> Paul,
>
> After looking into it a bit more I have to conclude that the impulse
> turbine running at engine speed is not workable. It would have to be
> close to three feet in diameter to get good efficiency.
>
> The reason is that the impulse turbine works best at a certain
ratio of
> exhaust jet speed to wheel speed (about 0.5 or a little below). And
> since the exhaust jet is moving pretty fast due to being
accelerated by
> the nozzles in front of the turbine, the wheel speed has to be
fast too
> -- just below the speed of sound.
>
> The 11-inch turbine in NACA 786 was spinning at about 20,000 rpm or
> about 960 feet per second. The speed of the exhaust jet across the
> turbine blades at peak efficiency was 2.5 times that, or 2400 fps.
>
> It should be noted that this is the mean jet velocity, which I
assume is
> the mean of the velocity of the mass flow and the sonic wave. In the
> exhaust manifold, mass flow only moves at about 200 to 400 fps,
but the
> sonic wave moves at 1500 to 1800 fps. This is actually much
higher than
> the sea level speed of sound in the atmosphere, but the reason
for the
> high speed of the sound wave is that it's carried along by the
> fast-moving mass-flow. Also the very high temperature increases the
> speed of sound.
>
> The attached graph shows how turbine efficiency varies with the
ratio of
> mean exhaust jet speed to turbine wheel speed. We see that a
wheel speed
> of less than 0.4 in relation to the speed of the exhaust jet causes
> efficiency to fall off.
>
> The exhaust jet in the manifold probably starts out at a mean
speed of
> about 1000 fps or a little bit less. (let's say 1700 fps for the
sound
> wave plus 300 fps for the mass flow, divided by 2). But the
nozzle jets
> accelerate the flow by a factor of about 2.4, to a jet mean
velocity of
> about 2,400 fps.
>
> This is how an impulse turbine works -- it has a constant pressure
> across the turbine wheel, but the nozzles just before the buckets
> accelerate the flow, turning pressure head into velocity head.
You can
> see this pressure versus velocity relationship in the graphic
comparing
> the impulse turbine to the reaction turbine. The pressure drops
as the
> velocity increases -- this is in the nozzle, not the turbine wheel.
>
> So if we speed up our mean jet velocity to 2,400 fps, our wheel speed
> must be about 40 percent of that for good efficiency, or about
960 fps.
> An engine speed of 6,000 rpm equals 100 revolutions per second,
so our
> wheel circumference must be about 9.6 feet -- about 3 ft.diameter
That's
> obviously not workable, except maybe for a large radial engine.
>
> Yet another problem with the impulse turbine is that it seems to get
> less efficient at altitude as ambient pressure drops. We can see
this in
> the chart. The reason appears to be the pressure ratio between
the inlet
> and outlet of the turbine. At high pressure ratios (above 7), the
> turbine is less efficient.
>
> This is exactly opposite to what we want. I believe a reaction
turbine
> should go in the opposite direction, that is become more efficient at
> higher pressure ratios, because it works by pressure drop across the
> turbine blades. (I could be wrong in my understanding of that).
>
> A third possibility is an axial-flow reaction turbine which would
> probably be the most efficient of all, but this is not a common item.
>
>
http://www.barber-nichols.com/products/turbines/axial_reaction_turbines/default.asp
>
>
> You would still need a high wheel speed, even higher than an impulse
> turbine (a ratio of 0.7, compared to 0.4), so you would still need a
> reduction drive.
>
> So I think the radial-flow reaction turbine (as used on
turbochargers)
> with a reduction drive is the only workable solution for
> turbocompounding the rotary right now.
>
> However, in looking into this I have come across some very
interesting
> information on producing thrust with the exhaust jet. I will be
posting
> more on this later, but just a teaser: Would you believe a
> maximum increase of 27 percent thrust horsepower? (See attached
chart)
>
> This is just by adding the right sze nozzles to the tailpipe and
> orienting it straight back. This is incredible and could be key to
> making my idea a high-speed rotary-fan engine airplane as
efficient as a
> prop.
>
>
> Regards,
>
> Gordon.
>
>
>
> Well that is what Mark Wrathal said :)
>
> You could always gear it down 3:1 with a planetary.
> Would 18,000 RPM work?
>
> Since exhaust thrust is constant it takes a fast airplane to
> get significant HP out of it. The exhaust stacks on the P51
> were credited with a couple of hundred HP at 400 MPH however top
speed
> is proportional to the cube root of HP. The cube root of
> 1400 HP is 11.18 while the cube root of 1600 HP is 11.69
> so top speed went up from 400 MPH to 418 MPH or 4.5 %.
>
> Things are not so great down around 250 MPH.
> Paul Lamar
Hi Gordon;
I don't think things are quite as bad as you think.
From above:
> "The exhaust jet in the manifold probably starts out at a mean
speed of
> about 1000 fps or a little bit less. (let's say 1700 fps for the
sound
> wave plus 300 fps for the mass flow, divided by 2)."
I assume the exhaust mass flow is peak on the initial exhaust port open
event and
decreases until the next exhaust port opening. There will, of course,
also be high speed
sounds waves as a result of the abrupt exhaust open event on the exhaust
large ports with no valves.
Ignoring all the other port open/close events and reflections, you are
left with the mass airflow
(say 300 fps) and the concentrated exhaust port open sound wave
(condensation and rarefactions at say 1700fps).
The sound wave is a relatively short duration event. My WAG is its
duration is 5-10% of the total, possibly less).
A weighted average for the mean exhaust flow is probably in order:
300fps*.95 + 1700fps*.05 = 370 fps
300fps*.90 + 1700fps*.10 = 440 fps
This puts the size of the impulse turbine diameter in the 13-16" range
for your 40 percent wheel speed design point,
just slightly larger than the stock flywheel/flexplates and simplifying
exhaust plumbing.
I am sure that exhaust tube diameter, splitters and jetting changes
could shift this somewhat to suit.
Smaller is probably better for weight/stress reasons.
Might be worth another look.
Cheers
Cary
http://www.rotaryeng.net/Turbo-compound2-3D.jpg
Thanks, Carey.
I haven't given up on the impulse wheel idea. However, it is going
to take some good data on exhaust pressures and pressure waves to
really know what's going on.
Regards,
Gordon.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.