Subject: Just watched Acura Race to the race Sebring
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/19/2007, 12:02 PM
To: AARotary Engine


The winner wasn't even running gasoline - the Audi R10 is a V10
turbo-diesel. :-)

From http://www.modernracer.com/news/category/racing-stories/

"The Audi R10 TDI, the world's only Le Mans diesel racer, has been doing so
well that new regulations have been put in place to reduce its advantages.
The American Le Mans Series has decided to allow the competing gas-powered
LM P1 Lolas to drop 143 pounds of weight to make for a tighter race. The
Lolas will also be granted a five-liter larger fuel tank. Audi says its
engineers have calculated with computer simulation that 22 pounds at the
upcoming Road America is worth at least two-tenths-of-a-second per lap. Audi
said it is deeply disappointed about the random decisions of the IMSA
organization. Nonetheless, Audi is hopefully it can continue its winning
streak this weekend with the Road America race."

Andy Hecker

That is funny. No word about all the other rules and restrictions.
Where is a complete set of rules for all IMSA race cars?
I have not seen them. Do you have a set?
What minimum weight is forced on the gas engined cars?
Five liters of more fuel when all cars are holding 100 liters, or
more, is of little advantage. As far as I know the piston
engine cars are non turbo. Given equal displacements and no limits
on RPM a turbo gasoline engine will have twice the HP of a turbo
diesel. The Europeans are hung up on stinky, carcinogenic pumping
diesel engines :) The reason they win is nobody wants to get close
enough to pass them :)

The other P2 cars are not allowed turbos. http://www.motorsport.com/

"Fitted with mandated air restrictors, the 3.4-liter, 90-degree, V8
racing engine developed by Porsche for long-distance events produces
503 bhp, an increase in output over the former model by 23 bhp. The
weight of the car is also in line with the A.C.O. regulations, with
the new RS Spyder weighing in at exactly 775 kilos or 1709 lbs."

1709 pounds is a war fighting tank :)

With no restrictor a Mazda p-port 3 rotary street car engine would have
a minimum of 450 HP and would weigh about 260 pounds using cast iron end
housings.
Turbos on gasoline piston engines can double the HP. A 3 rotor turbo
would have something in the neighborhood of 1200 HP.

Turbos on gasoline V8 piston engines with four overhead cams and
24 valves can double the HP.

With no  minimum weight, all other things being equal, a gas engine
will beat ANY diesel engine in a road racing situation. Over all weight
in a racing car is a strict function of engine weight. The ratio is
somewhere less than 3 to one. Back in the days of Can Am, with no
minimum weight rules, our Chaparral cars weighed 1300 pounds empty and
the all aluminum Chev 6.5L V8 engine weighed 450 pounds. That was old
low tech using aluminum chassis's and fiberglass bodies. My guess the
ratio is now closer to 2 to 1  using carbon fiber for both in racing
cars.

In street cars the same relationship applies except the ratio
is higher. The RX8 is an excellent example. It weighs 3000 pounds
with a 200 pound engine while piston engine cars of about the same
HP with heavier, 350 pound piston engines, weigh 3400 to 3500 pounds.

The fastest accelerating street cars with no minimum weight rules
are always gasoline powered cars.

It is the same in airplanes that have no minimum weight rules.
Diesel engines are extra heavy and not worth the slight reduction in
fuel burn.

Diesel engines are limited in the ability to rev due to combustion
characteristics. HP is directly proportional to RPM. Therefore a
gasoline engine will always generate more HP per pound of engine
weight. That is giving the benefit of the doubt to the diesel engine
because diesel engines run at higher compression ratios. That requires
a stronger and heavier engine at the same HP level. Teledyne Continental
and Renault both recently failed to produce a viable diesel
aircraft engine.

The Germans figured all this out in the late 1930's. There were
no diesel powered fighter planes or bombers in WW II.  At something
like 70 to 80% full power or above a diesel engine is only slightly
more efficient than a gasoline engine. That has not changed in the
last 100 years. See the attachment.

BTW IMHO Mazda ought to sue IMSA $100,000,000 for loss of advertising
and PR for arbitrarily discriminating against the rotary. That
is about what Acura spent winning the P2 class.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Rules:
http://www.imsaracing.net/imsaNS2.cfm?h=/2003/series/alms/header.htm&p=/2003
/competitors/indexnewalms.htm

2006 American LeMans Series Rules:
http://www.imsaracing.net/2006/competitors/2006ALMSRules.pdf

Europe has had ultra-low sulfur diesel fuel for just over 10 years - similar
to the fuel we're still phasing in thru most of the US.  This allows diesel
vehicles to be fitted with advanced catalytic converters and particulate
filters.  And this allows diesel vehicles to meet the same emissions
requirements as gasoline engines.  We're still playing catch-up here in the
'States - even California.  :-)

The TDI in the 2006 Touareg is a 5 liter V10 with two turbochargers.  310
hp, 553 lb-ft of torque.

My '97 Passat wagon with it's 1.9 liter 4-cylinder turbodiesel has 358,000
miles, a cat converter, and no smoke.  44 mpg at 70-80 on the interstate
loaded with 1000 lbs.  25 gallons of fuel usable; 1000+ mile range.

Andy Hecker

This topic drifting. I am partially at fault. Sorry. I am not here to
debate diesel verses gasoline truck or car engine or emissions. That is
far too broad of a topic. We are talking about racing engines and
aircraft engines.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.