all valid points.
Who knows, you guys may be right and Moller may be just another circus
barker with nothing but tricks up his sleeve. On the other hand...there
was no shortage of naysyaers about the Wrights and Langley and Curtiss
and Lilienthal and Dumont and all the rest of the early innovators too.
I'd rather be an optimist when it comes to progress. I hope the Skycar
succeeds. Heck, I would love to have one. You could park the thing in
your garage, drive to your nearby helipad (local hospital) and take off
vertically. Heck for us farm lads, we could just take off from our back
yard. I'd call that pretty revolutionary.
As far as the Skycar being underpowered, I think that is mostly a
challenge in the vertical takeoff phase. A conventional light plane
would have no problem getting off the ground and climbing smartly with
even a fraction of the thrust those four ducted fans are producing.
And that's the real attraction for me. I think the idea of
rotary-powered ducted fans for personal planes has real promise. I'd
love to see a Cirrus-size plane that's rotary-fan powered. Given some
basic development, I believe this could prove more effective and
efficient than small turbines.
But nobody is working on this except Moller. Everybody is content to
just keep flying behind the old lousy piston engine, which is both heavy
and unreliable. So just on that basis alone, I say more power to the guy.
Regards,
Gordon.
They are working on it! It is called the V22 Osprey.
The reason nobody is working on a similar ducted fan design is:
it is not going to work!
There are no analogies with the Wright brothers because
the Wright brothers understood the Newtonian physics involved.
Paul Moller understands the physics but he is counting
on the fact that few other people do. If this was possible
the military would be all over it like a cheap suit.
This has all be discussed on here at length and ad nauseous.
The show stopper is the noise in your back yard.
Paul Lamar
In the 1950's, many of the first world countries spent huge sums on
developing VTOL test vehicles. These efforts included a number of ducted
fan powered lift systems. Having surveyed them for about 25 years, I have
to throw a little cold water on the proceedings and say there is no free
lunch in VTOL.
The Moller efforts have evolved slowly over the years. From
time to time he seems to have hired competent consultants, but the bottom
line is that even if his vehicle flys, it is physically impossible for it to
meet the advertised performance specifications.
Take fuel consumption.
Lets be optimistic and put his consumption at .5 lbs/hp hr. The
thrust/horsepower for VTOL and transition will be 3-4 times the horsepower
requirement for forward flight. But it is this VTOL component that is the
selling point. He has 8 engines because of engine out conditions.
At some
point, someone must have suggested a turbine twin-pack and gear boxes and
shafts. Too complex and heavy you say. It is any heavier than the extra
engines at about 150 lbs (his numbers) per engine? Where are you going to
store the fuel and what is the vehicles capacity? The aerodynamics of the
vehicle in forward flight (especially the critical transition period) are an
issue.
I suspect it is possible to make the thing fly and that it could
have been done long ago. But it would have very limited endurance and the
need for man-rated safety alone makes the costs astronomical. If they
really thought they had something, they would have developed a drone
version. And if anyone (like DARPA) thought they had something they would
have funded it out of a black bag. Remember that Moller has experience in
drones with the Aerobot series.
As for safe testing - we have this place
called Edwards with plenty of room. For a long time I've suspected that the
Skycar project was nursed along to raise funds to put into the Wankel engine
program. This is not a dumb idea if you have a worthwhile engine. I don't
know how much money has been raised over the years for the Skycar. I've
never seen an audit report on where the money went, but I do know from
personal experience that projects that are chronically underfunded and don't
show results are inefficient projects because the overheads keep going and
going and going like the energizer bunny. You end up with funds supporting
the company structure with minimum return in development. You don't have to
be criminal to be unrealistic. But the results are the same.
George Wright
I might mention that George co wrote a book on ducted fans.
Is the book still available George?
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.