Subject: The turbo prop verses the turbo compound rotary.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/28/2006, 6:56 PM
To: AA-me



        Paul,

        I wonder if you are focusing on the bearings in the planetary
        shafts? Then
        you would have a point. They would be doing elliptical loops
   around a
        circle.

        I'll go down to the office tomorrow and paint some white marks
   on the
        different gears and take four or five pictures of what happens
        during one
        revolution of the sun gear. Like the rotary it was hard to get
   my head
        around. This question is going to come up again and again so
   with Rolf's
        explanations and picture proof it would make a good addition to
   your
        website.

        Meanwhile have a look at this NASA report on unducted fans. The
   last
        part is
        especially revealing about the issues that keep a 'good
   technology' from
        coming to market. The author speaks about 'reverse salient issues'
        Poignant info concerning the rotary and even the rotary turbo
   compound.

        http://history.nasa.gov/SP-4219/Chapter14.html

        DougFir

        They underestimated the noise problem. Barely mentioned in this
        paper. It was so bad that it affected the structure of the
        airplane. GE felt they would have to add weight and cost to the
        AC structure to counter the noise problem which off set the
        20% fuel savings. BTW the fact that GE actually built
        and flew the unducted fan full scale yet again proves private
        innovation beats big gov bureaucracy every time.

        Not really a good analogy with the turbo compound rotary.
        There are no downsides to the turbo compound rotary compared
        the smaller turbo prop engines. It has everything going for it with
        the SAME noise. Less acquisition cost being a major advantage.
        50% fuel savings being another. Only the weight issue is still
        in question and the other shoe, namely the weight of an all
        aluminum or some other alloy large rotary, has not dropped yet.

        The real price of fuel over the years on average taking
        into consideration inflation has remained pretty much the same.
        What happened in 1973 as the price of fuel oil went up so did
        everything else including wages. When I was a kid the cost of a
   loaf
        of bread was about 20 cents, about the same as a gallon of fuel.
        Now the cost of a loaf of bread is still about the same as
        a gallon of fuel. If anything bread is now probably more
        costly. Hybrid car sales are down if not dying.

        I see no end to this cycle in our life time. Since Iraq is sitting
        on the worlds second largest known reserves of crude oil
        when they finally get finished killing each other off and this
        huge source of crude is fully developed the real price will
        drop yet again. IMHO a major factor, frequently not mentioned
        in the sectarian war, is who gets to control the Iraq oil.

        Waiting in the wings when crude oil pumped from the ground actually
        (if ever) becomes a reduced source (hasn't happened yet) is the
        Alberta, Utah, Wyoming tar sands.

        Paul Lamar

        Oops, forgot to attach the pic of the NASA and GE propfans.

        Regards,

        Gordon.

   The two on the right are actually the GE concept
   and not the NASA concept despite the NASA logo on the
   cowl. I saw the test airliner with the unducted fan on it
   out at Mojave where GE has a full scale test facility.
   Unfortunately I did not hear it run.

   Paul Lamar


I think I heard/saw it run (in flight).  I was a kid, so I didn't have
much to compare it to, but I recall that it made a strange warbling,
screeching, groaning sound.  Maybe like having your ear right next to a
skill saw going through MDF.  And was VERY loud.  Soon after, I saw a
harrier fly at Oshkosh, and it seemed comparably loud even though I was
significantly closer to the harrier.  Obviously a very different sound -
qualitatively.


Matt-

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.