Subject: Ducted fan airplanes
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/20/2006, 8:55 AM
To: AA-me


    >     George,
    >
    >     I love the idea of a "pretend-jet" as you put it, but not for the
    >     boy-wow factor -- I actually think there could be a way to
   make such
    > an
    >     airplane work quite well -- even for bigger-than-sport plane
   size.
    >
    >     Here's my idea. Please feel free to poke holes in it: (Paul I
   know you
    >     don't need an invitation to fire away).
    >
    >     An airplane like the Diamond D-jet or Excel Sport jet weights
   about
    > 5000
    >     pounds gross, will go about 350 mph at 25,000 feet, stall at
   not much
    >     more than a high-performance piston single and have a range
   of about
    >     1000 miles, roughly.
    >
    >     These planes, although not yet certified, are a very exciting
    >     development. I've seen the D-jet take off and climb out and it is
    >     actually much quieter than a Cirrus, displaying the kind
   civilized,
    >     confident deportment that only a jet plane can. Flying in one
   would be
    >     very very comfortable, I'm sure -- what without the piston
   vibration,
    >     prop blast against the windshield, etc. After seeing this
   baby at a
    >     local field, I thought, "man, this is a nice way to fly." And
   that
    >     "whoosh" sound...who could go back to propellers?
    >
    >     Call me crazy, but I think that there exists the potential to
   make
    > this
    >     concept even better using rotary power and a ducted fan. Or
   at least
    > as
    >     good, but much less expensive.
    >
    >     Now I'm not talking about the big ducts that we see on ducted
   fan
    > small
    >     planes, like that Optica or even Perry Mick's Long-EZ, or
   that nice
    >     little Legati triangular wing job. I'm talking about a 24-inch
    > diameter
    >     duct at most, contained within the fuselage, as in the D-Jet
   and Sport
    >     jet, and with two intake scoops on the sides.
    >
    >     The problem with the big ducts is not just the added drag of
   the extra
    >     wetted area, but also that these huge surfaces can act like a
   big sail
    >     and cause stability problems and all kinds of aerodynamic grief.
    >
    >     George mentioned the misconception that rotary or piston
   engines can
    >     drive a duct as good as a turbine. This is indeed a
   misconception
    >     because, generally this is an impossible dream. For one thing, a
    > rotary
    >     or piston engine is much bigger in diameter than a turbine,
   which can
    > be
    >     quite a small round cylinder making a huge amount of power
   for its
    >     size.
    >
    >     This is important because you have the engine in the center
   of the
    > duct
    >     and if your engine is big around the middle, you have to have
   a big
    >     duct. You also have a lot of blockage to the air stream in the
    >     middle of
    >     the duct where the engine is sitting. Of course the engine is
    >     streamlined with a fairing, but even so that fairing adds
   quite a bit
    > of
    >     wetted area against which the high-speed air stream has to work.
    >
    >     My idea is eliminate the engine in the middle of the duct. In
   fact the
    >     engine will not be in the duct at all. The duct would be
   incorporated
    >     into the fuselage as on the D-jet and Sport jet, as
   mentioned. But the
    >     rotary engine would be sitting ahead of the duct, inside the
   fuselage
    >     proper. A short drive shaft would poke from this engine
   compartment
    > into
    >     the center of the duct and drive the single-stage fan.
    >
    >     All you would have inside this duct is the fan itself. There
   would be
    > no
    >     blockage whatsoever. In this regard, it is even better than a
    > turbofan.
    >     You would not have any of the drag of the air stream against the
    > engine
    >     fairing. And since the air stream is moving quite fast, this
   drag is
    > not
    >     insignificant, even with the small diameter of a turbine engine.
    >
    >     Also, since the duct is completely within the fuselage you
   have no
    >     additional outside wetted area, no sail effect, no
   aerodynamic issues
    > of
    >     any kind.
    >
    >     So what about efficiency? I think it could be quite good, even
    > compared
    >     to a propeller plane. Don't forget that with a prop plane you
   have the
    >     high-speed prop slipstream causing friction against the
   surface of the
    >     plane. This causes higher drag than the parasite drag from the
    >     undisturbed air, because the prop slipstream air is moving much
    > faster.
    >     This also causes some aerodynamic issues, such as the
   left-turning
