Subject: Ducted fan airplanes
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/24/2006, 7:30 PM
To: AA-me




Thanks, Gordon.  I've had a legal set of plans for these birds for several
years.  From my point of view the real trick is to take some of the
construction manhours out of the aircraft.  There are two versions.  A short
nose and a stretched long-nose with beefed structure and gear for heavier
engines.  The nose stretch required addition of a vertical stabilizer versus
the inverted V of the short nose prototype.  I had a long talk with Molt
about these aircraft in 1988 at his shop, he also showed me his Bullet
2-seater design (an interesting subject for another day).  Molt was as cheap
as a Kentucky mule-skinner about materials utilization (I admire that), but
retained a 30's- 40's view of labor intensity.  He came up when labor was
cheap and materials were dear.

Things are pretty much reversed these days.
So reduction in labor intensity is a consideration.  Especially for
pre-retirement types like me.  A terrific guy has been running Mini-Imp, but
was a victim of the Delta airline pilot pension melt-down and is looking for
someone ethical and savvy to take over the operation.  the Mini-Imp is not a
big seller.  Gary has already set up laser-cut sheet metal kits and talked
about low-cost pre-assembled modules for some of the structures.  I don't
know how far he got on that.  There is a builder's web-site (free). Anyway,


I'm more interested in the short-nose version of the aircraft.  there was
also a shorter version yet called the Micro-Imp.  It suffered from lack of
power and was truly experimental in being built of something called Taylor
Paper-Glass.  Not surprisingly, this "poor man's composite" wasn't really
that light and performance suffered accordingly.  I've corresponded with the
pilot (a brave man) and discovered that the Micro-Imp actually flew very
well.  But it took a mechanically-actuated variable pitch prop to get it off
the ground (the pilot ran about 225 lbs).  The last I heard of the prototype
it had been flogged to a teenager around Vancouver, Wa to be used as ???
The powerplant was to be a modified Citroen 2CV auto engine.  I know a
little about this one because Joe Horvath tried to turbo-charge one for me
about 1980 for use on a hot-air blimp I built under license from Cameron in
England.  Light, very quiet with the turbo, and didn't do dink because Joe
couldn't get the turbo over the step.  The blimp ended up with a 582 rotax
and now lives in Miami with a lawyer.

The point of this ramble is that I
keep hoping someone will either come up with a Mazda-based aluminum
single-rotor or that the Rota-Max single-rotor will turn out to not
self-distruct.  Both would seem to me to be candidate drivers for a ducted
fan Mini-Imp.  A twin-rotor Mazda would be pretty marginal from a weight
standpoint.  As for the twin-Rota-Max?  Who knows???  I've been seeing a
statement that sweep tests on the twin-rotor are pending for 10 months.
They do have one for the single-rotor on their web-site.  Paul seems to
think that they're in bed with Moller.

I don't know whether they are just
licensing the engines or bought the rights.  Paul seems to know the main guy
from their engine development program, so perhaps his lack of confidence in
the Rota-Max is based upon more than his opinion of Moller's securities
track record?  Anyway, It is certainly possible to design a piston-engine
installation (area ruling here we come).  But I'd really like to see a small
rotary in an aircraft that would get some attention.  The Mini-Imp is a
single seat design and not really easily stretchable to a two-placer. So
building one isn't really justifiable in terms of financial reward.  But if
workable it might be fun.

George W

George,

Thanks for the back story on the Mini-Imp. Whatever happens with the
company, this is still a great design -- although a bit labor-intensive
like you said. Some parts ready-made would surely help those who want a
quicker build.

I really like the idea of a rotary in this plane. Here is an 80 hp
twin-rotor all-aluminum engine that you can buy right now:
http://www.rotaryengines.ca/main/aircraft.htm

This is an outfit near me in the Toronto area. They are getting these
engines from Wankel in Germany, but have rights to start manufacturing
themselves in the future. I visited with the owner not long ago, an
elderly German fellow who logged some stick time in an Me109 during the
war. Decent chap with great stories...

As you can see from the specs, this 80 hp engine weighs under 80 pounds,
without redrive. With the fan, you don't need redrive anyway. I think
the rotamax and freedom motors has similar small two-rotor engines.

The rotary also has very small and neat form factor, so packaging and
access will be great. Another plus is its higher rpm opperation, which
will give you the fan speed you want. This would be a great engine
choice for the Mini-Imp.

For those who don't want to build with aluminum, this airplane could
translate well into composite, or even wood construction.

Regards,

Gordon.




"I really like the idea of a rotary in this plane. Here is an 80 hp
twin-rotor all-aluminum engine that you can buy right now:
http://www.rotaryengines.ca/main/aircraft.htm"

Give us the name and location of somebody that has bought one of
these 80 HP 2 rotor engines in the last few years. I would like to
see it and talk to the owner. My info is
the factory in Germany is out of business. I have been there
and know the former CEO.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

GeorgeW./ Gordon

What would be wrong with a single Mazda rotor 80-130 hp at 240lbs ( all up)
George ( down under)

The "problem" is that an engine of that weight would require use of the long
nose Mini-Imp airframe.  This version has slightly thicker skins and beefed
up landing gear.  It is also heavier which puts you into the wt/hp req
spiral.  As a powerplant in terms of reliability, I don't have any issue
with a single rotor Mazda at all.  But I guess I should ask what your weight
estimate includes?  I'd been working an assumption that a single rotor
installation would run about 200 lbs.  And a two-rotor at about 340.  Must
have under-estimated.

George W

You are about right George. Maybe a little more.
Say 210 to 220.

You are a bit heavy on the two rotor. With a properly
designed motor mount and aluminum oil pan 300 pounds is
possible.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Thanks for the weight info.  Bruce Harrison told me that his Mazda
installation in his Jet Hawk ran about 360 lbs.  But he was going with the
original cooling system design which was far from weight engineered.

G. Wright

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.