Subject: Ducted fan airplanes
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/21/2006, 6:05 PM
To: AA-me



   I will play devils advocate here.

   I am basing my duct eff. on Kucheman and Webers book, Aerodynamics of
   Propulsion real data. Last chart.

   I got bad news for you Gordon. The smaller the duct dia. the worse
   the efficiency. That is the rational behind the high by pass turbo fan.
   Take a look at this thrust chart. Notice the high by pass turbo fan is
   more efficient
   through out the speed range than the pure jet. In fact the big debate
   now in air
   liner engine design is to use and even larger fan and gear it to save
   fuel. The core
   engines are still in the duct. Perry Mick's engine was largely out side
   the duct with
   a long e-shaft extension. See the gif.

   http://www.bridgingworlds.com/duckt.htm

   The most efficient propulsion system is to accelerate the largest
   mass of
   air possible only a little faster than the aircraft speed.

   Your assumption of the .7 TSFC of the Williams is unfounded and
   undocumented
   so far. The last chart is closer to the real world. Do you mean BSFC
   for the
   Williams based on equivalent thrust HP? Show us your source.

   One last thing. Most biz jets will fly at 40,000 feet no problem. Huge
   advantage when
   it comes to weather and MPG. The turbo compound rotary has years to go
   before it can fly at 30,000 feet.

   My having said all that does not mean nobody should try it. IMHO it
   is a
   real
   engineering challenge and beyond almost everyone except perhaps a large
   aero space
   firm. Now a days the big engine manufacturers are still making
   significant
   changes in turbo ducted fans due to the pressure to reduce air liner
   fuel consumption.

   It is close but so is the turbo prop. People like jets for different
   reasons.
   One is the smoothness. Two is the long TBO. Three is above the
   weather. Four
   is the status. If you have money to buy the biz jet the cost of fuel is
   inconsequential.

   Paul Lamar



   Gee Paul,



   You're going to play devil's advocate? What a switch.



   About the duct diameter, yes the smaller diameter is generally less
   efficient because of the reason you said: "The most efficient
   propulsion
   system is to accelerate the largest mass of
   air possible only a little faster than the aircraft speed."



   In order to achieve the same thrust with a smaller diameter, the
   airstream has to be moving faster. That's why a pure jet is least
   efficient, and a high bypass ratio turbofan is more efficient.



   However, look at the relative sizes here. A 24-inch fan is actually
   bigger than the small Williams engine. So compared purely to the
   Williams engine my 24-inch fan will be more efficient, especially since
   there is no engine inside the duct.



   Look at the nozzle exit diameter of bizjet engines. You have to be
   talking about a pretty big plane if you are talking 24 inches. These
   are
   engines that are producing thousands of pounds of thrust.



   So relatively speaking my 24 inch fan is actually more efficient than
   the high-bypass engines. The slipstream speed going through that duct
   will not be very much faster than the airplane airspeed. As a ratio, it
   will be a much lower than that of the bizjet engines.



   There is also a point where the wetted area starts coming into play and
   becomes the dominant factor -- moreso than the speed and diamter of the
   propulsion stream. Think of the small plane I am proposing with a 24
   inch fan and then scale that fan and duct up to a bizjet. The fans would
   have to be huge, maybe four or five feet in diameter. Imagine the size
   of those nacelles. It would be like hanging the nacelles from a 747 on a
   Citation. Such a thing could not even hope to fly simply because of the
   huge wetted area.



   So this question of efficiency is one of relative sizes. Yes, the jets
   are getting better efficiency by increasing the fan diameter, but this
   works only up to a point.



   With my 24-inch duct on that plane I am actually beyond that point and
   making the fan bigger will only make things worse. That's why I believe
   making the fan even smaller will actually be an improvement.



   Yes, I was talking about BSFC and equivalent horsepower on the Williams
   engine. I have no idea what this figure might be for the Williams
   engine, but I have heard the figure 0.69 thrown around as the state of
   thea art for high bypass engines.



   But talking about equivalent BSFC on jet engines is not really a good
   practice. It's much better to stick to TSFC for jets. I believe
   state of
   the art TFC for high bypass turbofans is around 0.5 TSFC at sea level.
   At 25,000 feet it would be about 1.25.



