Subject: Canard slips departure
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/31/2006, 12:31 AM
To: AA-me



    >>     It is not exactly departure but if you pull high positive G's
    >>     and the canard stalls first (as expected) the airplane
    >>     will turn sharply towards the ground.
    >>     Paul Lamar


   Not sure what is meant by "high positive G's". But in my flight testing
   (Cozy Mk-IV), flights in other canards, and reports from all other
   canard
   pilots I know, there is never a "turn sharply towards the
   ground".  In a
   high degree bank angle if you just keep pulling back on the stick
   the canard
   will eventually stall. At that point the nose drops a little, air
   speed is
   gained and the canard regains lift, then airspeed is lost again
   because the
   elevator is still deflected and the canard then re-stalls. This
   process just
   keeps repeating itself. It's known as the "nose-bob". In accelerated
   stalls
   (high angle turns) the "bobbing" is more accentuated than in
   straight and
   level flight - where it is often so gentle it is almost not noticed.
   But the
   porpoising at high bank angles is not that big a deal - certainly
   not enough
   to depart from the existing attitude/angle or lose control of the
   airplane.
   It's more like you are on one of those kiddy rides that used to
   grace the
   front of supermarkets - you know - put in a quarter and bob up and
   down on
   the horse for 2 minutes. :)

   Regards,
   Joe Hull
   Redmond/Seattle WA, Cozy-Mazda Rotary 69hrs


   High positive G TURNS. Sorry.
   Like 90 degree bank angles.

   There is a lift vector on the canard that has a vertical
   component in a high G turn. If that lift vector is lost while
   the rear is still maintained the CG being head of the now
   horizontal tails will FORCE the nose of the airplane down.

   Paul got it rolled out and almost pulled out in 500 feet but the
   sink rate was so high it buried the tires in hard ground
   and collapsed the fuselage.

   In the Conner crash we had a pilot witness. That is exactly
   what he described. I investigated the accident with the
   permission of the FAA and made a report to them.

   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


I agree with what you're saying Paul, but I would reiterate what Joe
said about the canard stall..  Even with the stick held back, on a
properly designed (I don't know about the SQ) and constructed canard,
the loss of pitch attitude at stall is slight, even with very high
loads.  The canard lift doesn't go to zero in an instant.  The canard
airfoil is high lift, not one of those Natural Laminar Flow foils which
can have exciting stall behavior.

As you said, the nose falls (the airplane must yaw for that to happen at
90deg of bank), but it's not like a spin entry where nearly instantly
you are pointed at the ground (caused by massive flow separation from
one wing).  I have done 90deg banks in the varieze with the stick
against the stop (canard stalled), and can say that the nose doesn't
"fall through"..  The nose gradually gets lower (if you keep the ball
centered).  At some point you end up in a rather steep diving spiral.

I will also agree that canard planes can fall out of the sky, but in
general, they are more forgiving..  You have to be really breaking the
rules for them to bite you.

<RANT>

On a side note, I have to say something about a lot of canard pilots
(maybe myself included)..  For some reason, the design seems to attract
a large contingent of (for lack of a better term) "space cadets."  I
don't know what about the design seems to do it, but the quantity of
"Trekies" and major Star Wars fans in that crowd is disproportionate
compared to other designs.  There are some excellent aviators (stick and
rudder operators) in that crowd, but there are also a bunch that I think
are just plain flaky.  The RV crowd seems to attract a much more
straightforward group for whatever reason.

It's a shame too..

The Varieze is so-o easy to fly.  Really.  Yeah, the approach speeds are
sporty (90mph on final), but it's not scary.  The predictability of the
results is amazing.  Spot landing?  No problem.  I think a Beech Sierra
is harder to fly and land smoothly..  The Varieze is an amazingly high
performance, practical traveling airplane.  Its performance stuns me
sometimes..  On a tired O-200 Continental, at about 50lbs under gross,
on a day that's probably 30F above standard, I get a sustained climb
rate from 8,000MSL to 10,000MSL of 800-900fpm (at Vy).  Flying my 150
around under those conditions, I am lucky to get 200fpm.  I can go from
Boise to San Diego in less than 5 hours of flight time and burn about
27gal of gas.. 703NM.   That's with a grubby old airplane that doesn't
have wheel pants or a spinner or a host of other go-fast mods..  The
seats are comfortable - after 3 hours of flight, I land feeling fresh
and happy.  After 3 hours in one of my Cessnas, by body is hurting.
There are obviously other experimental which are more efficient than
the Cessnas, but they still don't come close to the Varieze.

The problem with all of this capability is that it tends to make you do
things you wouldn't even attempt in a lesser conventional airplane.  But
couple that mentally corrupting influence with a bunch of starry eyed
space cadet aviators and you get some STUPID accidents.  I am not trying
to point fingers at anyone at all (in case you're wondering).


</RANT>


Matt-


The witness said it could have been more than 90 degrees. I did
not see it of course. When the canard is rolled 90 degrees there
is NO vertical component to the canard lift vector regardless
whether  the canard is stalled or not stalled.
The acceleration of the CG downward will be 32 feet in
the first second generating a rather rapid yaw rate assuming the
tail does not move vertically.

If the lower rudder is inadvertently applied at the same time
the yaw rate about a now horizontal axis through a line connecting
the tails will be much higher due to the rudder not being
on the center line. In other words the drag of the deflected
lower rudder will aggravate the yaw acceleration.

At this point the AC is pointed 90 degrees from the
runway direction and straight down and must be rolled 90 degrees
and pitched 90 degrees to get back to the approach path.

A lot to do in only 500 feet.

On the other hand one might be able to knife edge a canard
if there is enough lateral area in the fuselage and upper rudder
authority. I don't know but I doubt it. Have you ever tried
to knife edge a canard aircraft Matt?

I would like to go for a ride and try some things
at altitude to see what happens. I am sure the CG position has
something to do with it as well as the shape of the fuselage.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.