Subject: Legendary Aircraft P-51
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/20/2007, 11:43 AM
To: AARotary Engine


    I was looking at the PSRU and engine mount. The PSRU case is cast to
    hold the Barry Mounts which is what has been suggested for the rotary
    if only we could generate the $$ to cast such a case. Unlikely.
    What did interest me was the use of square tubing for the engine
    mount. I believe this is possible because the upper and lower engine
    mounts and the Barry mounts are in the same plane parallel to the
    engine thrust line. In some instances we might be able to do
    something similar by adjusting the length of the S beam to match the
    firewall hard points if they are the same upper and lower. One could
    actually fab up the the sides on the bench. A modified version would
    be to maintain the firewall hard points out the the rear beam and
    then from the rear beam to the Barry Mounts, it could be narrower but
    still parallel to the thrust line so that square tubing could be
    used. Probably need a gusset at the rear beam if there is off set
    between the front and rear pieces. Now is when I need Rhino. It
    would be interesting to explore the possibilities.

    I think the present rear beam or strut engine mount is just about
    perfect for our application so I am not advocating a change. Jerry

    -----------------------------------------------------------
    The empty weight is listed at 1800 pounds and gross is 2500 pounds.
    The engine alone is in the neighborhood of 500 pounds. The chain drive
    gear box adds another 127 pounds. The prop 30 pounds. The wing
    loading is 22.5 pounds per square foot so stall, takeoff and landing
    speeds would be high.

    The Chevy LS2 engine is: 400 HP at 6000 RPM
    400 ft pounds torque at 4400 RPM or 335 HP.
    The last number looks about it for takeoff and climb as
    the max gear reduction is 2.22:1. That gives a prop
    RPM of 2000 I would guess. Lets see prop diameter is 86 inches.
    Circumference is therefore 22.5 feet. Mach one is about
    1100 FPS or 66000 feet per minute so prop RPM
    is 2933 RPM at Mach one tip speed. Tip drag starts getting bad
    at around Mach .7 so max RPM on this prop should be
    around 2000 RPM. The numbers check with my guess.
    It is erroneous to believe with this PSRU ratio that you will get
    400 or 500 HP out of the Chevy LS2 or any other LSx V8 engine.
    335 HP at 4400 RPM is a more realistic estimate.

    Now the question is: for how long? Back in the days when I was
    associated with GM the stock engine durability test was 300 hours
    cycling the engine between max torque 4400 RPM and 6000 RPM max HP.
    I don't know if the LS2 will pass that test. In sprint road racing our
    TBO was 2 hours. It took years of programmed dyno testing and part
    redesigns to get the big block life up to 24 hours for Lemans
    competitive power.

    In a car the LS2 engine rarely exceeds 2000 RPM at Freeway speeds.
    First thing you need to do is throw away the cast iron or powdered
    metal rods, cast iron crank and cast Al piston and change them to
    aircraft quality forged materials such as 4340 and heavy duty piston
    alloy. It is not possible to use sodium cooled valves due to
    the small stem diameter so a higher quality SS exhaust valve material
    is needed. Then one would need a good maintenance program for
    checking for internal parts cracks every 50 hours or so after
    the first 300 hours by disassembling the engine.

    It has a real nice high pressure die cast aluminum oil pan :)

    Paul Lamar



    Paul,

    Interesting little plane that P-51. With that narrow pointy cowl it
    would be a perfect candidate for rotary power.

    I notice the website mentions the 4-rotor as an engine option to the
    Chevy V-8s. Now I have to think that a 4-rotor is going to make a
    heck of a lot more power than those V-8s.

    I've attached a copy of my Turbochart spreadsheet which is handy for
    figuring engine power output. I have revised the spreadhseet with
    the addition of the Ford 3.17 gearset that has been mentioned in
    another thread.

    With that gear reduction and 6500 engine rpm, a p-port 4-rotor
    should make about 480 hp at sea level manifold pressure. This would
    give a prop rpm of 2050.

    Even a 3-rotor p-port will put out 360 hp at that rpm, which is more
    than the small-block Chevy engine.

    I have used very conservative power equations. For example, the
    Continental IO-550N would need a VE of 1.08 to get 310 hp, which is
    what the engine is rated at. In fact, 310 hp is a guaranteed minimum
    with individual engines producing up to 325 hp, according to
    Continental. This engine is known as a good breather with its
    cross-flow heads, but I doubt its VE is over 1, so this shows my
    spreadsheet is very conservative.

    Another thing is prop rpm. If you want to use a smaller diameter
    prop and go to 2500 rpm with the 3.17 reduction you get a huge gain
    in power. The 4-rotor p-port will put out 588 hp at 7925 engine rpm.

    Even the 3-rotor will make 441 hp at the same rpm. The slightly
    smaller prop will be just as efficient but may not look quite as
    scale. I believe either of these engines will weigh a lot less than
    the V-8s, while putting out more power.


    Regards,

    Gordon.




The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.