Subject: Error in your website NOT :)
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 4/3/2007, 4:32 AM
To: AARotary Engine


The rotary has only two firing chambers and will run
with only two spark plugs while the four cylinder
needs a minimum four spark plugs with four firing
chambers. Therefore those two rotary plugs fire
twice as often at any given RPM as both engines fire
twice per rev.

Each (leading) plug fires once per rev on a rotary,
and each plug fires once every two revs on a
four-stroke engine, which I believe I noted in the
email to which you are replying.  The situation with a
rotary in terms of dwell and coil saturation is the
same as that of a four-stroke four cylinder motorcycle
using two coils in a waste-fire configuration (each
coil fires once per engine revolution).

On your site, however, you say the following:  "Rotary
engines fire four times as often as a four cylinder
AC engine", which as you noted above is not the case
(unless you're including the trailing plugs, which
have their own coil, and which I consider outside the
realm of the conversation, since trying to run a
rotary on trailing plugs alone won't provide any
usable power).

Assuming you are using a single coil for a 4-cyl
four-stroke engine, you will have one firing event per
engine rotation.  With a single coil to handle two
rotors, it's twice that.  While your point about 4x
the spark events per plug in a flying rotary (because
of the higher engine speed and the twice as frequent
ignition per plug per engine rpm) is sound (and I
would recommend seeing if anyone makes an iridium plug
for that app, as they will last an amazingly long
time, especially in very high-heat environments (they
were originally designed for 1000+ bhp turbo engines,
which tended to destroy conventional electrodes with
one pass down the dragstrip), coil saturation/dwell
time is not as huge an issue as you appear to imply on
the site.  I definitely agree with the points you make
regarding CDI.  One thing I have noted, and this may
not be important in an aircraft application, is that
under marginal mixture combustion conditions, having a
longer duration for the spark often makes more power,
due to the equivalent of holding the match next to the
tinder longer.  This is the sole area where CDI comes
up a bit short; with proper tuning and a reasonably
homogenous mixture, though, it should be little
trouble, if any at all.

The same goes for individual coils AKA one per spark
plug.

I didn't think you were making that comparison (I
thought you were talking about one coil or magneto for
the entire 4-cyl engine.  Yes, with one coil per plug,
you get twice as much dwell at any given engine speed
on a 4-cyl four stroke as the same setup on a 2 rotor
engine.  Since even fairly small coils can handle the
requirements of two plugs on a high-revving 4-cyl four
stroke, however, I don't see a huge advantage in going
to COP for a 4-cyl.  You could, however, use smaller
coils (like COP) to save weight.  Even those tiny COP
coils can handle well over 14,000 rpm (production
Denso units used on a number of late-model sportbikes)
without issues about dwell and saturation (due to the
use of a CDI and there being no losses in the plug
wire, since there isn't one).  You could run a
two-rotor engine with one of those COP units (assuming
two plugs and a Y-shaped plug wire, and ignoring for
the moment the losses involved in the plug wires) at
3500 rpm without problems, and they are about the size
of a permanent magic marker.  A pair of them on a
2-rotor engine, fired sequentially, could handle over
7,000 rpm before there would be issues with dwell and
saturation.  Especially with CDI, as long as you have
a properly-size capacitor and enough current to work
with, coil saturation is a fairly small issue, IME.

Do you really think that the difference is that
tremendous in terms of spark energy and plug life in a
rotary, based on the number of firings alone?  I've
had iridium plugs in my personal motorcycle for 50,000
miles and they look brand-new.  The two small coils on
the bike fire once per engine revolution up to 11,000
rpm, delivering approx. 85 bhp at the crank from 615
cc of displacement (10.25:1 CR, CV carbed), to give
you a point of comparison.  I will fully acknowledge,
however, that the environment in which rotary engine
plugs live is a far harsher environment than that seen
on most anything besides a highly boosted turbo 4-cyl,
but not because of the extra spark events themselves.
If the number of spark events was the main issue,
you'd see exhaust systems on road-going 4-cyl engines
being made to the same spec as those on a 2-rotor
rotary (as they'd be carrying the same quantity of
gases from the same number of firing events as found
on a 2-rotor rotary).  This is not the case, however;
rotary exhaust have to withstand much higher
temperatures, even when naturally aspirated.  It's the
temperature more than anything, IME, that is the
biggest factor in the shortened life of certain
components when compared to non-rotary applications.