    >     tendency from the prop slipstream pushing against the rudder,
   etc.
    >
    >     A 24 -inch fan would result in a fan speed of about mach .75
   at 7500
    >     engine rpm, direct drive. If you wanted to use a higher rpm
   P-ported
    >     engine, you could move the rpm range up a bit and use an even
   smaller
    >     fan diameter. This small diameter duct would present a
   relatively
    > small
    >     wetted area inside the duct and would decrease friction drag
   and help
    >     efficiency. And with no engine in the duct -- and no blockage of
    > airflow
    >     -- efficiency would also be improved considerably. In fact,
   if you
    >     wanted to use an even smaller duct and a higher speed jet
   effect, you
    >     could gear up the engine to turn the fan faster than engine
   speed.
    >
    >     Ideally, the engine would be turbo compounded for great
   specific fuel
    >     consumption, as well as maintaining high power at altitude.
   This is in
    >     fact something that even turbines can't do -- their power
   drops with
    >     altitude.
    >
    >     The fuel load would therefore be considerably smaller as a
   ratio of
    >     total airplane weight. The 5000 pound jets we're talking
   about here
    >     carry about one third of that weight as fuel (1700 pounds or
   so). A
    >     turbo compound rotary with a SFC of under .4 could do the
   same on
    > little
    >     more than half the fuel, assuming equal power. You could count on
    >     saving
    >     at least 700 to 800 pounds of fuel weight.
    >
    >     Yes the engine will be a little heavier, but maybe 200 pounds
   at most.
    >     The 1300 pound thrust Williams FJ33 in the D-jet weighs 300
   pounds.
    > You
    >     could probably build a very powerful 3-rotor engine for under 500
    >     pounds
    >     I'm sure -- less if aluminum castings are available. So you
   would
    > still
    >     be able to have a gross weight 500 pounds lighter.
    >
    >     There is no reason why you could not scale this idea down to
   say a
    >     four-seater with a smaller engine, or even a two-seater with a
    > 2-rotor.
    >
    >     Regards,
    >
    >     Gordon.
    >
    >     This idea has some merit.
    >
    >     The 1300 pound thrust at sea level Williams engine is probably
    >     developing one third of that at 30,000 feet or about 430 pounds.
    >     TSFC (pounds burned per pound of thrust) for a small turbo fan
    >     might be as low as 1.3 at this altitude so fuel burn would be
    >     about 560 pounds an hour or 93 gallons
    >     an hour. With 1120 pounds of fuel or 186 gallons on board
    >     range at 450 MPH would be 900 miles. 4.8 MPG.  Every year
    >     at OSH I would stop by the Williams booth and ask about
    >     the TSFC every year they would not tell me :)
    >
    >     At 400 MPH or 586 FPS that would be  459 equivalent thrust HP.
    >     At 450 MPH if it will go that fast 660 FPS or about Mach .5 In
    >     that case the  equivalent thrust HP would be 516 HP net.
    >
    >     Rotary engine power required with a .6 eff. duct would be 860
   HP.
    >     Fuel burn at .4 BSFC (TC) would be 344 pounds per hour or 57
   gallons
    >     an hour or 8 MPG. Range would be about 900 miles with 120
   gallons.
    >
    >     Cooling required would be a major design effort. Some of the
    >     boost pressure would be diverted to pressurize the
    >     cabin.
    >
    >     Its been done and I will upload some pictures shortly.
    >
    >
    >     Paul Lamar
    >
    > I don't think we are at the peak of propeller design efficiency
   yet.  If
    > you have heard a dash8 400Q flying, you know that they have more
   going
    > on with their prop designs than what we get on direct drive LyCont
    > engines.  Since the rotary really needs a gear reduction unit
   anyway, we
    > have flexibility in choosing a prop RPM that's much quieter.  The
    > airframe obviously needs room to have a large diameter prop..
    >
    >
    > Regards,
    >
    > Matt-
    >
    > That is why the turbo prop verses biz jet argument is still
    > going on. Piaggio Avanti in particular is at the forefront of that
    > argument.
    >
    > http://www.artdisk.it/proposta_piaggio/htm/piaggioaero.htm
   <http://www.artdisk.it/proposta_piaggio/htm/piaggioaero.htm>
    >
    > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

   Fuel consumption.  Hmmmmmm.  Is this a bad time to ask just what kind of
   fuel you intend to burn?  And whether it will be available at the
   airports
   you visit?  George W>



Hello George,

Not sure what you're getting at there.  Until somebody makes a rotary
run really well on something other than gasoline, that's the only
choice, as far as I am concerned.


Matt-



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.