Subject: How to add a P-port to the RX8 and keep the EPA happy.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/7/2007, 12:41 PM
To: AARotary Engine <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>, Aden Lindsay <aden@iinet.net.au>, Archie Frangoudis <archie97@earthlink.net>, Barry Gardner <barrygardner@gmail.com>, Bill Hyde <billhyde@bellsouth.net>, Bill Phillips <bphillips@energy.com.au>, "Boyum, Patrick L." <Boyum.Patrick@mayo.edu>, Brian Lee <tau-r@concentric.net>, Bruce Ryan <bruceryan@email.msn.com>, Colin Smith <cmsmith@bravo.net.au>, Don Tauer <dtauer@alltel.net>, Ernesto Sanchez <res0391z@gte.net>, Francois St-Germain <cgtyy@yahoo.ca>, Fred Breeze <Brecab@bellsouth.net>, Fred Osborn <fosborn@infowest.com>, GW <gw.acre@shaw.ca>, Bruce Toski <agent007@doitnow.com>, Jeff Andre <jandre@secondlookhomes.com>, Jerzy Krasinski <krasins@ceat.okstate.edu>, Jim Ahman <ahmanrv4@comcast.net>, John Bullers <midwestinfo@yahoo.com>, John Gibbons <jorogi@shaw.ca>, "Jr, Mt" <n82630@yahoo.com>, Ken Welter <rotary.coot@verizon.net>, Jacob Link <jacobjlink@yahoo.com>, Tracy Crook <lors01@msn.com>, Mike Perry <mkperry99@cfl.rr.com>, Patrick Stapelberg <patrick.stapelberg@elco.co.za>, Perry Mick <pjmick@verizon.net>, dave ruiz <daveruiz50@yahoo.com>, Rino Lacombe <lacombr@nbnet.nb.ca>, Robin Ream <robinream@earthlink.net>, Tom Mondelci <tomm@4norpro.com>, "Rogers, Bob J." <BRogers@FDIC.gov>, Rolf Pfeiffer <rpfeiffer@rogers.com>, "Rosine, Steve" <steve.rosine@itt.com>, Royce Wise <royce@wayxcable.com>, Russell Kent <r-kent@ti.com>, Scott Gettings <sgettings@cfl.rr.com>, victor delta <vdelta@pacbell.net>, William Frymark <wfrymark@mac.com>, Ronald Freier <rf7928@earthlink.net>, skydoc <skydoc@wheatstate.com>, Chuck Dunlap <crayd@cableone.net>, RV7 builder <mcsophie@gmail.com>, Andy Moore <amoore@edge.net>, Paul Brannon <fpbjr2001@yahoo.com>, Ken Knevel <ken_iberville@msn.com>, Del Ralston <drals1234@adelphia.net>, "Karl R. Szczypta" <karl_s@msn.com>, James Freeman <MadScientist@covad.net>, Ron Morrison <rmrrisn@flash.net>, Bruce Rosowfske <bruce@rs-ins.com>, Ben Baltrusaitis <ben@gmpexpress.net>, Vince Orton <vorton@pacstates.com>, Luc Hermange <4luc@sbcglobal.net>, Michael <mldsub@earthlink.net>, John Andrich <andrichjj@yahoo.com>, G Taylor <686012@ican.net>, Doug Mueller <rotaryrx6@cox.net>, max mcclure <vmmcclur@msn.com>, Roger Enns <renns_99@yahoo.com>, Bob Bonhomie <boberrorusa@cox.net>, Randall Semrau <rsemrau@shaw.ca>, steve sprunger <sprungz@earthlink.net>, Jack Beale <jack.beale@att.net>, James Bailey <jamesbailey40@yahoo.com>, Butch <AVIONAGUJA@att.net>, Bill Garrett <bgarrett920@comcast.net>, Edward Klepeis <techwelding@comcast.net>, Jeremy Solomon <jmsolomon@optonline.net>, The Wilenius Family <wilenius@rogers.com>, sis co <sisco@arn.net>, mark supinski <mark.supinski@gmail.com>, Fred Skalicky <FredSkalicky@msn.com>, "Todd TC. Carrico" <todd@thecarricos.com>, Vaughn Mann <vlmann@bellsouth.net>, dennis altman <shupack@yahoo.com>, Bob White <bob@bob-white.com>, Terry