Subject: direct drive propeller shaft
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/26/2007, 10:50 PM
To: AARotary Engine


Dear Paul:

   The propulsion unit that have in mind will basically require a
13B turbo charged, inter-cooled engine rotating at 7000 rpm. mated 1 to
1 from the flywheel and perhaps a Flexidyne  dry fluid coupling enclosed
in a Bell housing or PSRU-like housing coupled to a 2 foot multi-bladed
rotor fan enclosed in a duct.
        Given the various detailed descriptions of PSRU units that you
have shown on your site, can you give me any advice regarding the
following:

1. Will there be any possible long term wear and tear to the rotary
engines' main thrust bearings after continued use at those speeds?

Yes.

2. Are there any torsional resonance problems you forsee with a direct
drive short shaft coupled from the engine through the flywheel to the
output bearings of the transmission housing case?

Depends on how stiff the drive shaft and its length.

3. Are there any possible torsional feed back transmitted through the
short drive shaft from the engine to the prop fan and vice-versa?

Its possible.

4. Would a Dodge "Flexidyne" dry fluid coupling attached to the flywheel
and designed to limit the torque and the torsional resonance between the
multi bladed prop fan be a  simple solution to the potentional resonance
problems (See Moulton Taylor's solution to torsional vibration issues in
his Imp designed pusher).

Don't really know for sure put it would probable help.
I think it is heavy.

 5. In the interest of simplicity would the direct shaft be the only
component within the "Bell housing" and the prop, and would any other
mechanical components be necessary, aside from lubrication and access?

You will need a prop thrust bearing.

6. Can it be made bullet proof?

Yes of course.

7. Would an adaptation of the Flexidyne clutch such as Don Dunbar's 13B
Auto bell housing series 5 in your PSRU section be acceptable to address
the power transmission issues?

Yes.

8. Could a short carbon fiber dry shaft connecting the engine to the
prop fan provide the strength and lightness necessary?

Yes.

9. Could it be assembled from off the shelf parts?

Probably not.

     Paul, given your wealth of experience in these matters can you
possibly outline a diagram of such a mechanical arrangement in your reply?
     Also, are there any other manufacturers of transmission housings or
members of the newsletter able to give me any advice or information on
the pros and cons of such a lash-up?

                                                  Thanking you in advance,

                                                  Best regards.
                                                   Dave Young

The problem is the ducted prop will be very inefficient
for an aircraft application. It will waste your time and money
and my time. One third of your engine HP will only stir and heat
the air. If you plan on setting any records with a rotary
engine powered aircraft you will need a large diameter prop and
a gear box. No duct. Its been tried and has failed many times before.

Paul Lamar

Hi Dave;
Sorry about the delay in responding.

What are your HP goals and driveshaft length?
Is this a jet look-alike?

Some additional comments to some of your numbered questions above:

#3 ->
IIRC, many references (Wood?) only consider the inputs from the engine,
although things like aerodynamic buffeting can certainly contribute.
There will be torsional resonances, the question is what frequency and
is that frequency in or near the operational range.
Also, how much damping is there in your system.

#4 ->
Note that flexidynes are industrial soft start clutches.  It is essentially a
steel shot "dry fluid" filled input housing and output housing.  On rotation,
the shot spins to the outside of the housings catching, by friction, on
ridges that transfer the torque from the input to the output housing. At a resonance point, the effective torque rises beyond the shot torque
transfer capability disconnecting the housings, the input housing
accelerates through the resonance frequency and re-engages to the
outer housing at a higher rpm above the resonance point.
Note that 7000 rpm is well beyond the intended design range of the
flexidynes and they do not use lubrication,
this would (likely) dramatically reduce the lifespan of the flexidyne...

#8 ->
All carbon shafts are not created equal.  The winding layups can
dramatically affect the strength/stiffness.  Some automotive carbon
driveshafts appear to bond Aluminum U-joints directly to the carbon
shaft.  No mention of a galvanic insulator - carbon eats aluminum -
something else to be aware of...
#9 -> see comments on #8 above.


Gary James has revived Molt Taylor mini-imp.  See "mini-imp" yahoo group:
  http://groups.yahoo.com/group/mini-imp/
Last I heard Gary was advocating a 75C or 9C Dodge flexidyne for much
smaller engines. He specifically recommended against a carbon driveshaft
in favor of Aluminum, although it could certainly work.
The "mini-imp" plans have a diagram of such a system.  There is no info
on the driveshaft sizing itself, although the design appears to be remarkably
similar to recommended numbers in the "Machinery's Handbook" by
Industrial Press on shaft sizing...
I have heard that there have been flexidyne failures, although, I do not
know the root causes.
Several successful driveshaft designs have (also) used a viscous damper
similar to a "Houdaille".

A few references:
"Mechanical Vibrations", J.P. Den Hartog
"Practical Solution of Torsional Vibration Problems", W. Ker Wilson (very long)

The ducted fan will likely be quite a bit less efficient until a very high speed.
It will always have additional wetted area drag compared to an unducted fan.
You will need a lot of very wide blades to soak up that HP.

Cheers
Cary

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.