Subject: OEM engine computer (Stock Engines in Homebuilt Planes]
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/4/2007, 12:08 AM
To: AARotary Engine



   Paul, and the group

   A lot has been written about aftermarket computers for our aero
   conversions. However, is there any reason why the stock engine
   computer
   can not be used? Does anyone have any experience in using
   stock? Good or
   bad? How does one go about configuring the stock unit for
   aircraft use?
   Engine is a 13b single turbo with fuel injection.

   Thanks and regards,

   --
   Erik Snyman
   Messina
   South Africa.

   Perry Mick has over 500 hours with the stock computer. There are a
   few tricks
   however. The stock computer takes in some data from certain
   places that
   don't exist in an airplane. I'll let Perry explain it if he
   doesn't
   mind.
   As I recall the big hang up is leaning it. Perry was working on a
   solution
   for that as I recall.


   ---------------------------------------------------------------------
   BTW HKS makes a bunch of add on device that change the output
   of the
   varies
   RX8 engine sensors in real time. I suspect they are basically
   PICAXEs with
   analog to digital converters that take in the sensor voltage and
   covert it to a
   different analog output voltage to be fed into the stock OEM
   computer.
   I think this is the way they did it with this 390 HP turbo RX8
   engine.
   http://www.rotaryeng.net/Turbo-RX8a.jpg

   For example if you wanted to lean the OEM computer for use at
   high altitude you would take in the mass air flow sensor output
   voltage
   and change it so the the stock OEM computer thought it was
   getting less
   air than it actually was. Consequently it would put out less fuel.
   Pretty easy to do with a $30 PICAXE.

   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


   Paul,

   I would have reservations about using an OEM computer at high
   altitudes. (Or any computer that has not been proven for aircraft
   use, for that matter.)

   The reason is that as atmospheric pressure drops, it becomes easier
   for electrical current to jump gaps and end up where it's not
   supposed to. We see this in aircraft magnetos that have arc-over at
   higher altitudes. That's why some of the turbocharged planes have
   pressurized magnetos.

   It is anyone's guess how the electronics inside an engine computer
   will behave at pressure of even half that at sea level (15,000 feet
   approx.). They may work fine, they may not.

   My own opinion is that I would rather not fly a stock engine
   computer above 10 to 12 thousand feet. At this altitude the stock
   computer should be able to handle the leaning anyway.

   For any serious flying above that, my preference is for a purely
   mechanical ignition system (flywheel magneto, a la Rotax), and carb
   or mechanical fuel injection.


   Regards,

   Gordon.

   Those are real high voltages Gordon. Not a problem at 5 volts.
   Sparks are
   20,000 volts and up.
   Most engine computers have a coating over the parts called a
   conformal
   coating which acts as an insulator. At Pikes peak in Colorado there
   is a road to the top at 14,000 feet as I recall where the
   public can and do drive to the top. Perry has had no trouble with
   this in
   over 500 hours.

   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

   Paul,

   Yes, the voltage in magnetos is very high, but so is the distance
   that the current jumps -- close to an inch in some cases. Even at
   smaller voltage you can get arcing if your gap is small enough.

   The minimum sparking voltage for air is I believe 327 volts, so it
   should not be a problem if it is 5 volts like you say. But if the
   voltage is above that, then the air pressure and distance of
   the gap
   come into play. The lower the pressure, the bigger the gap that the
   current will jump, according to Paschen's Law.

   Anyway don't get me wrong, I am not against stock engines. In
   fact I
   think a bone-stock engine is a very good way to go for an airplane
   of modest performance. The automakers have made great strides
   in the
   reliability of engine computers and sensors. Most of today's
   better-built cars will wear out long before they have an
   ECU-related
   breakdown.

   In fact, when it comes to adapting these engines for use in
   homebuilt airplanes, the problems usually occur with the stuff
   that
   we add or modify -- like reduction drives, exhaust systems,
   fuel and
   charging systems, etc.

   I really think that an airplane designed to take a box-stock RX8
   engine and run it as is without any kind of modification or
   add-ons,
   would be an excellent idea. In fact, I am designing such a
   plane and
   intend to build and fly it. I will have some preliminary 3D
   drawings
   on my ductedfanaircraft group on Yahoo in a few days.

   It is a twin-boom design, like a Cessna 336 or Adam A-500, with the
   engine and duct in the back of the fuselage "stub." It will require
   no reduction drive or any add-ons whatsoever. Even the stock
   exhuast
   system can be used as it is pointing the right way (aft).

   The propulsive efficiency will be very close to that of a propeller
   plane, but the big advantage is you can just take a box-stock RX-8
   engine, bolt it in and fly. However, I am limiting this plane to
   12,000 feet, above which you need oxygen anyway (to be legal).

   But when we start talking about turbocharged planes and flying at
   high altitudes, it means re-engineering a lot of the supporting
   systems on the engine. At that point, it makes more sense to me to
   go with mechanical systems for fuel and ignition.


   Regards,

   Gordon.

   A few issues...

   I believe that 327V applies to a 0.1" air gap. It would make sense that
   smaller gaps can be jumped by lower voltage.

   You can go to 14k' MSL without O2 here in the US.. I've actually been
   that high to get some relief from turbulence while crossing a pass on a
   windy day. Above 12.5k' MSL for more than thirty minutes requires O2.
   I wouldn't own an airplane that had any sort of equipment driven
   altitude restriction..

   As has been discussed here before, automotive emissions laws force the
   computer to run at stoichiometric mixture. Significantly better BSFC
   numbers can be achieved by leaning. If you run a stock computer the
   utility/economy of the plane can be improved if you come up with a way
   to fool the computer. You might think that the amount of time at
   partial throttle is limited, but I can think of a couple of scenarios
   where part power is used for long periods - westbound x-country is often
   flown at low altitude to minimize the impact of strong westerly winds..

   It would be relatively easy to test the function and reliability of an
   engine management computer at a simulated worst case altitude - in a
   depressurized (and instrumented) chamber.


   Matt-
Paul, and the group

Thanks for all the replies to my question. I totally agree with Gordon
re. the stock installation. Homebuilders by nature (most, anyway) are
looking for alternatives to high costs associated with general aviation,
so money lay-out is a big consideration. Using the std. car setup as is
would help there.

Where high altitude is concerned, my current steed, a C172M, battle to
see 12000 ft. anyway, and to feed oxygen to 2 small boys is difficult,
at best. So, my flying altitude seldom exceeds 10000 ft. I suspect that
for these altitudes and moderate performance (180 hp) the stock 13b
transplant will work. I also think (no experience) that these conditions
will limit the overspeed problem of the stock turbo. As you rightly
pointed out, Pikes Peak is a lot higher than what the majority of us
fly, and as far as leaning goes, a little rich of peak has never hurt.
Consumption might suffer a bit, but at an average of less than 100 hours
per year flown by the typical private pilot, I think rich running will
be ok if the trade-off is lower installation cost and reliability of the
stock systems.

Perry, I would be interested in finding what you did to fool the
computer about missing sensors.

Thanks and regards,

--
Erik Snyman
Messina
South Africa.


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.