Adams <terrywadams@sbcglobal.net>, "Joe Hull (Pilgrim Technologies)" <joeh@pilgrimtech.com>, John Pletting <johnp@pletting.com>, Byron & Jean Buckingham <byronjean@jefnet.com>, august schell <augustschell@email.msn.com>, Robert Vanzant <rvanzant@busynet.net>, Doug Raupp <dougr@mitchellair.com>, tim tracey <dragonridge@yahoo.com>, Reeves Callaway <erc3@mac.com>, Javier <mary03@msn.com>, ray johnson <johnogr@dcsi.net.au>, james coffman <jimcoffmanus@yahoo.com>, greg 3 <greg@itmack.com>, george wright <george.wright6@verizon.net>, gary <pojee@sbcglobal.net>, Hurant Karibian <hkaribian@yahoo.com>, John Vlake <javlakeca@yahoo.ca>, Flyer <flyer@unamuno.org>, Ernest And Jane Deel <ernieandjane@naxs.net>, Attila Melkuti <amvaircraft@cox.net>, Walter Williams <wgw75@bresnan.net>, "Decker, Michael" <MDecker@onelambda.com>, Chris Cosman <ccosman@comcast.net>, c denoncourt <fwd25@yahoo.com>, Mr Robert Geis <regeis55@yahoo.com>, "Lemings, Bob" <lemingsr@msn.com>, ray fiset <rayfiset@qc.aira.com>, Warren Leavitt <av8or@usa.com>, Bob & Ellie <bobellie@dctexas.net>, brent 2 <brent@hasty-solutions.com>, Eric Ruttan <ruttan@tridentfinancial.biz>, Mark Steitle <msteitle@mail.utexas.edu>, Steve Thomas <steve@stevet.net>, Eneabba Smash <esmash@wn.com.au>, Mark 5 <abstane@yahoo.com>, Les Orosz <lmorosz@bellsouth.net>, DALE HARVEY <DHARVEY564@msn.com>, Robert Hammond <robertlhammond@yahoo.com>, Philippe <philippe.chenevier@wanadoo.fr>, "Brian D. Cain" <bdc196@comcast.net>, "David A. Custer2" <dacuster@wmv-co.us>, Dave Cronin Mistral Engines <d.cronin@mistral-engines.com>, Wayne Bulgerin <whatsupdoc31@hotmail.com>, jeff downing <bytmee@gte.net>, Mike Arnt <kingmrmike@hotmail.com>, Harry Batson <harrydb@hotmail.com>, Jim and Lucy <jpollard@ciaccess.com>, Robert Leclercq <rcl41244@yahoo.com>, Michael McGee <jmpcrftr@teleport.com>, "Weinstock, Rob" <weinstro@hotmail.com>, Dave Arbogast <dave@arb.net>, Jim Brewer <alpha@concordnc.com>, Dean Head <potato@bellsouth.net>, Brian Sieber <Brian@RXtuner.com>, Larry Hendrix <larry_hendrix@charter.net>, Bruce Beck <simbec@earthlink.net>, CSMALE <smale@ncinternet.net>, d renaker <drenaker@insightbb.com>, Bill Siegel <bsiegel@adelphia.net>, Steve Webre <stevewebre@ccaconsultants.net>, "Steere, John" <JSteere@harmanbecker.com>, Dean <dvanwinkle@royell.net>, Gary V <corinth@amtelecom.net>, JAMES HOLM <JHOLM4013@MSN.COM>, Geraldine Berger-Yvon Cournoyer <geryvon@videotron.ca>, Erik Wahlstrom <erikwal@sbcglobal.net>, =?ISO-8859-1?Q?Fran=E7ois_Bado?= =?ISO-8859-1?Q?ux?= <f.badoux@mistral-engines.com>, Ray Cole <raycole@bellsouth.net>, Paul Vermillion <Paulo264@cox.net>, "Howard strope Jr." <Hstrope3@nycap.rr.com>, RJS <pilotbob@rogers.com>, frank barbot <frankbarbot@hotmail.com>, Allen Ervin <scorpion472@comcast.net>, Rick Irwin <Rick@edgeproducts.com>, Marcello Grigorov <marcello.grigorov@hispeed.ch>, John Wolding <johnwolding@hotmail.com>, David Mathes <dmath777@yahoo.com>, George Payne <g.payne@rotaryengines.ca>, Ian <kiltman@rogers.com>, Jerry Hey <jerryhey@earthlink.net>, "Douglas