All,
Just a quick note about my idea for a personal ?jet? powered by a rotary
engine ducted fan -- call it the "Rotor fan." In my last few posts I?ve
thrown up a lot of figures about power, thrust etc, with some
calculation errors along the way, which has probably confused things.
Here is a summary that should clarify things and put them into context
vis a vis the Diamond D-jet.
The D-jet is a single-engine fanjet airplane that is now undergoing
certification. The specs, which are preliminary and probably optimistic,
give a gross weight of 5,110 pounds, a useful load of 2,240 lb., and a
fuel capacity of 1,740 lb, leaving a full-fuel payload of 500 lb. -- a
little on the short side for a five-seat airplane, even compared to the
600 pounds payload you get with one of the new high-performance singles
like Cirrus or Columbia.
The D-jet is powered by a Williams FJ-33 fanjet engine rated at 1,300
pounds of static thrust at sea level. That is enough power, according to
Diamond, to give the plane a maximum cruise speed of 315 knots at its
25,000 ft. ceiling and a time to climb of 15 minutes, or about 1,700
feet per minute. The airplane?s range is given as 1,350 nautical miles
at an economy cruise speed of 240 knots.
Provided that the certified airplane actually delivers those numbers,
this is what we need to shoot for with the Rotorfan personal jet. In
outward appearance the Rotorfan will be similar ? it will have a duct
buried within the fuselage with an exit nozzle somewhat bigger than
the D-jet?s, and exiting from the aft fuselage similar to the D-jet. Two
intake air scoops will be side-mounted, as on the D-jet. The rotary
engine will be mounted forward of the duct in an engine compartment
separate from the duct and will drive the fan via short driveshaft. The
fan will be located at the front of the duct, aft of the intakes. The
duct will be about 48 inches long, which is similar to the FJ-33 duct
length of 47 inches. The fan diameter of 20 inches will give a helical
tip speed of mach 0.825 at 7000 rpm, at an aircraft true airspeed of 315
knots at 25,000 feet. This compares to a fan diameter of 17.3 inches on
the FJ-33 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Williams_FJ33.
The big question is: How much power does our rotary engine need to make
in order to keep up with the D-jet? And can the rotary realistically
make that kind of power?
To get an answer, we need to figure out just how much power the D-jet is
making in terms of thrust and then convert that to horsepower, because
that?s the only way we can compare its power output to the rotary.
We first need to know the drag of the D-jet at its cruise speed.
Diamond doesn?t tell us that, but thrust equals drag in straight and
level flight, and we can figure out the thrust of the airplane based on
its fuel burn and cruise speed. To get fuel burn we divide the
airplane?s range, by its speed: 1,350 nautical miles divided by 240
knots means the D-jet can stay aloft for 5.625 hours. Assuming that
Diamond has included the standard NBAA fuel reserve of 45 minutes, we
add 0.75 hours to get a total of 6.375 hours, about six hours and 20
minutes. Dividing the fuel weight of 1,740 lb. by this figure, we get a
fuel burn of 274 pounds per hour, just under 40 gallons per hour. (This
does not take into account the higher fuel burn used at takeoff and
climb, so actual cruise fuel burn will be a little more).
Now that we know fuel burn we can solve for engine thrust. To do this we
need to know the engine?s thrust specific fuel consumption, which is the
standard measure for turbine engine fuel efficiency and comparable to
brake specific fuel consumption for piston engines. The FJ-33 has a TSFC
of about 0.5 at sea level, which means it makes one pound of thrust for
each half pound of fuel burned.
But since jet engine thrust decreases with altitude, specific fuel
consumption goes up. At 25,000 feet, the FJ-33 can only make about 530
pounds of thrust at full power. But the engine is also burning less fuel
at that altitude because of the lower air density. Assuming a TSFC of
0.8 at 25,000 feet, and knowing that the D-jet burns 274 pounds per hour
at its economy cruise of 240 knots, we find that it is making about 340
pounds of thrust, or about 64 percent of full power.
In order to figure out how much power our rotary engine needs to make we
need to convert that 340 pounds of thrust to thrust horsepower, using
the equation:
THP = thrust in pounds * speed in feet per second / 550
This gives us about 250 thp. Now all we need to know is how much brake
horsepower out rotary needs to make in order to produce 250 thp. Since
thp is simply brake horsepower times propeller or fan efficiency, we can
easily find the answer if we know our fan efficiency.
And therein lies the big question: How much propulsive efficiency can we
get from our small diameter fan duct? Airplane propellers routinely
deliver efficiency of 80 percent to 85 percent, but it is believed that
fans cannot approach this level. Paul has mentioned a figure of 60
percent, which is from the Kuchemann and Weber book. This may or may not
be the most we can expect to see. There are reasons to think that much
higher efficiency could be achieved.
