Subject: Selecting a turbo charger for aircraft use.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 4/19/2007, 6:28 AM
To: AARotary Engine


        Yes it is my stock turbo but not failed yet. The first time I saw
        it on the Mecanair (now Mistral) rotary aircraft engine at OSH I
    said:
        "Wow look at that. A stock 1989-1991 Mazda 13B turbo rotary
aircraft
        engine." Water cooled, waste gate, heat shielded and all plumbed up
        with a very compact installation. Perfect for aircraft use.

        Unfortunately I under
        estimated the HP of the turbine and over estimated the
effectiveness
        of the waste gate. John Slade installed one and proceeded to blow
it
        up due to a combination of over temp. and over rev. Mecanair
        became Mistral and Mistral tasked Emory Riddle to install and test
        the turbo
        engine in a Piper Arrow and proceeded to blow the turbo up.
        Unfortunately they did not tell us about that until way
        later. Dave Leonard installed the Mazda turbo engine in his RV6 and
        proceeded to blow up the turbo.

        By that time I had figgered out the turbine would make an excellent
        turbo compound turbine because of the huge amount of excess HP
        it possessed. The reason it has so much HP is it is needed to
        rapidly accelerate the turbo charger for use in cars that need
        the boost RIGHT NOW. Not in a second or two.

        You were not on the
        Newsletter Buly at that time so you proceeded to install the
        stock turbo and blow it up also. My main man Dave Leonard
    persevered,
        figured out the problem and fixed it by using a larger compressor
        to load and slow down the turbine. He also bored out the hole in
        the waste gate and removed the waste gate flapper. Apparently it
        is now fixed. We will soon know as Dave is getting ready to fly
        again after his fine service tour in Iraq. Thank you again Dave
        for all you do here and in Iraq.
        ------------------------------------------------------

        It is not too difficult to match the compressor to the
        amount of engine HP you would like to generate. That is the easy
        part. We have several spread sheets from different people
        that achieve that task. I suspect the problem is the turbines
        that go with these compressors are way too powerful for aircraft
        use. If somebody went to Garrett and said I won't x compressor map
        Garrett would give them a turbo charger turbine designed for
        automotive use. In other words a turbo charger that would
accelerate
        rapidly and then be backed off to shift. If run at sustained high
        power it would soon over rev and explode I have no doubt.

        We need HP data on Garret turbines that will
        not over rev the turbochargers at steady state high altitude
        use. So far and as far as I can tell that info is not fourth
        coming from Garrett. I suspect we need an A/R over one.
        I also suspect no off the shelf automotive turbo charger
        is going to work. We will have to mix and match turbine with
        compressor. Garrett does not discuss this scenario on their
        web site. Also they donnot discuss turbocharger acceleration.
        If we knew the rotating moment of inertia for the
        compressor/shaft/turbine and the acceleration in terms of RPM
    per second
        per second we could figure out the turbine HP.


http://www.turbobygarrett.com/turbobygarrett/tech_center/turbo_tech103.html

        Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

        Paul,

        I have been working on adding the turbine side to my spreadsheet
for
        the last few days.

        Modeling a turbine is very easy -- with one big proviso -- that you
        know the pressure of the gases on the inlet side. In other
    words, we
        need to know exhaust pressures coming out of the engine.

        Ahh, but there's the rub. Estimating the engine exhaust pressures
is
        the hard part, because you basically have to come up with a
        mathematical model of the Otto cycle engine that will give you
        cylinder pressures and exhaust pressures. I thought this was
    going to
        be as easy as modeling a turbine, but it's not. All the models for
        Otto cycle engines are very complex if they are to be of any use. I
        would appreciate hearing from anyone with ideas on this.


        Also, I have to disagree with your comments about big turbines
being
        "too powerful" for a rotary aircraft engine. Big turbines only make
        lots of power if they have a lot of exhaust energy to work with.

        Big turbines are used on relatively small certified aircraft
engines
        for a very good reason -- the big turbine won't spin up until there
        is significant exhaust energy going across the turbine wheel. And
        that only happens at altitude, where the pressure ratio between
        intake and outlet is high.

        That is why the aircraft turbonormalizing systems can work well
    with
        fixed wastegates. There is simply not enough energy in the exhaust
        at sea level for the big turbine to spin up and make much, if any,
        boost from the compressor. Therefore an adjustable wastegate is not
        needed. Here's why:

        When the plane climbs up into thinner air, the pressure difference
        between the intake side of the turbine and the outlet side
        increases. This is because the outlet side of the turbine is equal
        to ambient pressure, which is dropping. The inlet side of the
        turbine is simply the exhaust pressure of the engine. This is a
        function of the intake manifold pressure.

