Subject: Aluminum center/end plate ?
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/22/2007, 5:24 PM
To: AARotary Engine




      > > Paul: You, any one else, ever look at RB's aluminum end and
   center
      > housings
      > > and wonder how much trouble to machine out of solid aluminum
      billets
      > for
      > > PPort engines? After all, they won't need intake ports in them.
      > > jofarr, soddy tn
      > >
      > > Can't be done because they are hollow. Now if somebody invented
      > > a tiny robot milling machine that you could put down a small hole
      > > and have it mine out cavities in the material that would work.
      > >
      > > No intake ports would certainly help.
      > >
      > > If you made them in two pieces that would also work if you could
      > > figure out a way to seal the internal joints. Could be done with
      > > some sort of gasket or O-rings and that is exactly what Richard
      > > Sohn is working on.
      > >
      > > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
      > >
      > > Paul,
      > > Those two pieces could easily be furnace brazed together.
      According to
      > > Alan Tolle Everett even did a steel 2 piece milled and furnace
      brazed.
      > > For the "superlite" engine. For aluminum the problem remains the
      > coating.
      > > I'm convinced that it would be "do able" just expensive. I
      think that
      > the
      > > state of milling equipment probably do a better and faster job
      than
      > > casting.
      > > Bill Jepson
      >
      > > hi Bill, this is the way my machinist and i have planned to do
      it. what
      > > would you estimate the cost of casting them? just so i could
      compare
      > costs.
      > >thanks , wyo. walt.
      >
      > Walt
      > The problem is the cost of the pattern making. You could easily
      spend 10K
      > to 15K setting up the patterns to cast the various parts. That
      is before
      > making a single casting. Additionally the sad thing is you
   could find
      > that your
      > casting still didn't work due to porosity or core shift. The
   fact is
      > that billet
      > construction would probably be cheaper until at least the 100
      unit mark.
      > machining from billet you have a reasonable expectation that your
      first
      > part
      > would work. All the aluminum concerns about coating are about the
      same.
      > Bill Jepson
      >
      > One possible problem I can see Bill is the compressive strength
      > of furnace braze is not as high as the base material.
      > The tension bolts put a lot of compressive stress on
      > the engine end housings.
      >
      > Paul Lamar
      >
      > Paul,
      > This is a reasonable concern, but with proper layout shouldn't be a
      > problem
      > The key is to place the braze material around the piers or in a
      center
      > reservoir
      > so the base material is in near contact. (a super thin film is
      wicked to
      > the base
      > material by heat and usually a flux) The way I've seen this done
      is to
      > weight
      > the two parts together to force out excess. Your separate wear
      surface
      > idea
      > with o-ring seals is another way to do this. (I thought that hot
      rivets
      > from
      > opposite sides could hold the plates in place) Lastly, modern
      thermally
      > conductive epoxies could be used to fasten interlocking opposite
      sides.
      > For
      > the CNC milled parts that might be the most effective method of
      all. the
      > parts could be well located and pressed together during cure.
   Detgun
      > coating
      > for least unwanted heat transfer. There are many ways to go after
      this, I
      > wish I had the money to pursue it. FWIW
      >
      > Bill Jepson
      >
      > JB Weld them together might work.
      >
      > Paul Lamar
      >
      > Paul,
      > If you setup the edges that come together like this, with a small
      > clearance
      > to allow the epoxy somewhere to go, it would work fine. You
      could do the
      > brazed part exactly the same way, only the clearances would change.
      > Pardon the crude model but the concept is obvious.
      > Bill Jepson
      >
      > That jpg did not work.
      >
      > Paul Lamar

      Paul,
      With the differential thermal expansion of the center plate,( two
      combustion
      chambers and cooling water between), it appears that there could be
      tension
      in any internal ribs passing from one face to the other. Any joining
      method
      would have to accommodate this.

      Colin Smith

      Possibly. Short of an FEA we would not know for sure.
      Do you have an FEA available?

      Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

   Does the aluminum piece have to be done in halves?

   Can an iron/steel wear surface used which also bridges the openings in
   the housing which allow for the machining to be done?

   A one piece housing might be fairly crudely cast. Then put it through a
   finish milling process to touch things up where precise tolerances are
   required. Mill where the iron wear surface fits plus an o-ring groove
   to seal it. Might be cheaper overall than taking huge billets of Al and
   milling them out. And you might get away without gluing anything
   together.

   Matt-

   Matt,
   Crude or perfect the patterns need to be done on any casting.
   George (down under) did a TON of work on a bellhousing including
   several iterations and everyone just kind of passed on it as being
   costly with machining. I think his later versions still have a shot at
   being a good solution. Took AGES to do even though George did
   all the pattern work himself. (and did it well IMHO) The bellhousing
   is babysteps compared to the rotary center housing. The billet method
   really isn't more expensive, and if the chips bother you recycle.
   The fact is that a cut housing would have better alignment and be
   easy to finish. You would have to machine any casting to make it
   square and flat enough to use. That machining adds to the cost of
   any casting. The high pressure castings used to make things at the
   factory just cost too much for us amatures. 30-40 thousand is
   common. I would be glad to do SolidWorks designs of the housings
   and work with someone for price considerations on the final product.
   I won't hold by breath waiting for takers though. This is a serious
   project, and even more difficult than meets the eye. If it was easy
   several interested parties would have sold tons of them already!
   Bill Jepson
   PS Paul I converted that JPEG from a PDF does that matter?



Fair enough..  None the less, using iron wear surfaces gets around some
surface finish issues, and might make machining a billet part
simpler/easier/cheaper.

However you look at it, it's probably still cheaper to order the
housings from Racing Beat and be done with it.

Matt-



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.