I conducted a study of the induction areas of two different throttle
mechanism. One was a 2 inch throttle body with a lever arm
arrangement
such that 3 inches of throttle cable movement was required to go
from
fully closed to fully open. The second was a slide throttle with
12 various configurations. The configuration that most closely
matched
the throttle body was the one with a 0.375 diameter metering hole
with a
0.188 fillet to the 2 inch diameter main metering hole. Rhino was
used
to generate the geometry and compute the areas.
Attached is a graph showing the induction areas of the two throttles
for
the first 1 inch of throttle cable movement from the fully closed
position. As can be seen, the slide throttle has a slightly gentler
initial opening for the first 5.8 inches of cable movement. After
about
0.6 inches of throttle cable movement, the slide throttle induction
area
increases more rapidly than the throttle body induction area.
This slide throttle configuration should give gentle throttle
response
when it is needed, e.g., taxi and approach and excellent induction
at
full power.
Doc Custer
Retired software engineer and sometime Audiologist
Building RV9-A. Fuselage
I think you mean .58 and not 5.8 Doc.
I still don't think you can compare the two like this.
Regardless of how favorable looking the slide throttle comes
out :) The butterfly is more of a three dimensional
problem. Short of 3D CFD we will never know unless
we compare RPM's or HP as a function of throttle cable
position.
Paul Lamar
Right. I slipped the decimal point. I meant 0.58.
WRT turbulence you are right. Performance data is definitive. However,
in the absence of performance data, it seems to me that area opening
data is better than none. In any event it should provide a good
starting point.
If the performance of any given slide throttle configuration is not
satisfactory it is relatively easy to make a new slide and try it in
the existing installation. It seems to me that there is no requirement
for the slide throttle to have exactly the same throttle response of
the butterfly, only that its performance be satisfactory.
Doc Custer
Retired software engineer and sometime Audiologist
Building RV9-A. Fuselage
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.