Subject: Combination slide throttle and carburator
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/14/2006, 11:39 PM
To: AA-me


>       > Paul,
>       > While I like the simplicity of the idea, and believe with the right
>       > ramp profile it CAN work, dribble systems are never going to be as
>       > efficient as FI. Fuel atomization is the first reason. By its very
>       > nature this system can't be high pressure, it is a fixed pressure
>       > variable orifice system. It would have to be over rich in most of
>      the
>       > mid range to be operable. Many things will run, most not very well. I
>       > saw a photo of a guy that got himself out of the desert of Baha after
>       > rolling his bug and smashing the carb. He ran the hose from the fuel
>       > pump into the point end of a BIC pen he pulled the guts out of. Duct
>       > tapped the thing over the inlet bell and it ran shoving gas out
>      through
>       > the little hole on the side of the pen! He even told the press
>      guys that
>       > it worked pretty well at "bout 50". Mechanical fuel pump made it
>      a kind
>       > of ultra-primitive FI. The flat slide idea could be ok but never as
>       > precise as good FI. Perhaps as a redundant system would be its
>      best use.
>       >
>       > By the way I checked and Lectron is still in business. They have some
>       > very sophisticated ground needle systems. They could be
>      incorporated in
>       > the center of the slide throttle to improve mixture control but then
>       > your simplicity goes out the window. You're making a carb again.
>      BTW the
>       > system WOULD be subject to icing. Though typical carb heat could
>      be used
>       > with it.
>       > Bill Jepson
>       >
>       > It is not like this is a new idea. Klaus flies an Ellison
>       > on his O-200 and gets 50 MPH at 200 MPH. What is inefficient
>       > about that? Gravity feed no less. All the pumps do is fill
>       > the header tank. I know half a dozen people running these
>       > types of carbs and they are getting better MPG than we are
>       > with EFI.
>       >
>       > http://www.aeroconversions.com/carb_saying.html
>       > http://www.ellison-fluid-systems.com/article/notaposa/notaposa.htm
>       >
>      http://revmasteraviation.com/products/revflow_injector_carburetor/index.htm
>      <http://revmasteraviation.com/products/revflow_injector_carburetor/index.htm>
>       >
>       > These are becoming universal on cert engines in experimental
>       > airplanes because they are simple and relatively cheap.
>       >
>       > If you have some data or documentation to support
>       > your inefficient or atomization claims I liked to see it.
>       >
>       > EFI is not worth the high cost and the redundant electrical
>       > system required to make it safe.
>       >
>       > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
>       >
>       > Paul,
>       >
>       > I think your original idea with the many small holes would work
>      better
>       > for atomization. That's the idea behind the Ellison fuel spray
>      bar which
>       > uses lots of tiny holes to achieve very fine atomization.
>       >
>       > Regards,
>       >
>       > Gordon.
>       >
> >      Paul
> >      Gordon has a good point.   A spray system, perhaps a double pipe
>      (mini tank)
>      with a built in throttle valve that controls the flow to  holes
>      drilled into
>      the P port Al. manifold pipe.  It would be placed just downstream of
>      the
>      slide throttle. This eliminates slide throttle soak.  Fuel flow
>      valves could
>      be linked to the throttle linkage  mechanically.  I think the design
>      parameters (read seal pressure friction) for handling flammable
>      liquid and
>      air are not complimentary to put in the same valve mechanism. Said
>      another
>      way the challenge would be to keep the slide press tightly against
>      the fuel
>      inlet pipe while assuring fuel traveled laterally along the slide
>      and out
>      the appropriate place while eliminating capillary action. Daunting
>      but worth
>      thinking about. It is done in rotating cylinders within a pipe all
>      the time
>      for fuel reserve and shut off valves though.
> > >      How about my linear gear on top of the slide idea I told you about
>      several
>      weeks ago? Instead of a electric motor it could be a flow
>      valve.  The same
>      rotating shaft that goes to the valve shaft goes to an arm.
>      Linkage to the
>      a lever makes the whole unit a lot more compact as well.
> >      DougFir
> > >      Have you ever dropped a drop of water on a hot frying pan?
>      What happens to the water? It becomes water vapor
>      or steam doesn't it? We are going to use exhaust heat
>      to heat the slide throttle to 150 F or there abouts.
> >      What is wrong with slide throttle soak?
>      The word soak implies that Teflon is a sponge.
>      Teflon is not a sponge.
> >      What is wrong with a little capillary action?
>      The amount of fuel going into the slide throttle and thence
>      into the P-port is controlled by the leaning ball valve. I think
>      you are missing the significance of that point.
>      The metering part of the ramp is just a crude
>      approximation so the engine will run when started
>      and accelerate to take off speed. Anything between
>      8:1 to 18:1 air/fuel the engine will start and run. Fine
>      mixture control is done by the leaning valve. You set the
>      takeoff power by running the engine up to static RPM and
>      set the mixture for max RPM. It is a good habit to get
>      into anyway in case you find yourself at a high altitude
>      airport.
> >      A grain of sand will defeat your rack and pinion.
> >      Why make it complicated? Yes I know your Seawind engine is many
>      feet from the pilot but so is a 747 engine and Boeing
>      uses throttle control cables.
> >      Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
> > > Paul.maybe you should look on Google and type in Wal Phillips....Wal was
> a eary Speedway[dirt track]rider that made a very basic injector that he
> used on a methanol-burning engine in the eary 50s the Phillips Fuel
> Injector is a very simple design.
> > Robert Pay
> > Yes. Very interesting. It certainly is a simple device.
> It varies however from the current aircraft low pressure fuel
> injection device like the Ellison  in that there is no way
> of tuning the mixture independently  of the rate of throttle
> opening. That would require another valve of some type
> in series.
> > http://www.britbike.com/ubb/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=65;t=000023;p=1
> Also it is not a slide throttle of course.
> > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no
Why not just use 2 ellison slide throttle bodies then? I
have one just need to get another one and I should be set
right? Well, if it is that easy lets talk about spark.
How do I light it off? is there any way to get a mag on
this thing in the configuration we are all mostly in. Is
there anyway to spin a mag from the oil metering pump drive
shaft? I looked at it and I think fabricating a bracket to
make that work shouldn't be to hard the only thing is, how
fast does the mag have to turn? is the ratio correct? If we
go with a magneto on the E-shaft which motorcycle will I have
to butcher to make that work? Can I use a standard aircraft
magneto?


Tony

Sure that will work. Probably only cost you $300 each
or $600. What do you do for a living over there Tony?
Do they need any help :)

Lets see a  mag fires twice per rev
on a 4 cyl AC engine which is the same as rotary.
So the 2700 RPM mag must run 7500 RPM on
a rotary. I am not sure it would be up for
that. You would be better off with a 4 cylinder
mag from a high RPM motor cycle engine if there
were such a thing.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Real estate, this is  Vega$$  you know. One good deal will net
you 7-15 grand, no lie! so 600 hundred for a couple of Ellisons
is laughable.


So are you saying there is no way  to use a mag? or one doesn't
exist that can handle the rotary, or is it a bearing thing when
you say you don't think it will handle it? what is Mistral using
is it just EI? Can we have EI and mags?

Tony

There is probably a mag out there somewhere that will work.
Sure you can have EI and a mag. You have two spark plugs
per rotor.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.