Subject: Racing Beat P Port Rotor housings
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/7/2007, 6:02 AM
To: AARotary Engine


     > That probably helps a little. As I said the lack of over lap has
    more to
     > do with idle than anything else. Actually on balance I would say
     > the side exhaust ports probably add a wee bit of back pressure.
     > --
     > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

    Gordon ,
    I'm not going against anything Paul has said, however if I could add a
    little in saying, I asked the same sort of questions of mechanical
    engineers
    and their answer was that that most engines tolerate some overlap (can't
    remember the degrees exactly). So the overlap of the RX7 is in line with
    this tolerance. I can't imagine the P-port being any worse in the RX8,
    although I haven't sat down and tried to work it out in degrees. We are
    speaking here primarily about idle as the higher RPM eliminates
    contamination, as the exhaust is self evacuating at the higher exhaust
    speed/RPM. In fact it's more likely to suck in some inlet charge at
    higher
    RPM.
    George (down under)


    George,

    Yes, I believe an overlap between exhaust close and intake open can
    indeed promote cylinder filling.

    In fact I have heard racing types say that the suction effect of the
    exhaust can be several times more powerful than the relatively weak
    suction effect of the piston moving down the cylinder.

    The key appears to be tuning the length of the exhaust pipes to take
    advantage of the negative pressure wave, which is reflected back up
    the pipe (toward the cylinder) at the point where there is a
    discontinuity in the pipe, such as at the exhaust collector.

    This negative pressure wave can be so strong in racing engines with
    lots of valvle overalp and tuned headers, that it is said to
    actually produces something of a supercharging effect by
    accelerating the incoming charge.

    I would imagine that the rotary could be tuned in the same manner,
    but I don't think this is needed in an aircraft engine. And
    obviously the idle quality would suffer.

    It's interesting that the Renesis has zero overlap and yet makes
    very good power. Anyway, I think it's pure speculation how a
    p-ported Renesis engine is going to perform. But I think it would
    certainly be a worthwhile project to experiment with.


    Regards,

    Gordon.

Gordon,
I must say I agree!
I also like the idea Paul is suggesting, i.e.  Tig welding in a P-Port SS
tube to the  steel liner. Welding ( Tig) in an aluminium tube would also be
good - from what I've seen distortion can be controlled by a good Tig
welder.
George ( down under)

The problem with tig welding on the aluminum side is the welder does
not have 360 degree access to the weld line.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.