R. Fix" <douglasrfix@prairieobserver.com>, Richard Sohn <unicorn@gdsys.net>, Mike Little <mlittle@surfside.net>, Allen Slominski <allenslominski@yahoo.com>, peter morrison <pm_9755@hotmail.com>, Rick Bettmeng <bettmeng@sbcglobal.net>, WL VANCE <lndftdmnd@nethere.com>, Remi Khu <morpheous@kc.rr.com>, jesse farr <jesse@jessfarr.com>, Daniel Clark <dclark@nwlink.com>, Marc Pedings <pedings@gmail.com>, David Leonard <wdleonard@gmail.com>, Guerdon Mitchell <guerdonmitchell@yahoo.com>, Dennis Himmler <dhimmler@comcast.net>, Will James <will@jamesaircraft.com>, Blake Lewis <blake.lewis@gmail.com>, Ed Pogue <ed.pogue@gmail.com>, LongEZ Tony <tonyslongez@cox.net>, Mark Wrathall <wrathall@aon.at>, Geir Anderson <flybush@hotmail.com>, Fred Kessler <acfkessler@cox.net>, Todd Archer <archerw@ubtanet.com>, Robert Sando <rgscomputers@hotmail.com>, VIRGIL N SALISBURY <virgnvs@juno.com>, Aubrey Thompson <athomp58@bellsouth.net>, Harold Kovac <kayce33@earthlink.net>, Peter Godden <peterg@bsr.com.au>, Robert Wright <rwright@gmail.com>, Andrew Sullivan <andrew@frontier.net>, Edward Sadler <pebvjs@gmail.com>, Hans-Heinrich Duensing <Hans-Heinrich.Duensing@onlinehome.de>, Tom Kimsey <kimseyco@gmail.com>, Ram Gogineni <sgogineni@hotmail.com>, Andrew Martin <apmartin@martinag.com.au>, Tom McCormick <tomthecomputerguy@yahoo.com>, Terry Barger <tabarg@gmail.com>, Joe Graham <ezbldr@gmail.com>, John McAvoy <waiter@iflyez.com>, Al Dunn <wallwalker500@yahoo.com>, vincent robertson <vandbrobertson@gmail.com>, R Matt Doody <rmattd123@yahoo.com>, Jim Springer <jim@sixspringers.com>, Jarrett & Heidi Johnson <hjjohnson@sasktel.net>, John Bell <aerobatt7@netscape.net>, Geoff GWP Design <gwpdesign@lineone.net>, Michael White <rv8rmoose@comcast.net>, Will Simmons <wsimmons3@gmail.com>, "Spencer W. Robinson" <swrobinson@prodigy.net>, Clifton 2 <bm2younger@tmo.blackberry.net>, Joseph Seays <jseays@yahoo.com>, JASON PATTON <pattonministries@yahoo.com>, Joe Berki <jskmberki@alltel.net>, Zeke Smith <psmith@napanet.net>, Barber Law Firm <CBarber@TexasAttorney.net>, Christoph Tomasson <ctomasson@gmail.com>, eh Kerr <atlas1941ehkerr@yahoo.com>, Marc Cook <marc@kitplanes.com>, ANTHONY AMBROSIO <aambro@worldnet.att.net>, Matthew Webber <mattywebber@yahoo.com>, Dave Myth <myth55@netzero.net>, Brian Beaton <briangbeaton@hotmail.com>, "Sharpe, Tim" <Tim.Sharpe@disa.mil>, Ken Powell <kenpowell@comcast.net>, Tim Tracey <ceratotheriumsapien@yahoo.com>, Todd Springer <springertj@hotmail.com>, Ralph S Bruner <RSBruner@hotmail.com>, Jim Beckman <Jim@NewEcologySystems.com>, JAMES J BAIRD <taildrager@verizon.net>, monty powers <powersmo@yahoo.com>, Jean-Pierre Ducharme <jp.ducharme@videotron.ca>, "John K.Lewis" <johnklewis@adelphia.net>, Andre Abreu <andre_abreu_2000@yahoo.com>, GLEN T ROSEL <gdrosel@sbcglobal.net>, Russell Aman <raman@fmtc.com>, Ian Beadle <iwbeadle@bigpond.com>, Tom Parkes <tkpark@cableone.net>, EDWARD MICHAELS <emichaels@prodigy.net>, Giffen A Marr <gamarr@charter.net>, Roberto Costa <sirehoufalize@yahoo.com.br>, "r.w.forbes" <rwforbes@slic.com>, Ed Moreno <emoreno1@cox-internet.com>, Brian Trubee <bktrub@yahoo.com>, ray atkinson <raybot@comcast.net>, peter beddows <pnbeddows@googlemail.com>, Clarence Sams <whitsams@earthlink.net>, Steve Yogi Behr <yogisod@hotmail.com>, GLENN CROWDER <gcrowder2@hotmail.com>, Gary Buster <gary.buster@suddenlink.net>, mark waldron <waldronm@hotmail.com>, Bob Young <Beyoung777@aol.com>, Gary Wise <Wiseguy910@aol.com>, Henry Vogt <vogthenry@yahoo.ca>, Bill Jepson <WRJJRS@aol.com>, John & Llewella <jl_evans@optusnet.com.au>, Doug Johnson <dougjnsn@midsouth.rr.com>, Norman DeBoer <nmbmbdeboer@msn.com>, shoni ben cnaan <shonim@walla.com>, Andy Hecker <ahecker@satx.rr.com>, Bo Mears <admin@lotsacars.com>, Thomas Rebhan <T.Rebhan@gmx.net>, "Marinus B. (Ben) Bosma" <ben@bosma.com>, Matt Prather 2 <ezeflierid@gmail.com>, Ron Simard <ronsnxt7@gmail.com>, John Dinkel <eleven-tenths@cox.net>, "Michael A. Jerger" <michaeljerger@hotmail.com>, Joel Mayhall <jmay2174@yahoo.com>, Alan Cameron <alancameron69@yahoo.com>, William Doell <wellnessdoc33@yahoo.com>, Dave Gaze <david@corporatesystems.com.au>, Jonathan <jrimington@creativedirector.com>, Jose Lopez <jglopez1984@yahoo.com>, keith stevens <keith909@comcast.net>, Bill Dube 2 <william.p.dube@noaa.gov>, Cole Chandler <ccchandler@bresnan.net>, Cary Beazley <cbeazley@magma.ca>, "Kevin K. Wong " <kwong@stonecracker.com>, Larry Wade <lawrencewade@att.net>, Ed Brady <ebradyirma@gmail.com>, John with LowcountryData <john@lowcountrydata.com>, Grant Johnson 2 <johnsongrant2@qwest.net>, Philip Groelz <pgroelz@yahoo.com>, Marc Wiese <cardmarc@charter.net>, "Alfonso J. Lebron-Berges" <alebron@bellsouth.net>, Mike Parker <mdparker9a@msn.com>, Kevin Richey 2 <kbr1954@yahoo.com>, Dan Grunspan <danielgrunspan@gmail.com>, Francisco Fuentes <franfuan@hotmail.com>, "E. Thompson" <xactyl@yahoo.com>, "Clint \"Sandy\" McNabb" <mink@cebridge.net>, Bryden and Bill Shiells <bshiells@xtra.co.nz>, DrCastro <alohatur@uol.com.br>, Rick Pitts <drp@kuskoae.com>, Dan Kidd <dkidd@pivot.net>, Paul Kvernplassen <k11@kvernplassen.com>, "Letempt, Jeffrey MR" <jeffrey.letempt@us.army.mil>, tony milko <t.milko@excite.com>, njomo knyata <njomo_k@hotmail.com>, Steve Reed <jefl@aol.com>, robert pay <robertpay@gmail.com>, DAVID BARKER <david_barker@MSN.COM>, george lendich <lendich@optusnet.com.au>, Rolland Savoie <rollandsavoie@yahoo.com>, Donald Gordon <donaldgordon@bellsouth.net>, Heath Holbrook <heath.holbrook@charter.net>, Terry Wilson <tswilson123@gmail.com>, Michael Francisco <coachwoody@gmail.com>, Charles Tucker <xtucker@charter.net>, "Shirley, Lloyd" <lshirley@upci.org>, Adrian Eley <adrian.eley@verizon.net>, David D Custer PhD <ddcuster@wmv-co.us>, Bill Schertz <wschertz@comcast.net>, Richard Craig <cozyflyr@aol.com>, Jeffrey Martin <dogshed@gmail.com>, Paul Lipps2 <elippse@sbcglobal.net>, Graham <gma@printtech.co.nz>, "Detty, David W" <detty@BATTELLE.ORG>, Baz Mayne <bazmay@scsn.com.au>, "EXT-Schurr, Larry" <larry.schurr@spiritaero.com>, James