Even if we assume the worst and take that fan efficiency of 0.6 as an
upper limit, we find that our rotary would need to make about 400 bhp at
our economy cruise power setting and over 600 bhp at our full power
setting at 25,000 feet. This is within reach of a 4-rotor boosted engine.
The bigger problem though is takeoff thrust. Mark has mentioned that the
little Williams probably makes the equivalent of about 800 hp at full
sea level power, and this is not unreasonable. This is more than we
could hope to get from even a 4-rotor boosted engine. Assuming the most
we could safely make from a 4-rotor engine is 600 hp, it means we are
making only three quarters the power of the Williams at sea level. But
assuming we have a boosted engine, we can probably carry that power to
our ceiling of 25,000 feet, where we will have rough parity with the
fanjet. We see here that the higher we go, the more we close the gap
with the fanjet.
But there is one important factor that plays to our advantage and that
is fuel weight. Our much lower fuel burn means we can carry much less
fuel and our airplane can be significantly lighter. That means that we
can hope to match the D-jet?s thrust to weight ratio of about 4 --
gross weight of 5110 pounds divided by 1300 pounds thrust -- with a
lower output engine.
Since takeoff thrust is the most difficult parameter for our rotary
engine to match, we have to try to reduce airplane weight to a
value that will give us a comparable thrust-weight ratio. Assuming we
can make 1000 pounds of static thrust with our 600 bhp engine, we would
need an airplane weight of 4000 pounds to match the D-jet's
thrust-weight ratio of 4. That is probably not possible. Because our
4-rotor engine is at least 200 pounds heavier than the Williams, we
would need to eliminate about 1300 pounds of fuel weight in order to do
that.
That would leave us with just 450 pounds of fuel, which is not enough.
So how much fuel weight can we eliminate? Assuming our very efficient
turbocharged or turbocompound engine has a reasonable BSFC of 0.4, the
400 or so hp we are making at our economy cruise would burn about 160
pounds of fuel, less than 60 percent of the Williams engine fuel burn of
274 pounds. So if we want the same range our fuel capacity can be 60
percent of the D-jet, or about 1000 pounds.
That?s a savings of 700 pounds of fuel weight, but since our engine
weighs 200 pounds more, we have a net saving of 500 pounds. Roughly
speaking we now have an airplane with a maximum gross of about 4500
pounds and a thrust to weight of about 4.5. That's not bad. We can
probably shave a little bit more weight by making the structure a little
lighter, to compensate for our lighter gross weight, but it?s not going
to be much.
So summing things up, we have an airplane that is probably going to have
a bit longer takeoff roll than the D-jet, but will actually perform
better up high. Assuming the same lift to drag ratio, our lighter weight
will give stronger climb and higher top speed. (We need less lift and
therefore less angle of attack, and hence less induced drag, to fly a
lighter plane at the same airspeed).
We will have great fuel economy, burning only 60 percent of the fuel it
takes to fly the D-jet. Plus we have the flexibility of a piston plane
to fly at low altitudes at the same low fuel burn. Turbines simply can?t
do that. Even the most fuel efficient turbine gulps gas down low, making
short hops something that you just don?t do, unless you don?t mind
whipping out your wallet at every gas pump you pass.
This advantage alone is not to be underestimated. So even with just this
rough comparison -- and assuming the dismal fan efficiency of 60 percent
-- it is clear that a rotorfan ?personal jet? is not an unfeasible
idea. If we could get our fan efficiency up to about 70 or 75 percent,
this airplane could be a world beater. We could use a much lighter
3-rotor engine, much less fuel weight again, lighter aircraft structure,
etc. We could also scale this idea down as George Wright has suggested,
right down to a single-seater like the Mini-Imp.
I'm going to give this a little more thought and try to figure out what
kinds of fan efficiencies we might hope to achieve, based on what the
efficient little fanjets of today are doing. I have a feeling that even
the little Williams with its 17-inch fan is getting well over 60 percent
efficiency.
Regards,
Gordon.
Pretty good summary Gordon. I have not checked all your
numbers but it looks good. You have certainly spent a
lot of time thinking about it.
One thing going against the duct is skin friction
drag is prop. to the square of the velocity so if you have
a high velocity duct exhaust you are paying a price.
That is one reason the eff. of the duct is so bad.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Gordon
It sounds like an interesting concept and the devil will be in the details.
Perhaps you have spoken to Monty about this as well? I think he was
thinking along the same path for his plane design. Paul's 1997 design
posted a few days ago had a unique way of diverting some of the thrust
through the radiators thereby killing two birds with one stone. If done well
then the 680 Hp. 26B engine would cool well and the expanding heat out the
exhaust would help to evacuate the duct. It will take years to get the duct
tested well so perhaps an all aluminum engine will be happening by then and
hence bringing your gross weight down further.
Doug Fir
Cooperstate bound
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.