Subject: Radial inflow turbine HP & turbo compound
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 4/2/2007, 8:27 AM
To: AARotary Engine



    > Our focus here is how much HP can we get out of
    > a radial inflow turbine as found in a turbo charger.
    > It is not likely we will ever use a jet engine style
    > axial flow turbine for a turbo compound rotary engine.
    > Here is a simple turbine HP formula I found in Aircraft
    > Gas Turbine Engine Technology by I.E.Treager
    > The radial inflow turbine can be about the same efficiency
    > as a axial flow turbine in a narrower range of flows.
    > Fortunately in the range we are interested. Particularly
    > with the new variable vane versions.
    >
    > The red line on the air flow chart is for a 2 rotor and
    > the blue line is for a 3 rotor.
    >
    > Running the numbers.
    > At 100% VE the 2 rotor uses 35 pounds of air per minute at 15 psi
    > boost
    > or .58 pounds per second. Therefore using this formula a typical
    > turbo charger turbine would be .58/5 X 679 HP or 79 HP.
    > Coincidently about what NASA calculated for a rotary based turbo
    > compound engine.
    >
    > In the case of the three rotor the number is 108 HP.
    >
    > P-ports typically have VE of 120% so these numbers become
    > 96 HP and 130 HP.
    >
    > If you are not as excited by this result as I am you don't
    > understand the implications of extracting 80 more HP from a
    > 2 rotor rotary engine with NO increase in fuel burn :)
    >
    > The question is what is the automotive world waiting for?
    >
    > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    >
    >
    > Paul,
    >
    > That 80 hp from the recovery turbine is a very exciting result. Doug
    > was assuming about 50 hp.
    >
    > However, you are basing this on 15 psi boost, which, in an aircraft
    > engine you will only see at high altitude.
    >
    > You can use my turbochart spreadsheet for pretty accurate mass flow
    > numbers. At 8000 rpm on the ground at ISA temp and pressure, a
    > P-port with VE of 1.2 will flow 34.1 lbs/min of air and make about
    > 300 hp. (In fact I think this power number is too conservative and
    > am going to revise the spreadsheet to calculate power on thermal
    > efficiency instead of mass flow.)
    >
    > But the mass flow is dead accurate. So 34.1 divided by 60 equals
    > 0.57 pounds per second, pretty close to the number you got. Now this
    > is with no boost at all.
    >
    > If you want 15 psi of boost at 15,000 ft., you will be making well
    > over 350 hp -- that's before taking into consideration the power
    > recovered from the turbine -- at a mass flow rate of 43 lbs/min, or
    > 0.72 lbs/sec.
    >
    > Now using your formula that works out to 97 hp from the recovery
    > turbine. (0.72 / 5 * 676 = 97.)
    >
    > The spreadsheet shows 374 hp, and if you add the 97 hp from the
    > recovery turbine and take away let's say 30 hp to drive the
    > compressor, you get a total of 441 hp at a fuel flow of 175 pph,
    > which works out to a bsfc of -- hold on to your hats -- 0.39.
    >
    > And that's at stoichiometric fuel mixture, 14.7. If you lean to 16
    > or even 18 like they used to on the big Wright TCs, you will get
    > absolutely remarkable numbers. At AF of 18 : 1, the spreadsheet
    > shows fuel flow of 142 pph, which is bsfc of 0.32.
    >
    > I should add though, that your formula is only an approximation
    > because it is specific to an axial flow turbine which works on the
    > impulse principle. Radial flow turbines work on the reaction
    > principle.
    >
    > However, I think the efficiencies are going to be close enough that
    > this is going to be pretty close.
    >
    > We can work out the exact numbers though, using the proper
    > equations, which is what I intend to do. I will be updating the
    > spreadsheet with a section on exhaust and turbine performance soon.
    >
    >
    >
    > Regards,
    >
    > Gordon.
    >
    >
    > Plenty of street rotary engines see 15 psi boost at sea level.
    > Dave Garbers 12A engines had 15 psi boost in 1973. 350 HP.
    > 45 inches of Hg manifold pressure. But yes of course you
    > will get more boost at altitude.
    >
    > Here is the Wright chart for altitude at a very modest
    > compression ratio of only 6.4:1
    >
    > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

   Hi Gordon;
   I have limited turbo experience - so bear with me...
   Almost every 13b turbo map I have seen runs really rich AF mixtures
   (11-13:1) in order to avoid possible detonation.
   I am sure it can avoided with careful monitoring but they are run
   rich nonetheless.
   The 13b is extremely intolerant to boost induced detonation. See
   attachment ;)
   People pop them tuning all the time - once properly tuned they seem to
   be quite reliable.

   Cheers
   Cary



   Cary,

   That's a good point. Detonation is always the enemy. We see this in
   turbocharged airplanes like the Columbia 400, which must use a very
   rich mixture at maximimum cruise.

   Take a quick look at the numbers. the Continental TSIO550 engine in
   the Columbia 400 is rated at maximum power of 310 hp at 2600 rpm, at
   35,5 inches MAP. (This is actually a derated version of the same
   engine that makes 350 hp at 2700 rpm.) Maximimum cruise power is 85
   percent, or 262 hp, at 31.5 in/Hg MAP, 2500 rpm. The engine can
   carry that MAP to its ceiling of 25,000 ft, where ambient pressure
   is about a third of sea level, which means the turbo pressure ratio
   will be more than 3 : 1.

   It's not surprising that at maximimum cruise, this engine has to be
   run quite rich. The POH tells us that at 14,000 ft and standard
   temperature, 85 percent power will require 31.5 inches of manifold
   pressure and fuel flow of 24 gph. That works out to an air-fuel
   ratio of about 12.5 : 1 and a BSFC of about 0.55.

   But if we back off power to 65 percent, the POH tells us we can lean
   the mixture to a fuel flow of 17 gph. This gives an A/F of about 14
   and BSFC of just under 0.5. The reason we can lean is that we are
   using less manifold pressure, 25 in/Hg, versus 31.5 at 85 percent power.

   So we see that it is overall manifold pressure that determines how
   lean we can run. So we could in fact be running quite a bit of boost
   at high altitutde, but our overall manifold pressure is still lower
   than wide open throttle at sea level with zero boost.

   The great thing about turbocompounding for an engine like this is
   that you are getting a lot of "free" horsepower without having to
   add boost. With a turbocompound rotary engine, we could easily make
   over 300 hp at only 22 to 23 inches of manifold pressure. This gives
   us better fuel specifics, which decreases fuel load, which in turn
   increases full-fuel payload, something that most airplanes could use.

   At altitude the recovery turbine will do the most work due to the
   higher pressure ratio across the turbine wheel.

   Since the rotary does not have an exhaust valve to burn out due to
   lean mixtures, you can run well past peak EGT. I've heard 200
   degrees lean of peak mentioned. This is probably an air-fuel ratio
   of 18 : 1 or even leaner.

   The turbo Continental is a fine engine, but we can see how much
   better the turbocompound rotary will be.


   Regards,

   Gordon.




The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.