Just <jpjust.aviator@gmail.com>, Eytan Givon <egivon@gmail.com>, Giuseppe De Cristofaro <josef85@gmail.com>, "Ruben O. Valle" <ruben@aeroalcool.com.br>, Ernest Magallon-Graineau <ermagallon@free.fr>, meat <meat@cobratrader.com>, Daniel Oshiro <danielmoshiro@hotmail.com>, Eric 2 <ericmpmail-rotary@yahoo.com>, david mccandless <daval@iprimus.com.au>, Mel Avery <melavery2@comcast.net>, PERRY HARRIS N801YS <n801yz@insightbb.com>, Gordon Arnaut 3 <goarnaut@yahoo.com>, Rubert ASIAN AUTO SPARES <asian198@bigpond.net.au>, Norm Farb 2 <stephen@minetfiber.com>, Thomas Gadd <ThomasGadd@Comcast.net>, Sven Nielsen NRS ceramic seals <nrsrotorsports@shaw.ca>, J Smith <jsmith310@cox.net>, John Prendergast <jprender2@yahoo.com>, Jared Humphrey <odinn84@yahoo.com>, Stephen Roth Embry Riddle <stephen.roth@erau.edu>, Bryan <bhcishere@comcast.net>, Milo Burrows <bmb2002@ywave.com>, Larry Graham <raunch_n_roll@msn.com>, Al Gietzen <ALVentures@cox.net>, Dezso Molnar <dezsom@gmail.com>, Paul Chang <surfpac@gmail.com>, Burck Hantel <ab.hantel@gmail.com>, retxab <wingnut1a@excite.com>, Erik Snyman <erik@xsinet.co.za>, Ken Bauman <kennybauman@gmail.com>, Scott Moore <Junoflydog1@aol.com>, Alex Rose <a.rose2@comcast.net>, George Ulicny <ulicnyp001@hawaii.rr.com>, HERB HILL <hhill458@msn.com>, Anthony Liberatore <aliberatore@comcast.net>, tkplane tomakro <tkplane@yahoo.com>, "E. Morcillo" <enriquemorcillo@yahoo.com>, Mark Ladewig <markl999@comcast.net>, Donald Willard Garrett <nospam@avamail.net>, Kenneth McKenzie <tennek@shaw.ca>, Roderick Scotto <roderick.scotto@gmail.com>, =?ISO-8859-1?Q?=22Melih_=5C=22Ta=FFfffffffffffeyanar=5C=22=22?= <mtasyanar@yahoo.com>, Wayne LeTendre <wayneletendre@hughes.net>, Dustin Eward <emptythemagazine@gmail.com>, Harley <harley@agelesswings.com>, Vic LaRocca <vlarocc@swbell.net>, N88FW <N88fw@aol.com>, dan stanzione <dfstanzione@yahoo.com>, Stevi <stevei@carey.wa.edu.au>, Dale Williams <dwilliams@vymac.com>, Thomas Phy <thomphy@msn.com>, HARLAN NELSON <nelson6029@msn.com>, Duane Service <dservice@comcast.net>, kevin lane <n3773@comcast.net>, "Mr . Bryan Wilkinson jr." <bryan@bry5000.uklinux.net>, "Ted (Tudor Miron) in Moscow" <nevaracing@mail.ru>, Cameron <cameron@pmt.org>, Brother mark <Brothermark03@aol.com>, dmoreno <dmoreno1@cox-internet.com>, FRANK R CLEMENTI <frcmerganzer@verizon.net>, Davis Family <famdavis@suddenlink.net>, ej neil <ejneil@sonic.net>, Keith 3 <graphotypist@tagwagon.com>, Bulent Aliev <atlasyts@bellsouth.net>, Matt Olson <matt0@ozu.es>, Jim Hartung <jimandcarol@gmail.com>, Alagbaoso chibuzor <lagborcv2@yahoo.com>, rp pages <page@japan.email.ne.jp>, Marlin Olson <olyolson1@earthlink.net>, saleh <saleh11one@yahoo.com>, todd russell <russell_todd@hotmail.com>, TOny disclosed <rx7glory@msn.com>, Ned Nikic <luke2034@gmail.com>, Steven Smith <steve5248@hotmail.com>, david young <day6van@yahoo.com>, Bob Cataldo <vicbobc@bellsouth.net>, mohan kumar <flytechnic@yahoo.com>, edward jordan <ejordan908076@yahoo.com>, Douglas Fir <fir@gol.com>




