Subject: Ducted fan airplanes
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/25/2006, 4:40 PM
To: AA-me


George./ Gordon

What would be wrong with a single Mazda rotor 80-130 hp at 240lbs ( all up)
George ( down under)

George (down under),

A single rotor Mazda would also be a good choice for the Mini-Imp, as
far as I'm concerned. In fact I think all up weight could be well under
200 pounds because with the direct drive fan we don't need a 40 pound
gearbox.

Regards,

Gordon.

The big problem with a shaft drive, and a Mini Imp requires a
shaft drive, is the severe low frequency torsional resonance
problem. The prop acts like a flywheel on the end of a long shaft
and you are feeding it one huge torque pulse per engine
rev.  Molt had his problems with a four cylinder engine
that puts out two smaller torque pulses per engine rev.
You ain't seen anything yet until you try a 1.3 liter single
rotor engine or a 650 cc single cylinder two cycle engine. Or even
a 1.3 L two cylinder four cycle engine. All put out one
large equivalent torque pulse per engine revolution.

http://www.prime-mover.org/Engines/Torsional/contact1/contact1.html
http://www.mini-imp.com/

Stick with a small all aluminum two rotor if you can find one.
Diamond aircraft is sitting on a great one if you can talk
the owner Christian Dries into selling them. (George P,
If you can send Chris a blanket purchase order for
100 a year I think he would go back into production.
Unlike Wankel Gmbh they have the inventory and the
where with all.)

It is as least as good torque pulse wise as a 4 cylinder.

Or better yet use the 200 pound 100 HP  O-200 and run a decent
dia. more eff. prop. No liquid cooling system required.

Mazda Wankel engines are great but they are not the best
for all applications.


Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.



Paul,

Your point about torsional vibration is very true with a long dirveshaft
and a big prop at the end of that shaft.

However, with a buried duct inside that fuselage and the fan just a few
inches behind that engine, you have a very short driveshaft and a small
diameter fan with very low moment of inertia. I'm not saying
categorically there would not be any torsional problems --  you never
really know for sure until you run it -- but I would think it should not
be an issue.

Btw, this is the first I've heard of the Diamond rotary. What's the
story with Diamond "sitting on them?" Are they planning to produce these
engines and use them in their planes? Do they want to just sell the
engines to other manufacturers?

Regards,

Gordon.

Old Midwest engine.  But right now they are in love with
the Thielert diesel because diesel fuel is cheaper
than gasoline in Europe. Send them email and bug them.
Perhaps if they get enough email they will produce the
engine in two rotor form. Right now they are producing
only a 50 HP one rotor version for powered gliders in Europe.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


Paul,
Any idea on the damper used in the single rotor Diamond engine.
I personally consider them a very nice little engine.
George ( down under)

I think it is a big rubber donut out of a BMW drive shaft.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.