Subject: Make your own e-shaft
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/6/2007, 8:07 PM
To: AARotary Engine


>> > I am reposting my last msg from a couple days
ago;
>> it
>> > seems to have been lost.
>> >
>> >
>> > Rolf, Bill and Kenneth
>> > Thought I would give one more try on this
subject.
>> If
>> > it is possible to operate lobes and journals
with
>> a
>> > thin wall of .06" min, then the min dia of the
>> spline
>> > approaches 1.47" [1.69-2(.06)-.098] which meets
>> Rolfs
>> > stress criteria at 415#', without the torque
>> ripple
>> > factor. My question is simple; is this wall too
>> thin?
>> >
>> >
>> > Kenneth
>> > Have you addressed the rather large tapped
holes
>> > required for the oil squirt jets? Seems they
would
>> > take away a lot of the shaft cross section
area.
>> >
>> > regards, Robert
>> >
>>
>> Wait a minute...
>>
>> Is it possible that you meant to spline the
>> eccentric lobe onto the
>> e-shaft?
>> Is that what you had in mind???
>>
>> If so, please don't even try. It will not work.
>> In order to make the narrow side of the lobe
strong
>> enough, the e-shaft
>> will be too weak to carry the load.
>> You have now two members that each must carry the
>> same torque within the
>> same space restraints.
>> Don't forget there is also bending on the
e-shaft,
>> not just torque. The
>> highest bending stress is under the lobe.
>>
>> Rolf
>>  >
> Rolf
> That is certainly my understanding from the
initial
> description. However Kenneth has pointed out that
the
> eshaft is supported on each side of the lobe by
> bearings. It would seem to me that the bending
forces
> would appear to the short supported eshaft section
as
> shear forces. Disregarding the torsional forces
for
> the sake of discussion.
> This brings me to ask you about a comparison of
axle
> shafts vs this splined eshaft in particular. Axles
of
> similar size to this proposed eshaft will handle
large
> amounts of torque, but it is my understanding they
do
> so by allowing windup. This would be undesirable
for
> any eshaft. So does the stress criteria you stated
> earlier apply directly to axles? Or is it an
entirely
> different situation to allow windup?
> regards, Robert


> An axle will not accept any more torque due to its
> length compared to any other shaft. Angular
deflection in
> a long shaft has nothing to do with maximum
stress. The windup
> stores torsional shock loads and returns them to
the system when
> the shock load is over with. Peak torque is peak
torque.
>
>  http://library.wolfram.com/examples/Problem3/
>
> The worst feature of this design is the stress
concentrations
> in the root of the splines. That leads to cracks
and fatique.
> But by all means build it and test it. I suspect
it will break
> long before you get around to flying it.
>
 > Paul Lamar


Robert,

My comments were meant to raise awareness and
concerns.
By all means, build it and see what happens.

Technically, you are talking many different things
here.
Looking at shear, the load of the piston at maximum
gas pressure is near
27,000 to 32,000 lbs.
245.5 cm^2 * 50 to 60 bar = 12275 to 14700 kg *
2.205 = 27,060 to 32,480
lbs total.
At a high charging rate it is even more.

In the case of the e-shaft, we have combined
stresses of shear, bending
and torque.
As a good approximation, two forces are added
quadratically, meaning
sqrt ( A^2 + B^2)
Or in this case sqrt ( A^2 + B^2 + C^2 ). But that
is not necessarily
correct.
To be precise an analysis of the time and angle of
these three forces
must be made. Not that easy.

Regarding storing energy through wind up, yes that
is occurring.
Heat will be introduced and most importantly, the
stiffness or rather
self frequency of the shaft must be known
together with the input cycle of the forces. But
this applies to longer
shafts only.

Axle shafts just carry torque, no bending and no
shear. Different
situation to an e-shaft.

The e-shaft when weakened as proposed, should also
be checked for its
own frequency.
Being much weaker, more deflection is being
introduced which is a key
enemy of the Wankel engine.
Any vibration may lead to the so called chatter
marks. That may be
encountered with a weak shaft.

Enough said, try it anyway.

Regards
Rolf

PS. For 2000 inlbs of torque I get 377 psi for the
example you send. He
calculates 296 psi.
The low number is unrealistic for steel or practical
engineering. The
shaft may be wood or plastic.
The length is irrelevant if no material and its
G-module is given.



Gentlemen
I was skeptical of the shaft strength from the
beginning. You have pointed out in detail the
weaknesses and as I said: last try. I have no further
interest in it.
regards, Robert



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.