At the beginning … there was the reciprocating engine.
2-strokes and 4-strokes.
Nowadays, 2-strokes are hardly used anymore.
Any reputable engine is a four-stroke. This is our standard, our base
engine we compare another engine with.
Then, the Mazda Rotary engine arrived on the scene. What is this? How
does it work? How much power per its displacement? Well, what is its
displacement?
All these questions come up, naturally.
So what do we do? We simply compare it with the known 4-stroke RPE. Not
least, as the Rotary also works on the 4-stroke principle.
A [SINGLE CYLINDER] reciprocating piston four-stroke requires "two" crankshaft
revolutions to complete its four-cycle operation. Accordingly, its displacement is
that achieved at two shaft rotations. [I don't think so Rolf. Check Taylor]
In comparing power and displacement, we must obviously use the same rpm
for all to be equal and one standard for all engines regardless if RPE
or Rotary.
The Mazda RX7/8 displaces 650 cc per rotor and per rotation. At two
rotors and two rotations the displacement is 2.6 litres.
Up to just recently we were all in agreement with that.
Then, Gordon arrived at the scene….
Gordon makes no mistakes with his calculation; however he does with his
designations.
Gordon uses now two terms: A) the "equivalent displacement" of 2.6 litre
and B) the "real displacement" of 1.3 litre. For the term 'real' he uses
at times 'actual' or 'effective'.
We all know the Rotary is equivalent to a 2.6 litre RPE. By doing so we
are able to use the same formulae, the same rpm, the same everything. No
problem.
Saying the Rotary is a 1.3 litre does confuse things. The formulae must
be changed; both engines can no longer be compared on the same basis.
All is just 'wrong'.
Why coin a new term for the Rotary such as "real displacement" when it
is not usable with the same existing formulae? Doing this we are unable
to compare it with the RPE, which is what we wanted to do at the first
place. We want to know how it 'compares' to the RPE we are all familiar
with. That is what it is all about.
Coining a new term for the Rotary and calling it by only half its
displacement is simply deceit. Mazda used it for tax reasons. As I
understand it, lately they are not using it anymore, but just calling it
the Rotary.
To make the four-stroke Rotary 'equal' and 'comparable' to a four-stroke
RPE, we must call it a 2.6 litre engine. Otherwise we are cheating. We
are trying to say it can make twice as much power per displacement as an
RPE, which it cannot.
Regards
Rolf Pfeiffer
I agree with almost everything except were noted above in brackets.
Paul Lamar
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.