In other words, I agree with you that it's a very
harsh environment.  :)  Just for different reasons
than you appear to state.

This of course ignores the fact the Mazda rotary has
two spark plugs per rotor.

True, but each set of plugs has its own section of the
distributor and its own coil.  For all intents and
purposes, the systems are separated (ignoring
mechanical linkages in the distributor on cars so
equipped).  If you were talking about COP and wanted
to use the trailing plugs (and dyno work does not show
any meaningful decrease in power output without them),
the situation would be basically the same as we've
been discussing, you'd just have twice as many
components.  Each plug and coil would fire once per
E-shaft revolution, there'd just be twice as many of
everything.

Each group of two fires more or less at the same
time. They do not alternate fire. They could
of course but I have never seen a rotary set up like
that.

I'm a little confused here.  Have a look over here:
<http://rotaryengineillustrated.com/how-a-wankel-rotary-engine-works/timing-ignition.html>

There's even an animation.  While the
distributor-equipped cars, as well as the 2nd gen cars
I have looked at, do not use waste fire on the leading
plugs, there is no reason NOT to waste fire them if a
single coil is being used for the leading plugs
(except possibly for emissions reasons).  The trailing
plugs, however, are not waste-fired, and cannot be;
here's a quote on the subject from the website
referenced above.  "The trailing plugs cannot be fired
in wastespark mode due to the location of the plug
above the minor axis -- when one trailing plug is
firing, the other trailing plug is already in the next
working chamber, where it would preignite the incoming
air-fuel mixture."  Here's another quote on the
subject, from <http://www.smbaker.com/rail/msd6a.html>
(which talks about using the MSD 6A and twin coils
(some people use the dual leading plug coils from a
second gen RX-7, and some use two aftermarket coils),
which might be a good option for rotary use):
"However, we can't utilize a wasted spark system on
the trailing plugs. The reason for this is that there
is actually a chance of the wasted spark on a trailing
plug igniting the combustion chamber in the incorrect
cycle. This would be very bad, and would almost
certainly lead to engine damage."

So if you are referring to the trailing plugs (which I
thought you were), I think you're incorrect; if you
were talking about the leading plugs, it is certainly
possible to use waste fire, and you could run a
2-rotor rotary quite happily with a compact 2-plug
coil from nearly any multi-cylinder inline or
horizontally opposed motorcycle engine made between
about 1955 and 2003 (and most up through today,
although the tide is turning to COP for lighter weight
and especially space considerations) up to 6,000 rpm
or so; personally I'd want a larger coil, since I
regularly exceed 5,000 rpm in my daily driver.  :)

Thanks very much for your reply.  I've wanted to build
an experimental for quite a while, and once I have the
money, I think I may use my 1985 GSL-SE as a motor
donor (it's by far the healthiest part of the car).
What do you guys do for opening the aux ports on the
6-port 13B engines?  Or do you always use 4-port
engines (I don't know if a NA rotary engine would be
sufficient for aircraft use, but I am pretty sure that
Mazda only used 4 ports on its turbo engines up until
the RX-8)?

The RX-8, BTW, would be a really nice engine to work
with.  Comes with a coil per plug and fully electronic
ignition, although I'm not sure how well it would take
to being turbocharged (unless you used the turbo
strictly to make up for altitude).  It also has much
improved fuel economy, which may or may not translate
into greatly improved fuel economy when running LOP).

Adam Wade.

---------------------------------------------------------

NO MISTAKE


You are forgetting the two to one gearing of the rotary
engine as compared to the direct drive aircraft engine.
Therefor the rotary aircraft engine runs at twice the RPM.
The key phrase is: "four cylinder AC engine"

http://www.rotaryeng.net/Why-CDI-2.txt

"AC" stands for aircraft engine and typically they run at 2700
RPM maximum while the Mazda rotary in aircraft use runs at
7000 RPM for take off and 5000 RPM to 6000 RPM for cruise.
Yes we now typically uses one coil per spark plug.

We have used both six port and four port engines.
We run all the ports  wide open but the trend now is to p-ports.
Better breathing means  lower BSFC.

Also when considering the plug life you have to realize
the rotary engine in an airplane is running at 150 HP continuous
on average while in a car the number is closer to 40 HP.

I hope I covered all the points here but if not please
let me know.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.