Subject: [Fwd: Re: Ducted fan airplanes]
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/22/2006, 7:43 PM
To: AA-me


Gordon wrote Snip
> However, look at the relative sizes here. A 24-inch fan is actually
> bigger than the small Williams engine. So compared purely to the
> Williams engine my 24-inch fan will be more efficient, especially since
> there is no engine inside the duct.

Assuming you can forge titanium fan blades with sharp leading edges
accurately to a highly optimized design. My money is on the Williams :)


> So relatively speaking my 24 inch fan is actually more efficient than
> the high-bypass engines. The slipstream speed going through that duct
> will not be very much faster than the airplane airspeed. As a ratio, it
> will be a much lower than that of the bizjet engines.

Hmmm, you are mixing ideas here. Physics is not a buffet. You can't just
cherry pick the advantages.
Your 24 inch nozzle is not going to flow that much mass, so to get
sufficient thrust you are still going to be accelerating it much faster than
would be optimum for propulsive efficiency on the low speed A/C you are
proposing. The 72" prop on the standard light aircraft is sweeping 4071 sq
in. generate it's ~400lb of thrust. Your 24" fan is sweeping only 452 sq in
or about 1/9 th the area. F=MV^2 so every reduction in mass used to generate
thrust needs to be compensated by a exponentially greater increase in flow
velocity, with drag rising in unison.

> With my 24-inch duct on that plane I am actually beyond that point and
> making the fan bigger will only make things worse. That's why I believe
> making the fan even smaller will actually be an improvement.
>
Belief is nice, but what facts support your belief?

Undoubtedly you can make a sporty jet looking light aircraft with a ducted
fan, but it will just repeat the data point Perry worked so hard to provide.
It will climb worse, cruise slower, use more gas and glide worse. To look
cool it would be better to slap up a mock up, get photographed with it, then
get on with making a plane which is of use to you once you have put in the
thousands of hours and dollars to build it.

Mark W.

Mark,

I have recalculated my tip speed and would actually use a 20 inch fan,
rather than 24. This would give a helical tip speed of mach 0.82 at 7000
rpm and 350 mph true airspeed.

The duct diameter of the Williams is 17.3 inches, with a length of about
48 inches. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Williams_FJ33

So with a 20 inch duct, my specific thrust -- the ratio of propulsive
stream airspeed to freestream airspeed -- is going to be lower than the
Williams, so it's like having a higher-bypass engine. Now look at the
total surface area inside that duct -- it is not big enough to create
huge amounts of drag. Also consider that there is no engine shroud
inside my duct, so total skin friction is probably about half of a
fanjet of similar diameter.

I cannot dispute Newton's second law that a smaller mass of air needs to
be accelerated faster to generate equal thrust. The small airstream
diameter of the ducted fan is always going to be at a disadvantage from
the perspective of specific thrust.

However, I'm saying this isn't the only thing to consider. I'm not
cherry-picking advantageous factors. I'm just saying that we shouldn't
accept as gospel that a ducted fan cannot get over 60 percent efficiency.

Look at a real-world example, the GE CF6, one of the first high-bypass
airliner engines. This engine is rated at over 45,000 pounds of static
thrust sea level at a TSFC of just 0.3. At 375 mph and 25,000 feet, its
TSFC is just under 0.5. At this speed we can equate one pound of thrust
with one horspower, so its nearly 16,0000 pounds of thrust at this
altitude and speed would equal 16,0000 shaft horsepower output of a
turboprop. So we can directly equate this engine's 0.5 TSFC to a BSFC of
0.5 if we're counting horsepower.

This is almost as efficient as a piston prop engine! If fans are limited
to an efficiency of 60 percent, then this engine could not exist. There
is pretty good aerodynamic science in today's ducted fans, namely the
high-bypass airliner engines. I've seen figures mentioning 90 percent
fan efficiency.

My point is that given an optimized configuration along these lines, a
small driveshaft-driven ducted fan could achieve much better than 60
percent efficiency. How high? We won't know until we try.

I do admit your earlier point about a fanjet engine's high power output
at sea level, is some cause for concern. Fanjets do make prodigous power
at sea level -- and they need to, in order to accelerate the small
diameter slipstream sufficiently to achieve enough thrust for takeoff.

This is the one thing that worries me -- since even a high-output,
boosted rotary is going to have difficulty matching a turbine's sea
level power. However, we can have a significantly lighter aircraft
because of a much lighter fuel load, so we don't need as much thrust at
takeoff. The challenge, as always, is finding the right balance of
compromises.


Regards,

Gordon.



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.