Subject: Ducted fan airplanes
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/26/2006, 12:41 AM
To: AA-me



> George./ Gordon
>
> What would be wrong with a single Mazda rotor 80-130 hp at 240lbs ( all > up)
> George ( down under)

> George (down under),
>
> A single rotor Mazda would also be a good choice for the Mini-Imp, as
> far as I'm concerned. In fact I think all up weight could be well under
> 200 pounds because with the direct drive fan we don't need a 40 pound
> gearbox.
>
> Regards,
>
> Gordon.
>
> The big problem with a shaft drive, and a Mini Imp requires a
> shaft drive, is the severe low frequency torsional resonance
> problem. The prop acts like a flywheel on the end of a long shaft
> and you are feeding it one huge torque pulse per engine
> rev.  Molt had his problems with a four cylinder engine
> that puts out two smaller torque pulses per engine rev.
> You ain't seen anything yet until you try a 1.3 liter single
> rotor engine or a 650 cc single cylinder two cycle engine. Or even
> a 1.3 L two cylinder four cycle engine. All put out one
> large equivalent torque pulse per engine revolution.
>
> http://www.prime-mover.org/Engines/Torsional/contact1/contact1.html
> http://www.mini-imp.com/
>
> Stick with a small all aluminum two rotor if you can find one.
> Diamond aircraft is sitting on a great one if you can talk
> the owner Christian Dries into selling them. (George P,
> If you can send Chris a blanket purchase order for
> 100 a year I think he would go back into production.
> Unlike Wankel Gmbh they have the inventory and the
> where with all.)
>
> It is as least as good torque pulse wise as a 4 cylinder.
>
> Or better yet use the 200 pound 100 HP  O-200 and run a decent
> dia. more eff. prop. No liquid cooling system required.
>
> Mazda Wankel engines are great but they are not the best
> for all applications.
>
>
> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
>
>
>
> Paul,
>
> Your point about torsional vibration is very true with a long > dirveshaft
> and a big prop at the end of that shaft.
>
> However, with a buried duct inside that fuselage and the fan just a few
> inches behind that engine, you have a very short driveshaft and a small
> diameter fan with very low moment of inertia. I'm not saying
> categorically there would not be any torsional problems --  you never
> really know for sure until you run it -- but I would think it should > not
> be an issue.
>
> Btw, this is the first I've heard of the Diamond rotary. What's the
> story with Diamond "sitting on them?" Are they planning to produce > these
> engines and use them in their planes? Do they want to just sell the
> engines to other manufacturers?
>
> Regards,
>
> Gordon.
>
> Old Midwest engine.  But right now they are in love with
> the Thielert diesel because diesel fuel is cheaper
> than gasoline in Europe. Send them email and bug them.
> Perhaps if they get enough email they will produce the
> engine in two rotor form. Right now they are producing
> only a 50 HP one rotor version for powered gliders in Europe.
> -- > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,
Any idea on the damper used in the single rotor Diamond engine.
I personally consider them a very nice little engine.
George ( down under)

I think it is a big rubber donut out of a BMW drive shaft.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

From memory Molt Taylor used a Dodge "lead shot centrifugal clutch". With the
small cars now going to CVT with torque converter or FF, it may be possible
to pick up a fluid flywheel to do the damping as well as acting as a
flywheel. FF's can be reasonably efficient, unlike some torque converters,
and some can be filled to suit the application.
Colin Smith

Colin,
I believe that weight is against them - what is your estimates of weight of
the unit.
George (down under)



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.