Subject: Combination slide throttle and carburator
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/13/2006, 4:51 PM
To: AA-me

    I think it would be great as a redundant system (no offence). I
    can't see it
    running as efficiently as EFI but when it all goes to hell in a hand
    basket
    it sure would be nice and there is no real weight penalty to pay.

    John

    Why not as efficiently as EFI?

    Paul Lamar

    Paul,
    While I like the simplicity of the idea, and believe with the right
    ramp profile it CAN work, dribble systems are never going to be as
    efficient as FI. Fuel atomization is the first reason. By its very
    nature this system can't be high pressure, it is a fixed pressure
    variable orifice system. It would have to be over rich in most of the
    mid range to be operable. Many things will run, most not very well. I
    saw a photo of a guy that got himself out of the desert of Baha after
    rolling his bug and smashing the carb. He ran the hose from the fuel
    pump into the point end of a BIC pen he pulled the guts out of. Duct
    tapped the thing over the inlet bell and it ran shoving gas out through
    the little hole on the side of the pen! He even told the press guys that
    it worked pretty well at "bout 50". Mechanical fuel pump made it a kind
    of ultra-primitive FI. The flat slide idea could be ok but never as
    precise as good FI. Perhaps as a redundant system would be its best use.

    By the way I checked and Lectron is still in business. They have some
    very sophisticated ground needle systems. They could be incorporated in
    the center of the slide throttle to improve mixture control but then
    your simplicity goes out the window. You're making a carb again. BTW the
    system WOULD be subject to icing. Though typical carb heat could be used
    with it.
    Bill Jepson

    It is not like this is a new idea. Klaus flies an Ellison
    on his O-200 and gets 50 MPH at 200 MPH. What is inefficient
    about that? Gravity feed no less. All the pumps do is fill
    the header tank. I know half a dozen people running these
    types of carbs and they are getting better MPG than we are
    with EFI.

    http://www.aeroconversions.com/carb_saying.html
    http://www.ellison-fluid-systems.com/article/notaposa/notaposa.htm
    http://revmasteraviation.com/products/revflow_injector_carburetor/index.htm

    These are becoming universal on cert engines in experimental
    airplanes because they are simple and relatively cheap.

    If you have some data or documentation to support
    your inefficient or atomization claims I liked to see it.

    EFI is not worth the high cost and the redundant electrical
    system required to make it safe.

    Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,

I think your original idea with the many small holes would work better
for atomization. That's the idea behind the Ellison fuel spray bar which
uses lots of tiny holes to achieve very fine atomization.

Regards,

Gordon.



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.