Subject: Experimental air craft and rotary engines.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 4/8/2007, 12:43 AM
To: AARotary Engine




       Experimental air craft and rotary engines.

       I kind of think there needs to be two sets of discussions going
   on about
       rotary aircraft engines. One should be about the "bolt-on and go
       fly it"
       parts and pieces, and the other one should be for people that don't
       mind
       dead-sticking it occasionally (hah!).. And there should be some
   fairly
       clear distinctions between "experimental" and "standard". Just
   thinking
       out loud, mind you.

       And, what Paul said about certified engines is very true. And to
       answer
       a question Paul asked me a while back, but which I never
       answered. Probably
       about $2000/year for maintenance on my Cessna 182. Maybe more. And
       that's
       with me turning the wrenches mostly.

       Matt Prather
       ---------------------------------------------------------

       Yep, Matt is right. There is a spectrum of individuals involved
   in the
       homebuilt aviation community. That spectrum goes all the way from
       people who
       only are interested flying and pay someone else to build their
       airplanes to
       guys who create, build, and fly their own designs. The same is true
       when it
       comes to engines that power those homebuilt s. There are those who
       have the
       cash and no interest in tinkering; who just buy the firewall
   forward
       package
       and call it good. There are also those for whom the engine is soul
       of their
       airplane and devote their lives to its birth, care, and feeding.

       And, between both these extremes you've got you and me. We want to
       fly, but
       the technology and revolutionary concept behind the rotary sings its
       Siren's
       song and draws us in. It has all the attributes of a perfect
       aircraft power
       plant - and at an affordable price. What could be more alluring.
       There are
       so many advantages that we can't resist giving it a go.

       However, the state of aviation implementations for rotaries,
       especially the
       supporting systems, is not quite far enough along so that the
       average "Joe"
       can just plug and play. If you and I are in the middle of the
       spectrum and
       want the advantages of the rotary, but don't have the time,
   skills, or
       interest to devote to that experimentation then we're doomed to be
       unhappy
       either way we go. If we go with the rotary we're wedded to
   someone who
       constantly nags us and takes a lot of attention. If we go with
   Lycoming
       we're wedded to someone who isn't quite as needy but spends all our
       money.
       Pick your partner; that is unless you're into glider's.

       The progress of rotaries for aviation has come a long way in the
       last 15
       years. It's getting closer to plug and play at an affordable
   price -
       especially because of those pioneers on the far end of the
   spectrum like
       Paul Lamar, Tracy Crook, David Atkins, Ken Welter, Perry Mick,
   George
       Graham, Ed Anderson, and many, many, many more that have dedicated
       themselves to the soul of their aircraft. But we're not there yet
       and maybe
       we'll never really get there because it's a grass-roots effort
   without
       enough infrastructure to maintain momentum. Only time will tell.

       Thanx,
       Joe Hull

       ----------------------------------------------------------
       Unfortunately experimental aviation is evolving towards exploiting a
       loop hole
       in the FAA regulations bypassing the certified aircraft maintenance
       rules.
       It also lowers the cost of buying and owning an aircraft. This
       raises the
       expectations of the kit plane builder. That is why the EAA never
       mentions
       the word experimental. The question is how far is this going to go
       before
       the bureaucrats put a stop to it?

       I started this newsletter almost ten years ago to make it as easy as
       possible
       to adopt a rotary engine. It has not always worked. Some builders
       are not
       computer literate enough to use the Internet and many others
   don't avail
       themselves of the information that is on the Internet about the
   subject.
       Another group disbelieve what they read.

       I take some things for granted too many times as far as peoples
       knowledge of
       engines are concerned and I have failed to go over the fundamentals.
       I also
       have not added all things to the web site below. However some
       critical issues
       are on http://www.wankel.org/ Maintained by
       Mark Wrathal in Europe. This web
       site link and purpose is mentioned on the web site below. Please
       read it.

       The significance of the heat range of spark plugs is one of them. It
       was not
       until Joe broke an apex seal because of a overheated spark plug used
       too
       long did this subject come up. This is an extremely rare
   occurrence.
       People
       buy rotary engines from a builder and the builder does not take the
       time
       to educate the user on the correct spark plugs to use and why they
       should
       be used. With a certified engine you have no choice in the matter.
       There is one heat range plug and that is it. There may be
   several brands
       but they all have the same heat range. The rotary on the other
   hand has
       a wide range of plugs available depending on what use the rotary is
       put to.

       Hopefully this problem is now fixed. I recently uploaded a section
       to the
       website discussing this issue.

        http://www.rotaryeng.net/Spark-plugs/Spark-plugs.html

       Please read it.

       Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

       ------------------------------------------------------
       This looks good Paul..

       More questions.. For Joe: Prior to the insulator failure, how
   recently
       had the plugs been out and inspected? From the dark color in the pic
       posted, it doesn't appear that plug was running excessively hot.
   Hmm..

       I think it was discussed before, but I can't remember the
   answer. Was
       it predictable that the plug being used might be susceptible to
       overheating and failure (based on published heat range)?

       Maybe it should be standard practice to remove and inspect the plugs
       after each flight for the first 10 hours?

       I can see that picking a heat range for the plugs can be a
   challenge -
       especially given the number of variables involved. For instance,
   if the
       mixture is overly rich during ground running, it might be
   interpreted
       that the heat range is acceptably cool, when in fact at high
   power the
       plug may be running too hot.

       When there is some standardization in ignition, fuel delivery, and
       exhaust components, things are going to get easier... I wonder what
       Powersport uses in their engines..

       Another topic - Jim Mederer said that "only power matters" when
   tuning
       the engine. That says that the load meter built into the planetary
       reduction might really be a key component. Very cool. If you
   have a CS
       prop, you just lean the mixture until the torque peaks -
   assuming you
       have adequate cooling.

       Matt-


       I think the cylinder heat temperature thermal couple will also
       be a key component. I am very excited about Mark S's installation
       of CHT probes in his 3 rotor. This area is immediately adjacent
       to the spark plug.

       BTW Mark, I will drop off the 2, four channel data acq modules when
       I see you a week from this coming Sunday.

       IMHO Jim's suggestion of running plugs two steps cooler than normal
       is an excellent idea. If the engine will make it to the run up
       area with out fowling you have it made. It makes no sense at all to
       run street car heat range spark plug in an aircraft engine. Aircraft
       use is nothing like street car use.

       Paul Lamar


   Paul, Mark

   I'm curious about Mark's installation of thermocouples as shown in the
   photos.  Will there be trouble with electromagnetic interference from
   the the plug/plug wires?  I know the wiring will be shielded, but am
   curious as to what type/class of shielding will he use?  Also what type
   of T/C and range and or part number.  Thanks.

   Allen
   Houston

   That is something I hadn't heard of. The CHT probes are real close
   to the plug wires in my O-470 and that does not appear to be
   a problem. On the other hand they and the spark plug wires are
   shielded. I guess it is possible. If we sample the data often
   enough the spark will appear in the data at idle.

   Have you experienced RF interference with thermocouples?

   I'll let Mark answer the last questions as I don't know
   what he used.

   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Hi Allen,

I used regular unshielded thermocouple wire and quality automotive
silicone plug wires.  I'm using Tracy's EC-2 and EM-2.  So far, the CHT
readings are rock steady, so I would conclude that interference isn't a
problem.  That could change with the data loggers, but I'll have to wait
and see.

Mark S.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.