Subject: Superchargers and Efficiency
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/9/2007, 7:25 PM
To: AARotary Engine




        ...snip,


        Paul,

        While on the supercharger subject: a fellow on a Yahoo list is
        experimenting with a 1/2 turbocharger. He removed the broken
   exhaust
        side, and added a cog belt drive -stepup 1:10 ratio- in it`s
   place. He
        only wants 2-5 psi, so the compressor speed is adequate.

        A really cheap supercharger.

        Do you think such a concept will be (remotely) efficient and
   workable?

        -
        Erik Snyman
        Messina
        South Africa.

        You pay a fuel penalty with all super chargers as opposed
        to turbo chargers. All the HP to drive the supercharger
        comes from the net mechanical HP of the engine. In other words
        if your super charged engine is generating 200 HP net at the
        e-shaft the engine is burning 220 HP worth of fuel.
        The BSFC does not change. At a BSFC of .5 the fuel burn
        is 110 pounds an hour or 18.33 GPH.

        If your turbo charged engine is making the same net 200 HP
        at the shaft the engine is burning only 205 HP worth of
        fuel or 102.5 pounds or 17.08 GPH. The supercharger is
        costing you over 1.3 GPH in this case. The reason is the
        turbo charger is extracting otherwise waste
        HP from the exhaust. A step towards turbo compounding.
        It gets even better at altitude for the turbo charger.

        Note the efficiency of just the compressor is the same
        in both cases because he is using the same compressor.
        Centrifugal compressor efficiencies are the highest in
        the compressor industry. Also the mechanical drive for the
        super charger is not 100% efficient. If the compressor is 80%
        efficient and the drive 98% efficient the overall super charger
        is only .98 times .8 or 78.4 % efficient.

        Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

        Paul,

        A turbocharged engine is more fuel efficient than a supercharged
        engine, as you said.

        However, that's not the whole story for airplane efficiency. A
        supercharged airplane can be more fuel efficient than a normally
        aspirated plane -- although not quite as efficient as a turbo
   plane.

        The reason is that a supercharged engine can let us to fly at
   higher
        altitudes where dynamic pressure is lower, so we can fly faster at
        lower power level. This results in more range for the amount of
   fuel
        burned, or better miles per gallon.

        Let's take a Cessna 182 for example, which has a 230 hp engine and
        cruises at about 145 knots at 8000 feet at 75 percent engine
   power.

        Dynamic pressure at that speed and altitude is 55 pounds per square
        foot. The 182 has an equivalent flat plate area of about 5.5 sq-ft,
        so total drag is 302.5 lbs.

        With a supercharged engine we can cruise easily at 16,000 where
        dynamic pressure is only 42 psf at the same 145 knots. Our total
        drag is only 231 pounds. We can reduce power to about 55 percent to
        fly the same speed.

        Even though it is costing us a little bit of power to run the
        supercharger, the reduced power setting more than makes up for it.

        We can run through the numbers quickly to see just how much:

        At 8000 ft, our drag is 302.5 lbs. Since thrust must equal drag in
        straight and level unaccelerated flight, our engine and prop
   must be
        making 302.5 pounds of thrust.

        Thrust is simply power available divided by velocity. So we can
        calculate power available by multiplying our thrust times our
   velocity:

        Power available = 302.5 * 245 fps / 550 = 135 thrust horsepower

        (We divided by a constant of 550 because one hp equals 550 lbs. * 1
        ft.; or 1lb * 550 ft).

        The actual engine horsepower is just thrust horsepower divided by
        our propeller efficiency so if we assume prop efficiency of 0.8 we
        get 135 THP / 0.8 = 168. This is 73 percent of the 230 hp engine's
        power. Assuming a fuel burn of 0.45 pounds per horsepower hour, we
        find that we are burning 75.6 pounds per hour, or 12.6 gallons
   per hour.


        Now flying at 16,000 feet with our supercharged engine, we have a
        drag of only 231 pounds.

        This requires only 102 THP. ( 231 * 245 fps / 550 = 102)

        102 THP divided by our prop efficiency of 0.8 equals 128 engine
        horsepower. This is 55 percent power. Assuming a higher fuel
   burn of
        0.5 pounds per horsepower hour for our supercharged engine, we
   get a
        total fuel burn of 64 pounds per hour or 10.7 gph.

        We are flying the same speed, 145 knots in both cases but our
        supercharged engine flying at 16,000 feet is burning nearly two
        gallons less fuel per hour. over a four hour trip we can increase
        our endurance by three quarters of an hour and increase our
   range by
        more than 100 nautical miles.

        A turbocharged engine would be even more efficient, but a
        supercharged engine is still better than NA. The supercharged WW2
        fighters got pretty good range and endurance by cruising up high at
        low power levels and could circle for quite a while like this until
        they spotted bogies. Only when they engaged did they go to high
        power and this usually did not last more than a few minutes.

        Supercharged engines have the advantage of easier boost boost and
        you don't have the heat issues of a turbo.


        Regards,

        Gordon.

        All very true. No doubt about it.
        You need oxygen at 16,000 feet and IFR in most places in the US :)
        I don't know about Canada. I think 12,000 feet is a more practical
        altitude limit for most of us VFR pilots in the US.

        BTW As I recall VFR on top is illegal in Canada as I recall. Every
        time I fly in Canada there always appears to be a top :)

        Paul Lamar

        Right you are Paul,

        Here in Canada we have a so-called VFR-on-top rating, which lets a
        VFR pilot get on top. In the US you can do that with just a VFR
   rating.

        I think the US requirement is that you have to file an IFR flight
        plan for 18,000 feet and above.

        Regards,

        Gordon.



        Paul,

        Just another quick note on this subject of altitude. I agree 12,000
        feet is plenty high for most VFR pilots. Higher than that and you
        need oxygen to be legal -- and smart.

        However, a lot of the planes that people are building for rotary
        power are easily capable of flying in the mid-teens on a regular
        basis. If you plan on doing lots of serious cross-country, the
        medium altitudes are something to think about.

        The higher you go the stronger the winds aloft. If you're flying
        west to east you can take advantage of the strong tailwinds at
        higher altitudes. A 50 or 60 knot tailwind will do wonders for
   your
        fuel efficiency, range, and flight time. If you've got a plane that
        can go above 20,000 feet you might even hitch a ride on the
        jetstream and its 100 knot plus winds...

        Flying east to west you will almost always find lower headwinds at
        the lower altitudes. But here again your supercharged engine could
        stand you in good stead. If you are fighting a 30 knot headwind at
        4,000 feet, you can pour on the coals and make a little
        better groundspeed. You don't have that option in a normally
        aspirated engine.


        Regards,

        Gordon.

Flying in the western US sometimes it's really nice to be able to go
above 12000MSL.  Gets you out of some of the summer/wind generated
bumps.  I have been to 14k (13999, actually) a couple of times to get
relief.  I don't have an O2 system yet but am casually shopping for
one.  I imagine it can make a huge difference in brightness and
comfort.  In the scheme of things, they aren't particularly expensive,
either.

Matt-

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.