Subject: N93BD is seriously damaged.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/9/2007, 8:19 AM
To: AARotary Engine



    >      >>     Just to let everyone know I had a serious problem with a
    > landing
    >      >>     today and the plane is seriously damaged.  Pilot has a
    >     scratch on
    >      >> his
    >      >>     thumb.
    >      >>
    >      >>     I had a pretty bad bounce on landing and after the second
    >     bounce,
    >      >>     decided to go around. That was a mistake.  I never
   got out
    > from
    >      >> behind
    >      >>     the power curve and ended up doing a high power skid into
    > the
    >      >> grass on
    >      >>     the south side of the runway.  Both main wheels were torn
    > off,
    >      >> the prop
    >      >>     disintegrated, an the fuselage is somewhat bent.  After
    >      >> contacting the
    >      >>     ground, the plane did about 1/2 turn and skidded to a
   stop.
    >      >>
    >      >>     Bob W.
    >      >>
    >      >>     --
    >      >>     N93BD - Rotary Powered BD-4 - http://www.bob-white.com
    >      >>     First Flight:  11/23/2006 7:50AM - 3.3 Hours Total Time
    >      >>     Cables for your rotary installation -
    >      >> http://www.roblinphoto.com/shop/
    >      >>
    >      >>     Dang! I was just about to go over there and take some
    > pictures
    >      >>     of Bob's airplane. I have never been a fan of tail
    > dragger's.
    >      >>     I think they add to the hazards of aviation. They are
    >      >> fundamentally
    >      >>     unstable on the ground. The CG is behind the main wheels.
    >      >> Therefore
    >      >>     there are situation where they are impossible to
   control no
    >     matter
    >      >>     how good the pilot.
    >      >>
    >      >>
   ----------------------------------------------------------
    >      >>     Bob, we are taking an early stand by flight non-stop to
    >      >> Albuquerque
    >      >>     Monday morning. I'll call you when we arrive. I would
   like
    >      >>     to see how the motor mount made out.
    >      >>
    >      >>     Folks, the news letter will be shut down about noon today
    > for
    >      >>     a few days. Don't send messages until I get back.
    >      >>
    >      >>     Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    >      >>
    >      >> Glad to hear Bob's okay..
    >      >>
    >      >>
    >      >> Matt-
    >      >>
    >      >
    >      >
    >      >
    >      > With over 6500 hrs in tail-dragger's and no accidents or
    > incidents, I
    >      > think you need to reassess your "opinion" of tail-dragger's.
    > It's
    >     good
    >      > when a man knows his limitations...
    >      >
    >      > Eric Benson
    >      >
    >      > It is not an opinion. It is a law a physics. The CG is behind
    > the
    >      > side force input and that causes  severe yawing motion in the
    >     airplane.
    >      > It is the same as putting the feathers on the front of the
    > arrow.
    >      >
    >      > Your obviously a highly skilled pilot that can handle a
    > fundamentally
    >      > unstable design. Particularly on pavement. However most of the
    >      > people on here are building airplanes and not bush flying
   for a
    >      > living.
    >      >
    >      > They are rusty to say the least and some are brand new pilots
    >      > with little time in tail dragger's if any. They need all the
    > help
    >      > they can get. A nose gear airplane is stable when touching
   down,
    >      > unlike a tail dragger, because the side restoring force is
    > behind
    >      > the CG just like the feathers on the back end of an arrow.
    >      >
    >      > Statistically speaking tail dragger's have more accidents
    >      > and hence hull insurance cost more.
    >      >
    >      >
   http://www.eaa.org/communications/eaanews/051215_insurance.html
    >      >
    >      > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    >
    >
    >
    >     That's why you have what's called a "rudder". Your feet do not
    > belong
    >     on the floor, they belong on the rudder pedals flying the
   airplane.
    >     Your comparison of an arrow's feathers on the front of an
   arrow is
    >     invalid.
    >
    >     If you'd like to come out to my airport, it is KAOC which has a
    > 6600 ft
    >     asphalt runway. We are at the heart of the Idaho back-country and
    > have
    >     not had any "accidents" with all these "unstable" aircraft
   flying
    >     around on my airport.
    >     Regards,
    >     Eric Benson
    >
    >     I have no doubt you are a wonderful pilot Eric.
    >
    >     That does not change the laws a physics however.
    >
    >     The feathers on the front of the arrow are exactly
    >     the problem.
    >
    >     Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    >
    >
    > Eric,
    >
    > Hey..  I'm in Boise, and occasionally make it to Arco.  Is Grandpa's
    > Southern Style BBQ still in business there?  They served some great
    > grub
    > the last time I was in there.
    >
    > I am a fan of taildraggers.  They typically weigh less, go faster,
    > treat
    > their props better, and just look snarkier than the equivalent nose
    > dragger variants.
    >
    > However, pilots have to stay ahead of taildraggers - they are less
    > forgiving of rustiness/complacency than like nosedraggers.  If
   you are
    > a
    > pilot that enjoys taildraggers, there's no problem.  Get after
   it.  For
    > absolute practicality however, nosedraggers are less likely to create
    > an
    > expensive situation.
    >
    > As to your claim that nobody has accidents with taildraggers in back
    > country Idaho, I have to beg to differ.  Just a quick search on
   NTSB db
    > of the Arco airport shows that there have been at least 2 accidents
    > that
    > could be attributed to loss of directional control in a taildragger
    > airplane..  If you expand the search to other Idaho airports you see
    > more.  Hailey is especially bad.  I haven't figured out how to
   get the
    > real backcountry runways like Johnson Creek or even Soldier Bar.  In
    > the
    > defense of taildraggers, I have to say that people do things in the
    > back
    > country with taildraggers that they wouldn't even think of doing
   in a
    > nose dragger.  Higher risk ops= higher accident rates.
    >
    > Even so, I am tempted to try converting my 182 to a 180 - for the
    > reasons listed above..  I like the 180's more.
    >
    >
    > Regards,
    >
    > Matt-