        So we see that if the intaek manifold pressure remains the same
        -- which it will be if you have boost -- and the outlet pressure
        drops, the net result will be a steeper pressure gradient across
the
        turbine wheel. The higher you go, the lower the ambient pressure
        drops and the bigger the pressure ratio across the turbine will be
        (provided you can maintain a steady intake manifold pressure, or
    MAP).

        What does that mean? This pressure ratio between the inlet and
        outlet side of the turbine is what is called a turbine pressure
        ratio, TPR, and is the single biggest factor in how much power any
        turbine will make.

        The higher the TPR, the more quickly the gases will accelerate
        across the wheel, because air, or any fluid, will always accelerate
        more quickly from an area of high pressure to low pressure.

        You can see this with a tire that is pumped up to a high perssure
        and one that is nearly flat. The highly pressurized tire will blow
a
        very energetic jet if you open the valve, while the nearly flat
tire
        will have a very weak jet. Or suppose you have a tire that is
    pumped
        to a very high pressure, but you also pressurize the room in which
        it is sitting (like a barometric chamber). Now when you open the
        valve, there will be very little energy in the jet, just like the
        almost flat tire at ambient pressure. This illustrates that it is
        the pressure ratio, not absolute pressures that is the key.

        How does this translate into power? The rapid acceleration of gas
        across the turbine wheel when there is a a high TPR creates high
        momentum, and that momentum imparts force to the turbine wheel,
        which in turn, will spin faster and make more power. (Every turbine
        pilot is familiar with TPR and NPR, the nozzle pressure ratio,
    which
        is used to set engine power, along with rpm.)

        http://www.grc.nasa.gov/WWW/K-12/airplane/powtrbth.html

        Like I said it is an easy matter to calculate the turbine hp with
        very good accuracy if you know the inlet and outlet pressures --
        using the ideal gas law, which equates temperatures, pressures and
        volumes.

        But the whole thing depends on being able to estimate exhaust
        pressure coming out of the engine -- because this is the inlet side
        of the turbine. (Whether the turbine is driving a compressor, or is
        recovering power and feeding it mechanically back to the engine
    shaft).

        Another thing you touched on is that we don't have much turbine
data
        from Garrett. This is true, but not such a big problem.

        For example if you take a compressor map on my spreadsheet and see
        how much power that compressor is absorbing in the heart of its
map,
        you know the turbine that is matched with that compresoror (the one
        Garret inlcudes as a matched set), will be working at its design
    point.

        Now, if you know the exhaust flow and pressure coming out of the
        engine, you can figure out just how much power is actually
available
        to drive a turbine. This will always be more than it takes to drive
        the compressor. So you know how much excess hp your exhaust is
        capable of making, beyond driving the compressor.

        What you do then is simply go to a bigger map and find a compressor
        that can absorb all of the exhaust power you just calculated. You
        then take the turbine that goes with that really big compressor and
        use it with the smaller compresor that you selected previously.
This
        will work just fine with a turbocompound engine as well.

        True, having more turbine data would make things even better, but
it
        is not really necessary. And since it is not forthcoming from
        Garrett, it is a moot point.


        Regards,

        Gordon.


        I didn't use the words "big turbine" Gordon. What I did say was:

        "turbines that go with these compressors are way too powerful for
        aircraft
        use."

        Almost any physical size turbine will generate a wide range of
    power
        depending on the pressure or velocity of the gases feeding it and
        the RPM it
        is capable of. HP is proportional to torque times RPM.

        The back exhaust pressure on the engine will be a strong function
        of the turbine used. Low A/R's numbers are not free. You won't know
        the back
        pressure until you know more about the turbines available. Also the
        engine
        HP is a function of the exhaust back pressure. It is a chicken
    and egg
        problem. Good luck until you come up with some meaningful off
    the shelf
        turbine information. So far Dave Leonard and others have gone
        through the
        trial and error process of adding a larger compressor and
    opening up the
        waste gate. Dave is closer to a solution than anybody IMHO.

        What we need to do is measure the exhaust back pressure, the RPM
        of the turbo charger, engine MAP and the temperature
        drop across the turbine. That will give us some data points.
        Dave is closer than any of us so Dave if you would please measure
        the EGT
        on both sides of the turbine that would be a start. Then we need
        a turbo charger tachometer. Once we have some of that kind of data
        We can tell if we need to go up or down on the A/R.

