Subject: Combination slide throttle and carburator
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/9/2006, 7:29 PM
To: AA-me


   This is a VERY simple system. No computer, no sensors, no
   floats, no venturi, no fuel injectors, no nothing. Just very
   low pressure fuel. The fuel orifice area simply increases with
   the air passage area increase. Bigger fuel hole bigger air hole.
   There is another simple series valve that controls leaning.
   Paul Lamar

Paul,
  FWIW I believe the Aero-Carb violates the Lectron patents, if they are
still active. The Lectron I worked with used a square slide like a slide
throttle, but were built on a single bore using a return spring and pull
cable.
Bill Jepson

http://www.aeroconversions.com/carb_specs.html


Times up.
Here it is. Super simple. A series of progressively larger
feed holes in the Teflon slide communicating a with a fixed
larger fuel hole in the aluminum spacer.

Patent applied for :)
-- Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,
Sorry for not getting back yesterday, went to bed. The hole idea is ok
but you will have some problems. Kind of like a digital drive for an
analog circuit? An alternate idea would be to have a single feed hole
and a shallow tapered wedge connected to the feed on the end. easier to
make too. (some of the holes would be reeeeeelly small) Tell me what you
think.
Bill Jepson

Good idea Bill. Cheaper than my system. Less cost to make.
Will work better. With an NC mill program you could vary the slope
of the ramp.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Here is the $7 mixture control valve from Home Depot.

This is a major break through in aircraft fuel systems.
Simple systems like this work because the aircraft
engine has simple requirements. The load is fixed
and the RPM is constant. The only real reason for a complicated
carb or EFI system is automatic mixture control.
Since pilots are used to setting the mixture manually
it makes no sense to have an automatic mixture control
as well.

With an EFI system you are in a world of hurt if your
alternator fails. You have a limited amount of time
before your EFI system stops as well as your engine.
That is due to the high current requirements of high
pressure fuel pumps. In this case you could use a hand
pump to keep fuel supplied to a small sump tank mounted
up under the cowl.

The cost of this system everything included is less
than about $200.  The cost of an EFI system everything
included is well over a $1000.

Not to mention the intrinsic high power of a slide throttle
P-port engine.

Klause Savier has run his O-200 with something similar as a back
up to a Posa Carb.

BTW the Wright brothers used something similar.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

I think it would be great as a redundant system (no offence). I can't see it
running as efficiently as EFI but when it all goes to hell in a hand basket
it sure would be nice and there is no real weight penalty to pay.

John

Why not as efficiently as EFI?

Paul Lamar


Well perhaps with a flight engineer you might come close. Your system will
not be easy to adjust to the finite amount a computer could. The HD $7
valves work great as on/off  but I think you would find it very difficult to
adjust for economy cruise of say 9 gph or if your fancy adjusting two valves
to 4.5 gph (or X egt). A small tap might be easier (especially if it is
bumpy) or some sort of needle valve. You might also have a time lag issue
between your adjustment and the engines reaction. You also have to fly the
airplane, with EFI your computer can check the fuel a hundred times a second
and it doesn't care if it is dark, bumpy or if some controller is yacking at
you.

I would see your system as being initially set to a happy medium
mixture setting and then shut off except for testing and for when it get
very quiet. Then you just crack open the shut off valve and sit back and say
a little prayer of thanks to PL.

I also don't know that the power failure
mode or EFI failure is that common. I see the merit in your proposal and as
a redundant system it is one with with very little failure mode and very
little additional weight. Your most likely failure mode would be the
additional in cowl fuel connections and I would guess that connectors are
probably more failure prone than the EFI. I might be biased here as I have
had 9 incidents that have had me do precautionary landings, and only one
that was a forced landing and that was a fuel fitting coming off just after
T/O. Luckily it came of then, ten seconds later and I would have had to
change my name to Bob if I had survived (I hate cold water).

John

Ever fly a carb aircraft piston engine?  Lots of mixture
adjustments are required. Most of the pilots successfully flying
them are not flight engineers.

The high quality ball valve shown has a one inch circumferential
travel. If you lengthened the lever to 3 inches, which
is a stock mixture control cable travel, fine adjustments are possible.
Mixture controls have vernier adjustments.

We have had several problems with EFI systems. There is a lot more
to fail. We had one total electrical failure crash that would not have
happened if they had a carb and mag. We had another in flight fire that
burned the wires going to the electrical fuel injectors causing
the engine to quit. Fortunately the guy was on short final.

I had a boost pump fail in a Mooney and the injection engine quit with a bang.
Parts of the vanes made it to the mechanical pump and caused it
to fail. Fortunately I was over an airport and got it back on
the ground dead stick.

AN fuel plumbing is very reliable.

Dual alternators and batteries are heavy and costly.

My guess is the most reliable aircraft engine is the simplest and equipped
with carbs and magnetos not counting turbines. They are also
easy to maintain, inspect and fix by non computer gurus.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.