Our British cousins have a saying, "horses for courses". There is a
common misconception that piston or rotary driven ducted fans are a cheap
alternative to turbo-fans or turbo-jets. They are not and aviation
history is littered with projects that reinforce this fact. On the other
hand, they do have their uses, particularly in agricultural aircraft. Had
Dowty not withdrawn from the market, we might have quite a number of very
efficient utility aircraft operating in speeds of 0-150 mph. One of the
points that is often missed is that a properly designed ducted fan could
be the basis for a really fun series of slower sport planes with the
appearance of jets, the advantage of great low speed thrust (take-offs and
landings), relatively low noise level (but only if designed properly) and
enhanced ground safety.
I actually did a pretty in depth cut at a wooden semi-scale Panther a la
5151 mustang, et al. It's quite possible to build a decent little plane
and be the first boy on your block to pretend to have a jet. As long as
you're willing to settle for putzing around the airport and don't demand
cross-country efficiency. Up to about 400 mph you can't beat a decently
designed prop job.
George W
A friend built a dandy sportplane with a ducted fan. 'Course, he's an
aerodynamicist for Raytheon Aircraft. He knows this stuff. Darned good
Engineer all around.
Jet-like, yes.
Nice performer, yup.
Still around? Nope.
Ducted fans have a HORRIBLE power-out condition. It's like having an
umbrella or dragchute thrown out. Funny thing about sportplanes, sooner
or later you have a power-out situation. Then alla sudden, that ducted
fan is not your friend and you WISH you had a prop.
If you can deadstick an F-4 fighter, you could probably deadstick a
ducted fan sportplane. Anything less need not apply ;-)
Larry Schurr
Your point is well taken and is the reason that RFB went with a short-chord
shrouded fan versus a ducted propeller. You can get several different
definitions of the difference between the two types. Some base it on
pressure ratio, some on swept area of rotor blades versus duct cross
section.
The RFB designs had a relatively small blade area versus cross
sectional area. They also went with a variable pitch rotor that could be
feathered. The primary drags in an engine out condition were shroud and
interference drags. Dowty Rotol went to a much higher solidity rotor design
and was forced to make it fully feathering for just the reason you've noted.
They tested it full-scale on a modified Islander with twin Ducted
Propulsors. Both the Germans and Japanese investigated inlet doors that
could be deployed in an engine out condition. In the Japanese example, they
designed a self-launching motor-glider with a buried ducted fan and had to
close the inlets for obvious reasons. The Germans looked at twin engines
running a single rotor with the idea that they should always have at least
50% power and flow through the rotor. This works as long as the problem
isn't fuel contamination or exhaustion.
One of the reasons I looked at the
Panther sport plane concept was the relatively thick central body of the
fuselage. I wanted to run a tractor ducted installation for several reasons
including cooling and a modest thrust increase from an ejector. This layout
also allowed a slightly larger diameter rotor. I elected to investigate 3-
and 5-bladed versions with a relatively low solidity.
In an engine out
condition with this bird, there were a lot of internal drag losses from the
ducting. The mitigating factor was a pretty large wing and low wing loading
(10 lbs/sq.ft.). For a 0-130 mph aircraft it seemed do-able. I've seen
some designs where I'm convinced they would glide like a rock. The really
interesting stability/control/drag interactions come into play when you
attempt to integrate the area of the duct into the stabilizing surface area
of the aircraft.
Under power, you can get some amazing vectored thrust
effects. Engine out, you can end up with marginal surface areas. Raspet,
Jim Miller and Jim Bede all tried this out with full-flight articles. The
results were mixed. I know of at least one well-known designer who
abandoned a really promising agri/utility design because of such effects.
George W.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.