Subject: Turbocompound turbine torque
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/22/2007, 11:11 AM
To: AARotary Engine

   Paul,

   I have explored a few VGT turbines now and we need to have a ball
   park idea
   of how much torque can the turbocompound turbine technique tweak.

   Say that phrase 5 times and you will have an idea of my frustration
   level:)

   To deliver 54 Hp net to the e-shaft we would like to have about 4
   ft/lbs of
   torque at the turbine output at 80k rpm.

   Said in another way, to produce 4 lbs of torque at 80,000 rpms a TE-04
   turbine would have to output about 61 Hp output. Likely? The torque
   on the
   three inch turbine tips would be what about 12 ft/lbs

   Said another way a compressor attached to this turbine in operation is
   unlikely to requiring 61 Hp to perform its function of compressing
   air for
   the engine. Logic would suggest we need a bigger turbine. How big?
   If it is a blow down impulse style Gordon has already shown how it
   would be
   over three feet in diameter.

   We are planning to use a more efficient reactive turbine with VGT
   technology.

   Reeves if you get this thread could you give us a ball park figure
   on the
   torque or Hp output of any turbine in the TE-04 or TE-06 class you have
   experience with testing? Assume 80K rpm. operational speed.

   Obviously there are a lot of turbines out there to choose from but
   if their
   output is only .1 ft/lbs to 1 ft/lb then we have to seriously
   reexamine our
   turbo compounding.

   Best Regards


   Doug

   Here is one way to crudely estimate the max torque. Calculate the
   area of
   the blade. The dynamic pressure on the blade in pounds per square foot
   at sea level density when stationary. The dynamic pressure equation
   is .0026 times the gas velocity in MPH squared. The exact gas velocity
   will be a function of the A/R among many other things.

   Just for our example here I will assume it is 1100 fps or 750 MPH.
   Right around Mach one. The shrieking sound coming out of the open
   rotary exhaust at full chat strongly suggest Mach one :) If the blade
   is one inch square the area in square feet will be 1/144 or .0069
   square feet.

   750 MPH times 750 MPH times .0026 times .0069 square feet equals 10
   pounds on each blade.

   The center of the blade area is .75 inches from the turbine shaft
   center line on the stock Mazda 2nd gen turbo charger turbine. So
   the max torque from each blade is .75 x 10 or 7.5 inch pounds. There
   are ten blades so total torque is 75 inch pounds or 6.25 ft pounds
   when the blades are stationary. All turbines have max torque when
   the blades are stationary.

   Figure half that at max turbine HP. Lets say it is 3 ft pounds at
   60,000 RPM. HP = Torque X RPM / 5252 or roughly 34 HP.
   34/200 is 17% of 200 HP engine. NACA 786 estimated 16% of engine HP
   or 80/500 at sea level for a piston engine.

   So I can't be that far off. Remember this is a crude estimate.
   Not bad for a crude estimate. You will get more turbine HP
   as altitude goes up and back pressure on the turbine is reduced.

   Max HP occurs when the tangential velocity of the blade center is
   roughly half of the velocity of the gas entering the turbine.
   You must work out this velocity number and consequently the turbine
   RPM where it occurs and compare it to the assumed gas velocity.
   See 13A-HP-torque-turbine.jpg

   As the blade speeds up at higher and higher turbine RPM's torque
   and HP will be less and less until torque and HP become zero as
   blade speed approaches gas speed.

   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

   Paul,

   I forgot to mention that the speed of sound in air goes up with
   temperature. At the high temperatures of the exhaust gas speed of
   sound will be much higher than 750 mph.

   The equation for speed of sound, Vs, in feet per second is:

   Vs = square root of (k * g * R * T)

   Where k, g, and R are constants (1.3; 32.17; and 53.34 respectively,
   for air). T is absolute temperature in Rankine.

   So assuming an exhaust temperature of 1600 degrees F, this is equals
   2060 degrees R.

   So mach at this temperature is:

   Vs = sqrt(1.3 * 32.17 * 53.34 8 2060) = 2144 fps = 1462 mph.

   So we need to use this much higher velocity to compute dynamic pressure.


   Doug, I'm going to look at the CAFE Foundation paper on exhaust
   pressure again to try to see what approach we might take. I think
   you could replicate what they did quite easily and have all the
   exhaust data you need to make the right choice for turbine size.


   Regards,

   Gordon.



Gordon, you are reading too much into this crude approximation.
There is also the phase of the moon :)

BTW the Brits in Scientific Design of Exhaust and Intake Systems.
Philip H. Smith and John C. Morrison Published by Robert Bentley.
ISBN 0-8376-0309-9 estimate the exhaust gas velocity as 1,700 FPS.
I was being conservative when I guessed 11,000 FPS.

Technology is continuing to move forward on radial inflow turbines.
To be able to look at a turbine and calculate the HP out based on its
geometry with a given gas flow is not going to be easy.
We really don't know what the velocity, density and pressure of the
exhaust gas is. In fact it changes moment by moment as the port opens
and closes. What we may need is a turbine dyno. The real energy is the
area under the pressure curve.

Paul Lamar


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.