Subject: Engine failure on climbout (was Re: Mazda engine crashes]
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 1/9/2007, 9:27 AM
To: AARotary Engine


<snip>
> Yes, I knew the problem was an attempted RTLS following engine out.  I
> was taught that if the engine failed below 4000AGL on climbout, I had to
> pick my spot from what was visible through the windscreen -- the plane> was too heavy, too low and had no energy for a turn back to the runway.
>
> Keith

I'm guessing that 4000 is a typo.  Did you mean 400'?

Al


I was taught, and confirmed by numerous articles, that 1,000 feet is
the minimum height for most small aircraft.  Even with ideal
circumstances and early responses, 1,000 feet may not be enough to get
back to the runway, and is often more risky than picking a landing site
from the front windshield. I'd imagine this is even more true with a
new, experimental a/c.

This height is 200' for many gliders, and is commonly practiced as a
tow-rope break scenario.  Even with a sink rate of less than 400'/min,
turning a glider around at 200' is a very unnerving exercise.

I don't suggest that you try the 1000AGL thing in real life in anything
other than a sailplane.

That sink rate is for OPTIMUM angle of attack.  That means level wings,
perfectly at the center of CG, calm air.

At gross, power off, in climb attitude, making downwind turns, your
production plane isn't going to go as far as the book says their test
pilot got when he tried it from level flight with half fuel and half
load.  It just isn't going to happen.

You're going to lose time and altitude just figuring out that you have a
problem.  Meanwhile, you're going AWAY from the runway at over 100 feet
per second in a Cessna 150.  By the time you've checked all the stuff
that should keep you in the air, decided to turn around and made sure
there isn't someone turning into your intended flightpath, you're
another half mile away and probably 1000 feet lower than when things got
quiet.

At 3000 (4000 minus 1000 lost), you can spend that with reasonable
assurance of getting back safely.  At 1000 or even 2000, you're about to
test your ELT.

Check the NTSB database for all the guys who tried to turn back.  Look
at the estimated altitudes.  Those altitudes are where he was when he
was NOTICED.  That means when you see "1000AGL," he was actually higher
than that when his day turned to worms, but nobody was watching him
until they noticed that he was in trouble.

Keith


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.