 > This is in addition to the side ports.
 > Basically what we are doing here is pivoting a section
 > of the rotor housing trochoid wear surface up while
 > opening a large P-port.
 >
 > It only opens at full throttle and
 > high RPM. Over 6000 RPM. The rest of the time it seals
 > the exhaust gas from the intake ports for smooth low RPM
 > running and low HC emissions. Just like the current
 > RX8 engine. No port overlap at low RPM.
 >
 > On a 16B this would be spectacular. My guess
 > is somewhere close to 400 HP. A real Corvette
 > eater for half the price and no increase in RX8 weight.
 >
 > -----------------------------------------------
 > I redid the 3D for hopefully a clearer picture.
 > Second attachment.
 >
 > This will work on an RX8 engine as well. My guess is
 > 300 HP while still meeting all EPA regulations.
 > I call it the Trap Door P-port.
 >
 > -- > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Three questions Paul,

How do you seal it ?
How do you bolt the sandwich together in that area ?
At what point do you reach max VE ? There must be some point where air
stream
velocity gets low enough to cancel out the advantage of increased cross
sectional area.

Cool idea though and simpler than some other ideas.

John


Does not need to be sealed as the pressure differences inside the
rotor housing are minimal in this area. As the apex seal
passes the top of the trap door that is when the
compression chamber starts to work and the pressure builds up.

Since the pressure is so low in that area fewer tension bolts
need to be used. The trap door pivot could be concentric
with one tension bolt.

I don't know the answer to the last question but I do know
a p-port is worth a 20% higher VE than side ports. Hence
more power. I suspect it is due to forcing the side port air to
make right angle turns while the P-port is a straight shot in.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,
I thought about this idea some time back but considered it such major
surgery that
I figured it would never fly. I thought that a sliding plate in a
dovetail constraint would
be the best solution. Another thought was that wouldn't it be better to
pivot or slide
the the door DOWN rather than up as this would give more benign timing
to the P-port?
Also pivoting or sliding the door down would the least overlap exhaust
back flow. The
true ultimate system would be a radiused slide that would leave the
inner surface
as unaffected as possible. My 2 cents worth.
Bill Jepson

---------------------------------------------------

I agree it will never fly nor should it. It is something Mazda
should do for car engines. Also it has nothing to do with
throttling the air going into the P-port. It snaps
fully open at say 6000 RPM and stays open until red line. It
snaps closed when the RPM drops below 6000 RPM. All throttling
of air is done by the stock fly by wire throttle body.
It is intended to improve the VE and add p-port power to an
engine that is saddled with all side ports due to emissions
regulations.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Let me throw in a comment of caution on combining side and p ports. I had that idea on the single rotor for improving the idle limits. The engine run fine with either side port or pp by them selfs, however, as soon as I opened both there was rough running at different RPMs. I came to the conclusion, idle was not an issue in my case, and did not persue the issue any further.

Richard Sohn
N2071U
unicorn@gdsys.net

It may be necessary for the computer to shut off the air
supply to the side ports while the p-port is open.
-----------------------------------------------------

Here are the latest 3D's I hope they are clear.
I am getting ready to add this to the web site.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.