Subject: Radial inflow turbine HP & turbo compound
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 4/1/2007, 8:19 PM
To: AARotary Engine



     > Our focus here is how much HP can we get out of
     > a radial inflow turbine as found in a turbo charger.
     > It is not likely we will ever use a jet engine style
     > axial flow turbine for a turbo compound rotary engine.
     > Here is a simple turbine HP formula I found in Aircraft
     > Gas Turbine Engine Technology by I.E.Treager
     > The radial inflow turbine can be about the same efficiency
     > as a axial flow turbine in a narrower range of flows.
     > Fortunately in the range we are interested. Particularly
     > with the new variable vane versions.
     >
     > The red line on the air flow chart is for a 2 rotor and
     > the blue line is for a 3 rotor.
     >
     > Running the numbers.
     > At 100% VE the 2 rotor uses 35 pounds of air per minute at 15 psi
    boost
     > or .58 pounds per second. Therefore using this formula a typical
     > turbo charger turbine would be .58/5 X 679 HP or 79 HP.
     > Coincidently about what NASA calculated for a rotary based turbo
     > compound engine.
     >
     > In the case of the three rotor the number is 108 HP.
     >
     > P-ports typically have VE of 120% so these numbers become
     > 96 HP and 130 HP.
     >
     > If you are not as excited by this result as I am you don't
     > understand the implications of extracting 80 more HP from a
     > 2 rotor rotary engine with NO increase in fuel burn :)
     >
     > The question is what is the automotive world waiting for?
     >
     > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

    Two things: firstly, the piston engine, because it is initially more
    efficient in extracting the energy from the fuel, does not have as
    much to
    gain as the rotary. And secondly because they have not been forced to
    develop the turbo compound by either the market place or the government.

    I expect the industry will cry and cry about not being able to meet more
    stringent government requirements for fuel efficiency. Detroit has
    had its
    head in the sand since the early '50s when the first Japanese cars and
    trucks were being introduced into the US. They had a 5% rule: you didn't
    exist until you had 5% of the market.

    Someday someone in the auto industry will offer a turbo compound
    engine and
    then everyone else will be playing catch up. In the meantime, an
    economically hard pressed industry will try to avoid the investment in
    developing a practical turbo compound engine.

    What I don't understand is why Mazda doesn't do it. It seems to me
    that they
    have the most to gain. If turbo compounding made the rotary as fuel
    efficient as a piston turbo compound engine, the rotary would win on
    simplicity, power to weight ration, and probably just about any
    measure you
    would care to use. Hmmm, maybe the Ford ownership has something to
    do with
    it. :)

    Doc Custer
    Retired Software Engineer and sometime Audiologist

    There is another factor and that is the piston engine exhaust
    valve is not up to turbo compounding. For all the years
    Curtis Wright worked on the piston turbo compound most of
    the effort was focused on making the exhaust valves live. Even
    at the end of the turbo compound piston engine's commercial life
    one out of four turbo compound engines on an airliner would fail
    because of exhaust valve failure before the end of a 20 hour flight.
    Unlike the rotary engine, which of course has no exhaust valves,
    2/3rds of the kinetic energy in the exhaust was dissipated by the
    piston engine exhaust valves. See the attached jpg.

    Paul Lamar


    Doc and Paul,


    I'm not so sure turbo compounding has much to offer for cars. The
    main reason is that cars, unlike airplanes, cruise at a very low
    power levels, probably about 25 percent. There is little energy in
    the exhaust at low power levels, so not much power to be recovered.

    Another factor is ambient pressure. The NACA paper -- 786 I believe
    -- proved that the power recovered by the turbine is a direct
    function of the pressure gradient between engine intake manifold and
    turbine exhaust, which is at ambient pressure. The steeper the
    gradient, or delta P, the more power the turbine wheel will see.
    This should be intuitive -- the bigger the difference in pressure,
    the faster the gas wil accelerate from the high pressure side to the
    low pressure side, and the more momentum, ergo energy, it will bring
    to bear on the wheel.

    At sea level and without boost, there is no pressure gradient. In
    fact, intake manifold pressure will be lower, even at full throttle,
    than ambient pressure, due to pressure losses in the intake tract.
    At part throttle, such as cruise, the intake pressure will be quite
    a bit lower than ambient. There is nothing to be gained here.

    If you boost the engine significantly, you will get a pressure
    gradient. For example if you boost the engine 15 psi, you will have
    2 : 1 pressure gradient. In an aircraft flying at 20,000 feet, the
    ambient baro pressure is less than 7 psi. Even if you only have a
    turbo normalized setup that brings your manifold pressure to sea
    level pressure of 14.7 psi, you have a pressure gradient of more
    than 2 : 1.

    So I would say that turbo compounding would only make sense for
    high-performance vehicles that are highly boosted. In this situation
    you will get extra power from the recovery turbine, above and beyond
    what you get from the boost. So I think it is a niche technology at
    best for the automotive world.

    Also, I absolutely agree with Paul that turbo compounding is only for
    the Wankel engine. Forget about it for piston engines, for all the
    reasons stated above.

    But for an aircraft engine, the turbo compound rotary could be
    revolutionary, no doubt about it. Think of an 800 hp 4-rotor, that
    weighs less than a Pratt PT6, and sips half the fuel. Think what
    that engine would do in a plane like the TBM 850, or better yet, a
    plane specifically designed to take advantage of the lighter fuel
    load and engine.



    Regards,

    Gordon.


    Billions have been spent over the years getting one percent more
    efficiency out of car engines. Curtis Wright (no less), John Deere,
    Rotary Power International, Mazda and lately Mistral have all spent
    as much as a 100 million dollars or more (in total) on the rotary
    engine attempting to get the BSFC down from .47 BSFC to .44 BSFC.

    IMHO by downsizing the engine and the turbine during cruise
    the rotary powered car fuel consumption can be improved by as much
    as 40%. From the RX8's 25 MPG to 35 MPG using the turbo compound
    principle. Here in LA we spend as much as 80% of our travel at a
    constant80 MPH on the freeway. You don't need a 250 HP engine to go
    80 MPH. Here is an How-to in pdf format and html.

    http://www.rotaryeng.net/RX8-TC-eng.html


    Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


    Paul,

    Thanks for that article. That's a neat idea, with the small rotor.

    Another approach might be to use a very small, highly boosted
    engine. Here's a paper about an engine where they ran boost of up to
    3 bar. They used ethanol direct injection for detonation control,
    thanks to the evaporative cooling effect.

    The advantage of the boost is that it gives a steep pressure
    gradient across the turbine that really kicks up the recovery power.

    I've included a copy of that paper here.


    Regards,

    Gordon.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.