        Also the life of the turbine is a factor so you want the lowest
    turbo
        charger RPM and smallest diameter turbine that does the job. The
        centrifugal force on the blades is m times V^2/r Where m is the
    mass
        of the
        blade and V is its tangential velocity of the blade and r is the
        radius of the
        blade's CG. Of course V is also a function of r at any given RPM.

        The strength of the blade is an inverse exponential function of the
        temperature. Needless to say the rotary applies extra requirements
        on turbo
        chargers due to the higher temperature of its exhaust.

        Higher tensile strength to density ratio high temperature materials
        like Inconel help.

        The problem here is not finding a turbo charger that generates
        the boost. Almost any turbo charger will do that. The problem
        is finding one that lives, generates the required boost and
    imposes a
        minimum of back pressure on the engine.

        Even Hughe MacInnes says: "Start with your best guess and
    adjust." :)

        Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

        Paul,

        Since you mentioned Dave Leonard's turbo, I will take this
        opportunity to point out that his experience illustrates exactly
        what I'm talking about.

        Correct me if I'm wrong, but Dave started with a stock turbo from
        the car which quickly blew up once he started flying a bit higher.

        The reason is not hard to see: the small turbine is designed to
work
        at sea level TPR. Once you take that turbine to altitude, the TPR
        increases dramatically which means a lot more energy working on the
        turbine wheel, causing it to overspeed.

        And since the compressor was pretty small too, it could only absorb
        fairly small amount of power, so it couldn't do much to slow down
        the overspinning turbine.

        Then Dave put a bigger compressor on which absorbed more power and
        slowed the turbine down a bit. But it still wasn't enough, so he
had
        to open up the wastegate to divert more flow around the turbine.

        This shows exactly that the small turbines for cars just can't
        handle the TPR you get at altitude.

        Dave could have achieved the same result by going to a bigger
        turbine that would take more power to spin up. But he doesn't have
        room under his cowl for a bigger turbine, so he has to divert flow
        from the small turbine. The net result is exactly the same.

        The ideal solution, of course is to use a turbine that is big
    enough
        so that you don't need to divert much, if any flow, through a
        wastegate. That is what the small turbo Continentals use. Notice
the
        small size of that fixed wastegate in the picture I uploaded
    earlier.

        If you looked at the size of those turbines and compressors you
        would be surprised. They are surprisingly big.

        Also, since you mentioned materials, this is a very important
point.
        A turbo failure in an airplane is not a non-event. It can lead to a
        forced landing, engine fire and all kinds of bad stuff.

        Turbos are serious items and should be treated as such. Not just
the
        turbos themselves but also the exhaust plumbing and all the
        components. A lot of people who build their own planes are drawn to
        the allure of the turbocharger, but the reality is that this only
        presents more opportunities for problems.

        Everything has to be done at a very high level of design and
        workmanship if you are to avoid problems. I'm not trying to talk
        anybody out of it -- I'd love to build myself a turbo too -- I'm
        just asying it's not as simple as all that...


        Regards,

        Gordon.
    "a bigger turbine that would take more power to spin up"

    This is not necessarily true. "spin up" is a vague term.
    This sounds like acceleration.

    Are you talking about turbine acceleration or steady state
    turbine RPM? If the HP of the turbine is below that required
    of the compressor than yes the larger turbine will not exceed
    the turbo charger red line. As I pointed out before the size of the
    turbine is only one factor in the HP it makes.

    Putting it another way if the torque output of the turbine equals
    the torque
    required by the compressor than the turbo charger reaches a steady
    state RPM. The A/R probably has more to do with it.

    I have looked at many turbos on aircraft engines. Here is a dual
    turbo set up on a Lycoming. These look pretty small to me. Looks like
    a TO3.  This is a 640 cubic inch engine or 320 cubic inch per turbo.

    Yes of course high altitude speeds up the turbo. Nobody is saying it
    won't.
    I think MacInnes calculated it around 10 or 15%.

    The point is if you ran it at sea level at a constant 5 or 10 psi
    boost hour after hour it would still blow up at 150 engine HP and
    the implied exhaust gas heat. It takes about two hours at 10,000 feet.
    It is a fatigue situation. The fatigue limit stress of the turbine
    blade material is being exceeded at that operating temperature.

    At 150,000 RPM it does not take long to exceed several million
    cycles. 20 minutes in fact for 3 million cycles. Add the extra heat of
    a rotary and you have a real problem.

