Subject: Canard slips departure
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/30/2006, 1:46 PM
To: AA-me



        Perry just as a matter of interest please try a forward slip at
   high
        altitude and
        tell us what happens. For example is the canard stable or
        does it buck in yaw or pitch? I am curious. The C 172 with full
        flaps pitch bucks a little bit in a forward slip.

        Paul Lamar


   Paul,

   Here's what Burt said about VariEze slips:

   VARIEZE LOSS-OF-CONTROL
   We have just completed another series of flight tests on N4EZ to test
   its departure (loss-of-control) resistance.  What prompted this is
   reports from two VariEze pilots in Texas that they experienced a partial
   or full snap roll at about 80 knots.  These occurred below pattern
   altitude and fortunately the pilots managed to recover in time to avoid
   an accident.  The maneuver was described as follows: Full aileron and
   partial rudder steady sideslip, then full rudder was applied which
   caused the airplane to yaw excessively and abruptly roll, experiencing
   negative g.  Recovery with neutral control was prompt, but several
   hundred feet of altitude was lost.


   The most surprising thing about these incidents to us was that control
   was lost at such a high speed - 30 knots above stall.  Reinspection of
   our stall/spin test data and the NASA tests indicated no susceptibility
   to departure.  We then initiated a new test program to investigate
   this.  Dick performed full rudder sideslip with N4EZ at all speeds and
   experienced no departures.  Concentrating on the 80-knot speed range he
   then aggravated the yaw with abrupt rudder inputs while in a rolled
   attitude.  On one of these he experienced a departure - a roll off in
   the direction of the slip.  He then tried to repeat the maneuver and
   could not get a departure in
   over 20 attempts.  We then adjusted the aileron and rudder rigging,
   moved the cg aft, and repeated the tests.  Dick found that by learning a
   specific technique he could cause a departure nearly every time, if
   speed were above 75 knots and an excessive sideslip angle were
   generated.  The departure generally consisted of an uncontrolled roll
   away from the rudder input direction.  Recovery with neutral controls
   was prompt.  However, on several of the maneuvers the yaw angle was
   extreme at departure causing a massive stall of
   the winglets and blanking of the upstream wing.  The airplane then yawed
   past 45 degrees, abruptly rolled, and entered a 1 to 2 turn inverted
   incipient spin.  The airplane always promptly recovered with neutral
   controls.  If aileron or rudder were applied for recovery it could cause
   a further "snap" departure and delay recovery.  Altitude loss on the
   worst of these maneuvers was as much as 1500 ft.


   Why did we not find this departure when we did the original tests and
   the tests with cuffs in 1978 (CP #19)?  The most probable reason is that
   most of those test were done at high angle of attack (full aft stick)
   which was thought to be the worst case.  However, we have found that at
   lower angle-of-attack ie, 80 knots, the rudders can generate more
   sideslip than at high angle-of-attack, and thus can be powerful enough
   to stall the winglets in an accelerated yaw maneuver. We were then
   faced
   with a decision on what to do:  (1) caution pilots that the airplane can
   be departed when using excessive yaw inputs or (2) fix the airplane to
   improve its departure resistance.  Since we feel strongly that good
   departure resistance is an important asset and design goal for the
   VariEze, we set out to attack # (2).


   We have always known that the EZ has more rudder power than needed for
   normal maneuvers - a full aileron steady sideslip at low speeds
   requires
   only 60% of the available rudder to hold heading.  The available travel
   is 3 1/2 inches, measured at the top of the rudders trailing edge.  We
   then limited the rudders travel on N4EZ in various increments, 3", 2.6",
   2.3" and 1.8".  At each increment we flew tests to determine departure
   susceptibility and the necessary rudder authority for crosswind
   landings.


   As expected, the departure susceptibility reduced as rudder travel was
   limited.  After extensive testing and evaluation by three pilots we have
   N4EZ's rudder now rigged for a two-inch full travel.  With this rigging,
   the following characteristics exist:  crosswind landings up to a
   component of 24 knots are possible without tire scrub.  The aircraft is
   not susceptible to departure during any normal maneuver.  Thus, we are
   now recommending a mandatory rigging change to limit the rudders to
   two-inches of travel.


