Subject: Viscosity & Idemitsu 10W-30 RE: Oils
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/2/2006, 11:01 AM
To: AA-me




    > The reason for the light weight oils isnt so much cooling as it
   is gas
    > mileage. And it's not as big of a deal in a rotary as it is the
   piston
    > engines. I personally can not fathom running a 5 weight oil in any
    > engine,
    > so I don't. I'll give up a little gas mileage.
    >
    > Bob Mears
    > Supermarine spitfire
    >
    > Yes - the trend to lighter weight oil is about fuel economy.  The
    > anti-wear
    > performance standards have been strengthened to keep wear in
   check as the
    > viscosity is lowered.
    >
    > Synthetic will run cooler than petroleum - less friction, and
   better heat
    > transfer.  Generally we can go up or down one viscosity grade and
   have
    > good
    > performance from the oil.  Dropping two or more grades can
   significantly
    > increase wear.  Rising two grades eats power, increases heat, and in
    > extreme
    > cases can cause oil starvation in bearings.
    >
    > 5W-30 isn't a SAE 5 oil - especially when synthetic.  The SAE 30 is a
    > kinematic viscosity measurement - actual physical 'thickness' at a
    > specified
    > temperature.  For engine oil, this temp is 100C/212F.
    >
    > The 5W is an 'apparent viscosity' measured in a cold-crank simulator
    > (ASTM D
    > 5293).  The torque transmitted by the oil in the test is compared
   to the
    > performance of straight-weight petroleum oil measured at the same
    > temperature.  5W doesn't necessarily mean the oil has an SAE 5
   kinematic
    > viscosity.
    >
    > Additives can be added to petroleum to change the cold
   properties, and
    > viscosity improver additives are needed to keep petroleum from
   'thinning'
    > when hot.  Generally, synthetic base oils don't have the
   thickening issue
    > when cold and don't need viscosity improver additives to
   'thicken' the
    > oil
    > when hot.
    >
    > 0W- oils are tested at -35C, 5W- at -30C, 10W- at -25C, 15W- at
   -20C, and
    > 20W- at -15C.
    >
    > There are synthetic SAE 30 oils on the street that also meet
   5W-30 and
    > 10W-30 requirements without the use of cold flow improvers.
    >
    > I bought and lab tested Idemitsu 10W-30 in March '05.  Here's the
    > spectrographic data (in parts per million per ml) and physical
    > properties:
    >
    > Iron 1
    > Chromium 0
    > Lead 0
    > Copper 0
    > Tin 0
    > Aluminum 0
    > Nickel 0
    > Silver 0
    > Silicon 2
    > Boron 1
    > Sodium 1
    > Magnesium 13
    > Calcium 1604
    > Barium 0
    > Phosphorus 1081
    > Zinc 1246
    > Molybdenum 227
    > Viscosity/100C 10.17
    > TBN 5.87
    >
    > Viscosity is in the lower 1/3 of the SAE 30 range (9.3 - <12.5 cSt)
    >
    > http://www.idemitsu-usa.com/page_216.htm
    > http://www.apolloamerica.com/images/specsheet10w30.pdf
    >
    > The datasheet reports CCS viscosity at -15 (2090 cP) and -20 (3420
    > cP), but
    > not the -25 required of 10W- oils.
    >
    > This oil appears to be a PAO/ester oil as advertised.  Cold crank
   is a
    > bit
    > high compared to other 'real' synthetics, but it's hard to
   compare since
    > they report non-standard temperatures.  Viscosity index is decent.
    > I'd like
    > to see high temperature/high shear.
    >
    > This isn't the same oil referenced in the SAE paper on LeMans oil
    > development, that's for sure.  The benefits/description of the oil
    > listed on
    > the Idemitsu-USA website are true for any man-made synthetic oil
    > (Mobil 1,
    > Redline, AMSOIL) when compared with petroleum.  Molybdenum by itself
    > doesn't
    > guarantee reduced friction.  There are oils on the streets with
   moly that
    > have higher rates of wear than the same company's oil without moly.
    >
    > For aircraft use, especially because we share a gearbox with the
   sump, I
    > think that high-quality synthetic motorcycle oil is the way to go.
    > Probably
    > 10W-40 rather than 20W-50.  Synthetic motorcycle oils are
   designed to
    > stay
    > in grade when lubricating gears, are designed for high-rpm
   operation, and
    > are designed for wide temperature extremes.
    >
    > Andy Hecker
    >
    >
    >

   Andy,
   Thanks for this report.  Do you have a favorite brand of  motorcycle
   oil?   The motorcycle companies all have their own oils that they
   recommend over brands such as Mobil, Castrol, Pennzoil, etc.  In the
   case of the well known motorcycle company whose initials are hd,  I
   sometimes find their products to be more hype than substance.  So,
   lacking good data to the contrary, I decided to run semi-synthetic
   Aeroshell 15-50 in the motorcycle.  Was that a good or bad decision?   I
   have assumed all along that when its time to fill the pan on the 13b
   aircraft engine, that the decision would be between Idemitsu 10W - 30
   and Aeroshell 15 - 50.  I'd love to have a third choice supported by
   data.  With motor oil, there are as many recommendations out there on
   the street as there are grandfathers.

   Thanks again for the data.
   Aubrey


   Before I started using Idemitsu I used Mobile One since
   it became available. We cooked it a few years ago at 500 degrees
   F for half an hour and it was head and shoulders above all other
   oils we tried except turbine oil used in airliners and biz jets
   in regard to residue and break down.

   My 1992 Dodge caravan went through all other parts except for
   the engine in 200,000 miles using Mobile One. The engine was
   still running strong and passed CA smog inspection when I gave
   it away.  No easy feat. I also ran it in my first gen 1984 RX7
   as well as my 1994 V8 Cougar which my son is still driving. Still
   running strong with 175,000 miles. Lots of other trouble
   with it but no engine trouble so far. Before Idemitsu came out
   I used Mobile One in the RX8 with no apparent problems.
   The rumors about synthetic being bad for the rotary
   are nonsense.  Mazda admitted to me they never tested Mobile
   One.

   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

If you're considering aviation oils such as Aeroshell 15W50, you might
also consider Exxon Elite..  They claim it has better corrosion
protection than other synthetics.  Important for aircraft engines that
often sit for long periods..  The formula 1 guys at Reno are starting to
run it - some are claiming that it's better than the equivalent
Aeroshell - cooler running.  I run it in my 182.  Seems very slippery.
eliteetc seems to have the best prices I've found on Exxon oils:
http://www.eliteetc.com/expisoil.html  The prices include shipping.


Regards,

Matt-


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.