    There is absolutely no question that the stock
    turbine has way more power than needed for aircraft use and it will
    over rev the turbo charger as far as the reasonably life red line
    should be.
    If it did not have the excess HP the turbo charger would not accelerate
    when needed.

    The stock turbo is designed for momentary use at max turbocharger RPM
    if ever it gets going that fast.

    As you accelerate through the gears the turbine speeds up towards peak
    RPM and then the driver shifts to a lower gear. Soon the car is doing
    well over the speed limit and the driver and the turbo slow down.
    Also a lot of heat in the exhaust then goes away as the average
    HP needed by a car is around 40 HP.

    BTW Gordon could please use your spelling checker.

    Fortunately so far the turbine failures have not led to any crashes.
    The engine just looses power but has enough power to make it back to
the
    airport apparently. I am sure Dave will fill us in on this.

    Paul Lamar


Hi Paul,

Glad to see you think I am so close to a solution.  We really should
wait until my turbo has at least 500 hrs before we get too crazy.  I am
mostly just waiting on my painter theses days.  Apparently, 18 months is
not enough time to paint the flying surfaces...  anyway.

Re-compressor maps - Gordon is right.  They are completely independent
of the turbine or whatever source is used to drive the compressor.
However, you size the turbine to match the RPM and exhaust energy you
have available.  Strange that there is so much info about compressors
but little info about turbines.

Given the fact that I have such a large fixed bypass and am still making
adequate boost, I am tempted to say that there is no turbine A/R that is
too large (just get the biggest one available).  However, the problem
with that would be that the larger turbines are more sensitive to over
speed---  i.e. they operate generally at a lower RPM range.  If your
compressor requires 100k RPM to make your desired boost, then your
turbine needs to live at that speed as well.  Smaller turbines tolerate
higher speeds better.  By this logic, I may very well have stumbled upon
the best set-up for the every-day flyer:  A significantly enlarged
compressor with a moderately enlarged turbine with lots of exhaust
energy being diverted around the turbine.  For extreme performance (very
high altitude or racing - the formula would obviously be different).

This more ore less implies that you just want the turbine that usually
goes with your given compressor, but both should be on the
larger-than-automobile-application side.
-- 

David Leonard

Turbo Rotary RV-6 N4VY
N4VY.RotaryRoster.net <http://N4VY.RotaryRoster.net>
www.RotaryRoster.net <http://www.RotaryRoster.net>
leonardiniraq.blogspot.com <http://leonardiniraq.blogspot.com>

Hello to everyone,

I don't have much time as I am leaving this afternoon for the Aero 2007
airshow in Friedrichshafen, Germany this afternoon.  However, as Mistral is
mentioned in this discussion and as turbos are a hot topic for us, I feel I
should give you a quick overview:

- Yes, Mistral Engines and Embry-Riddle did test fly a turbo 13B engine.
The turbo was the standard one on 1993-95 Mazda engines.
- This turbo, and more particularly its hot section, is perfectly tuned to
the very particular exhaust characteristics of the rotary (very powerful
exhaust pulses, particular timing considerations of the ports opening).  It
is a "close-coupled" (the turbine inlet is only a couple of inches away from
the exhaust ports), twin-scroll turbine with a particular A/R ratio.
However, it is optimised for automotive use (fast pick-up and higher torque
at relatively low rpm) and certainly not for aircraft use.
- In a nut-shell:  the turbo works fine at low altitude but will overspeed
somewhere between 10 and 15,000 feet.  The combination of high temp and high
turbine rpm lowers its turbine's life expectancy down to 50-100 hours.
Unacceptable.
- Mistral did an intensive study and developed detailed specs of what turbo
was needed for a rotary in an aviation duty-cycle.  On the compressor side,
it's ok, some commercially available compressors are just fine.  On the
turbine side, bad news, NO commercially available turbine fits the bill.
They all fall short either in terms of lifetime expectancy and/or
efficiency.  It is not really surprising after all:  as mentioned above,
rotaries have very peculiar exhaust characteristics, and no turbo has ever
been developed to work on a rotary in thin air as far as I know.
- Result:  Mistral, in partnership with a specialised turbocharger
engineering firm, is developing a proprietary turbo (hot section only).
Prototypes should be manufactured in the next few months and tested this
fall.  More on that later.

Fly safe and see you at Oshkosh.

Francois Badoux, Mistral Engines

Hold your messages folks. I am too busy at Sun N Fun.
I'll try to get cought up.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.