   It must be noted that this may not guarantee total departure
   resistance.  This may vary from one airplane to another, due to expected
   tolerances in things like winglet leading edge finish and shape,
   fuselage shape etc.  Also, even at 1.8 inch rudder travel, Dick was able
   to induce a departure by learning an unusual and aggressive combination
   of control inputs:  full left aileron, full left rudder at 30 degrees
   bank, then at 100 degrees bank abrupt full right rudder. When this was
   done a departure was possible (not probable) even though the rudder was
   limited to 1.8 inches.


   The important thing to note is that, even though this design is not as
   susceptible to loss-of-control as a conventional aircraft it
   should not result in over-confidence on the part of the operator.
   Assume your aircraft is susceptible to departure until proven resistant
   during your stall tests with lots of altitude and a parachute.  Refer to
   the plans-changes section of this newsletter for a caution note to be
   added to your owners manual and for instructions on rigging rudders to
   two inches.


   Sorry for the length..  I thought everyone should see what the whole
   story was..

   This issue never resurfaced on the VariEze.  I think this was the only
   loss of control problem found on the airplane.  I know people that
   fairly regularly do all sorts of crazy aerobatics in them..  Except of
   course snap roll/spin maneuvers.

   I don't think the Long-EZ based airframes including Berkut, Cozy, Eracer
   had the same issue..  Much less wing sweep and much larger winglets than
   the VariEze probably help.

   Here's what Burt later said about the Long-EZ:

   Also of interest to NASA was the departure immune stall characteristic
   we have noted during our tests.  NASA wanted to test the spin
   susceptibility to supplement the extensive data they have gathered on
   all types of general aviation aircraft.  Phil put the Long-EZ through
   all types of extreme stall entry conditions:  accelerated entries,
   vertical entries, etc. with all combinations of control
   inputs.  He also alternated left and right rudder inputs at the dutch
   roll natural frequency, combining opposite aileron to add adverse yaw
   effects, at the maximum attainable angle of attack.  Despite all
   combinations of gross misuse of flight controls, and attaining over 45
   degrees sideslip, he was unable to obtain a departure from controlled
   flight.  Phil left with the comment that he could
   find no way of inducing loss of control in the Long-EZ.


   This is a stark contrast to the general aviation aircraft configurations
   he has testing at Langley, all of them being relatively susceptible to
   loss of control or spin entry from any aggravated stall entry.  Many of
   them have unrecoverable spin modes that require
   wingtip rockets or anti-spin parachutes to effect recovery.


   Regards,

   Matt-

   It is not exactly departure but if you pull high positive G's
   and the canard stalls first (as expected) the airplane
   will turn sharply towards the ground.

   This IMHO was one of the factors in Paul Conner's fatal crash.
   I also suspect this happened in a fatal Berkut crash
   at an air show in SZP a few years ago. Both done at low
   altitude. Of course if you try this in a tractor airplane
   and you stall the main wing you will die as well.

   Just don't get the idea that you cannot make a canard fall out
   of the sky.

   Paul Lamar


Paul, you are probably talking about the Rick Fessenden crashing the
Berkut..  The theory that I have read is that he blacked out leading to
loss of control..  Do you have other information?

This alleged turn toward the ground would not be an uncontrollable
maneuver...  The ailerons and rudder remain effective if there's enough
airspeed to put G's (even 1g) on the airplane..

Of course, if the pilot keeps pulling, but isn't actually flying the
plane, you are absolutely correct about the canards falling out of the
sky.  As everyone here knows, the "turn back to the runway" is a common
cause of light plane fatalities.


Regards,

Matt-

Nothing for sure Matt. Happened so fast. He was very experienced
aerobatic pilot with time in fighter jets as I recall.
Paul Conner was no slouch as a pilot either.
He turned back once before successfully.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.