    > BTW Matt what do you spend on the average per year to maintain
    > your O-470? Are you an A&P? An IA?
    >
    > I am trying to get a handle on certified air cooled aircraft engine
    > over all costs. with me it was about $2000 total with at least half
    > of that engine. Not counting allowances for replacement or overhaul
    > after 1500 or 2000 hours (depending on the dash number).
    >
    > Paul Lamar
    >

   Hi Matt,
   Grandpa's has closed, unfortunately. I did not claim there were no
   accidents in the back-country, just there were no accidents at Arco!
   Regards,
   Eric.



Bummer about Grandpa's..  I'll have to check if he still has his
restaurant in IDA..

Here's a Husky that groundlooped at AOC:

http://ntsb.gov/ntsb/brief.asp?ev_id=20001211X14727&key=1
<http://ntsb.gov/ntsb/brief.asp?ev_id=20001211X14727&key=1>

NTSB Identification: *SEA92LA093 *
14 CFR Part 91: General Aviation
Accident occurred Friday, May 08, 1992 in ARCO, ID
Probable Cause Approval Date: 8/13/1993
Aircraft: Aviat A-1, registration: N200HU
Injuries: 2 Uninjured.

AFTER DIVERTING DUE TO WEATHER THE PILOT EXECUTED A FULL FLAP APPROACH
TO RUNWAY 5 AT THE AIRPORT. HE REPORTED THE WINDS AT THE TIME OF THE
LANDING AS 320 DEGREES AT 8 KNOTS GUSTING TO 14. UPON TOUCHDOWN THE
PILOT LOST DIRECTIONAL CONTROL OF THE AIRCRAFT AND DURING THE RECOVERY
THE LEFT WINGTIP IMPACTED THE GROUND.

The National Transportation Safety Board determines the probable
cause(s) of this accident as follows:

THE PILOT'S INADEQUATE COMPENSATION FOR WIND CONDITIONS RESULTING IN
FAILURE TO MAINTAIN DIRECTIONAL CONTROL. FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO THE
ACCIDENT WERE: CROSSWINDS AND GUSTS.


One final comment..  Tricycle gear airplanes have been known to ground
loop as well, but just not nearly as often.


Matt-


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.