   And speaking of calculations, I just found another mistake in my last
   post. (Sorry about all the mistakes, I'm putting this stuff up there
   without really checking it...)



   In trying to figure out how much power a rotary would have to have in
   order to equal the perfromance of the Williams, I figured out the long
   range cruise thrust of 330 pounds.



   I mistakenly translated this figure directly into brake horsepower,
   rather than first calculating thrust horsepower.



   So, 330 pounds of thrust equals at 275 mph (240 knots) equals 240
   thrust
   horsepower. (Using the equation THP = thrust in pounds * speed in feet
   per second / 550.



   So now we can calculate how much brake horsepower we need to make
   240 THP.



   If we assume a fan efficiency of 75 percent, we get 322 brake
   horsepower.



   So if this is our 62 percent power long range cruise, our 100 percent
   takeoff power would be 520 horsepower.



   This is probably a bit more than you would want to push a 3-rotor
   engine, but 450 hp should be doable.



   This means that our fuel consumption figures also go down dramatically.
   Long range cruise at 62 percent power and 240 knots would give a fuel
   burn of 130 pounds of gasoline per hour, or 21 gph.



   This is spectacular. That means that with 150 gallons of fuel on board,
   our range would be considerably longer than the D-jet -- but with 800
   pounds less fuel weight.



   That lower weight means our 450 hp 3-rotor could give us a comparable
   power loading as the turbofan D-jet.



   You mentioned flying at higher altitudes. Yes this has advantages for
   weather flying and fuel efficiency, but that height is a whole'nother
   ball game for pilot training and capability. Flying at 25,000 feet is
   much more reasonable from a safety perspective for the average
   owner-pilot and a single-engine plane.



   Besides, the fuel efficiency of our rotary is so much better than a jet
   that it makes hardly any difference. Turbine engines have to fly high.
   Even turboprops burn a lot of gas below 10,000 feet. Our ratary fan on
   the other hand will fly as frugally as a piston single down low, while
   keeping up to the small single-engine jets at FL250.



   Sounds pretty good to me. Yes, I agree that if you have the money to
   buy
   a bizjet you have the money to buy gas for it. But we're talking here
   about personal use planes. Even if I could afford to buy a $1.5 million
   D-jet, I would still have to have a pretty big wallet to keep those
   tanks filled.



   If you can make a rotary fan plane that does eveything the D-jet does
   and does it just as smooth and civilized, and at half the price, you
   will really have something. And keeping it in fuel will not be much
   more
   than a turbocharged Columbia or Cirrus.



   And yes, I know the turbocompound rotary is not there yet, but a
   turbocharged rotary would be pretty close and that's pretty much
   there now.

   Regards,

   Gordon.


Jets are truly different animals from other forms of ic engine.  They
started out with horrible fuel efficiency at subsonic speeds.  That was
okay, because they only needed to be faster than the fastest prop driven
airplanes of all time - WWII fighters.  No strong need for fuel
efficiency.  Flyover noise was horrible.  Cockpit noise wasn't too bad
because the noisey part was behind and pointed away from the pilot.  And
the airframes/windshields were built like tanks.

As the desire for higher speed transportation (and longer tactical
range) developed, ways to improve jet fuel efficiency were sought.
More stages and tighter tolerance improved compression ratio - improving
the thermodynamics.  Adding a bypass stage was a way to effectively get
the efficiency closer to turboprop but save the weight of a gearbox.  I
suspect that turboprops might have actually come out before turbofans..
Does somebody know the history?

The early turbofans were nearly as noisey as the early turbojets.

The increased wetted area of the large nacelles which are part of
converting a turbojet to a turbofan is more than outweighed by the
increase in efficiency caused by increasing the mass of air to be
accelerated (thrust).  At subsonic speeds.

Unshrouded fans were even more efficient because of increased diameter,
but unacceptably noise when the fan was run at the core speed.

For speeds under 400mph, nothing competes with props when it comes to
efficiency..

No airplane is good enough to throw efficiency away by adding
complication (such as ducts on the prop)..


Regards,

Matt-

Amen Matt. Well said.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.