lots of snips...............
Paul,
With the differential thermal expansion of the center plate,( two
combustion
chambers and cooling water between), it appears that there could be
tension
in any internal ribs passing from one face to the other. Any joining
method
would have to accommodate this.
Colin Smith
Possibly. Short of an FEA we would not know for sure.
Do you have an FEA available?
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Does the aluminum piece have to be done in halves?
Can an iron/steel wear surface used which also bridges the openings in
the housing which allow for the machining to be done?
A one piece housing might be fairly crudely cast. Then put it through a
finish milling process to touch things up where precise tolerances are
required. Mill where the iron wear surface fits plus an o-ring groove
to seal it. Might be cheaper overall than taking huge billets of Al and
milling them out. And you might get away without gluing anything
together.
Matt-
Matt,
Crude or perfect the patterns need to be done on any casting.
George (down under) did a TON of work on a bellhousing including
several iterations and everyone just kind of passed on it as being
costly with machining. I think his later versions still have a shot at
being a good solution. Took AGES to do even though George did
all the pattern work himself. (and did it well IMHO) The bellhousing
is babysteps compared to the rotary center housing. The billet method
really isn't more expensive, and if the chips bother you recycle.
The fact is that a cut housing would have better alignment and be
easy to finish. You would have to machine any casting to make it
square and flat enough to use. That machining adds to the cost of
any casting. The high pressure castings used to make things at the
factory just cost too much for us amatures. 30-40 thousand is
common. I would be glad to do SolidWorks designs of the housings
and work with someone for price considerations on the final product.
I won't hold by breath waiting for takers though. This is a serious
project, and even more difficult than meets the eye. If it was easy
several interested parties would have sold tons of them already!
Bill Jepson
Okay finally some one hinting at what I have been thinking. What is the
point of this exercise ? It seems to me that this would be a huge
undertaking for anyone who either doesn't have a ton of money, machining
skills, casting know how, metallurgy expertise or all of the above. What
is
wrong with what RB is doing ?
If there are hundreds to be sold I'm sure RB would alter their plates to
meet some other spec that would be appropriate for a/c use. They have
certainly done a lot of work to get to where they are now, and although
Jim
might disagree I think his pockets are deeper for this sort of development
project than a bunch of homebuilders.
John Gibbons
With all due respect John I think you would be wrong.
Richard Sohn, working out of the shop in his backyard
has come up with a major breakthrough in terms of
cost and appropriate technology. No exotic detonation gun
coating. No diamond grinding. Simple to re-lap when over
hauling. Just the right thickness of iron for the side
housing with a well proven cast iron wear surface. No more
than is needed. If you want to lighten it you take the two
pieces apart and put them in an NC mill. If a thiner cast
iron part proves to work you modify the simple wear surface
pattern. No core boxes. Very simple sand casting patterns.
Here are a series of pictures on the development
process over a period of years. Richard was also
working on his house during this period of time.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
I am aware of Richards amazing work, I just don't lump him into the category
of homebuilder. It just seems to me that every once in a while some one
throws an idea out here and after a bit of discussion it is decided that
things aren't as simple as they seem and that Mazda with their millions of
dollars over the years should just be copied.
What I'm seeing in this thread
is a lot of what ifs. With all respect to Richard his system is still not
proven although I think it shows great promise. Even if all goes well it
will be several years before we see how reliable it is. How many unproven
plates could he sell in that time.
It is one thing to build one or two and
use them yourself, but is manufacturing them a realistic outcome ? RB on the
other hand has what appears to be a copy of the proven Mazda plate but
aluminum instead of iron. But according to the post here they are unproven
and the coating are a bit of an unknown. But isn't this a better point to
start from ?
I have seen a few Rotax 912 go to triple TBO in hard training
service and at that point the wear in the al. cylinders was minimal to the
point of being very difficult to measure. I believe one of these cores,
which could no longer be used in a certified a/c, is still in service in a
homebuilt. Surely the service to be seen in rotary duty couldn't be any
worse.
Wouldn't we be further ahead putting some RB plates into service and
doing oils analysis every 25 or 50 hours and poking a boroscope into a
p-port hole at the same time. What would be an acceptable TBO for these ?
Would RB be willing to sell some uncoated plates so they could be det gun
coated and tested. Imagine an al. three rotor at Reno, that would promote
the rotary and plate sales. I sure don't want to sound like a naysayer but
it seems like RB is halfway there and they could sell 10 times as many to
ground pounding rotor heads.
John Gibbons
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.