Subject: Ducted fan airplanes
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/21/2006, 6:18 PM
To: AA-me


         >     Fuel consumption.  Hmmmmmm.  Is this a bad time to ask just
        what kind
         > of
         >     fuel you intend to burn?  And whether it will be
   available at the
         >     airports
         >     you visit?  George W>
         >
         >
         >
         > Hello George,
         >
         > Not sure what you're getting at there.  Until somebody makes
   a rotary
         > run really well on something other than gasoline, that's the
   only
         > choice, as far as I am concerned.
         >
         >
         > Matt-

        Sorry, Matt, I tend to look across the range of powerplants and
        forgot you
        were concentrating on a rotary.  My impression is that rotaries
   are
        relatively insensitive to octane - am I right?  I seem to remember
        owning a
        1973 RX-3 and its owner's manual claiming that it ran well on
   60 octane
        fuel.  I've never heard of this octane before, but they didn't
   seem
        worried
        about anything we could buy here.  Many of the airports don't have
        mogas.
        Can you run on aviation fuel without damage or increased
   maintenance?

        George W

   My understanding is that the rotary runs fine on 100LL.  Sparkplug life
   isn't as good as with autogas, but it's not bad either (50hours+).  I
   think with appropriate plugs and ignition, it won't be more of a problem
   than with a small air cooled aircraft engine - minor PITA, but
   nothing more.

   As an aside, I have wondered if the people that have problems with 100LL
   on rotary spark plugs lean the mixture aggressively when at low power..
   My understanding is that the lead scavengers that come in 100LL only
   work above a certain temperature of operation.  If an engine is run
   below that temperature with a rich mixture, I'd have to guess that lead
   salt buildup would be rapid.

   Also, I wonder if TCP (supplemental lead scavenger) would be effective
   at reducing lead fouling on rotary spark plugs.  Some of the Subaru guys
   claim that they can get reasonable life from their O2 sensors when
   running 100LL if they use TCP.

   As a further aside, whenever I fill up at the home airport, it's almost
   always with autogas.  I have to think that dilutes the effects of
   running 100LL.  If I had a rotary powered airplane, I'd get even more
   serious about running autogas.

   Finally, 100LL will eventually go away.  I think most commercial
   operators that now run piston powered aircraft will all eventually
   convert to turbines.  I suspect those operators are the only real
   economic force that keeps lead in aviation fuel.  As soon as the
   economics work, 100LL will go away.  The recreational operators will
   have to burn whatever gasoline that replaces 100LL (95UL?).  For most
   recreational aircraft, that won't be a big deal..


   Regards,

   Matt-

   I'll have to differ with you there Matt most new piston engine
   are requiring 100 LL. I don't think 100 LL disappear in
   my life time.


   Paul Lamar

Err..  Maybe.  I think the new piston powered airplanes that are being
sold (except for possibly the new 206's) are all essentially toys for
successful business owners.  These airplanes are being purchased by/for
businesses because that's the only way it makes sense economically -
offset operating profit against the price of the airplane, and then
depreciate the value of the airplane over future years (also against
operating profit).  Then, they use the airplane essentially for
boondoggles for the "corporate execs."

The piston powered airplanes that are really furthering businesses are
the ones that are out of production..  The Aztecs, Navajos and Cessna
340, 421, etc that are hauling documents and parcels are being replaced
by Metroliners, Turbo Commanders, MU2's and sometimes Caravans.  All
turbines.  The piston twins are wearing out or being crashed.  I think
the only real piston twin that's still in production is the Seneca.  A
trainer.  The Barons are so bloody expensive, they aren't going to haul
checks and medical samples in them.  Plus in contrast to many of the
older twins which are turbocharged, the new planes are naturally
aspirated - less good at for-hire, all weather operations.  The A500 is
turbocharged, but I can't see it as a good cargo hauler.

The dispatch reliability of the turbine powered airplanes helps
profitability when hauling for-hire.  The turbine reliability helps with
safety.  To me, this means that the piston engines that are burning the
majority of the gasoline (and which need 100LL) are going away.  They're
literally flying the wings off these airplanes (look at the Cessna 400
series wing spar AD).

Maybe this analysis is nonsense..  :)

Please, let's get back to propeller driving rotaries (though I don't
feel compelled to get the last word).


Matt-

Well Van's is completing one aircraft per day with a piston engine.
He is probably selling 1 1/2 kits per day :)
Mostly new Lyc's as the used engines are pretty well scrap by now.

Couple of years ago Continental was selling 17 engines a day
both new and zero time rebuilds. I don't know what the numbers
are now but they are still in biz.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.