Subject: Ellison type tube hole patterns and sizes
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/13/2007, 6:33 PM
To: AARotary Engine




         I calculated the air opening area of the slide in .2 inch travel
         increments.
         I then attempted to match the fuel flow to the slide opening area.
         Roughly speaking it takes 27 .013" dia. holes variably spaced
         along the tube. Each hole passes enough fuel for 4.45 HP at 2
   psi so
         27 holes is 120 HP per runner. 240 HP for the p-port engine.

         As Ben Ellison says this causes a stepped ramp digital supply
   of fuel.
         In other words the engine goes from rich to lean and back to
   rich as
         the
         slide moves. The problem is severe in the first one third
         travel of the slide throttle. Ellison largely got around this by
         using much
         smaller holes and many more of them. My guess by looking at
   them is
         they can be
         as small as .1 mm or around 6 thousands of an inch. He
   probably has
         close to 100 holes in his tubes.

         BTW I can't for the life of me figure out how they can make a
   drill that
         small but they do. Airgas sells them for $45 each.

         More, much smaller holes, soon becomes a problem in a single
   row as
         the holes
         get too close together. Two or more staggered rows are used in the
         Ellison.
         The first 3rd are a single row. The next third  is a staggered
         double row and the last
         third is a staggered triple row. None of this is shown on any
         Ellison websites.
         Of course this further increases the cost.

         I talked to a friend of mine that owns an NC shop here in Santa
         Paula that
         has experience drilling small holes. He says there must be a close
         fitting
         brass rod in the  brass tube or drill breakage occurs
   frequently. At
         $45 a crack
         you don't want this to happen. Then you have the problem of
   pressing the
         sacrificial brass rod out of the nine inch long 1/8 inch diameter
         tube. Not
         an easy thing to do. That too requires special tooling that
   supports
         the outside
         of the tube. Perhaps this can be done better with a laser.

         I can see why Ellison is charging $850 for his aircraft carbs.
   It is
         also rapidly
         talking me out of this approach. Not a show stopper yet
   however as I
         have
         yet to investigate the laser option.

         -----------------------------------------------------------

         I am sure this outfit can do the job. I'll know more about the
   cost
         on Monday.
          http://www.calasers.com/gallery.html

         --
         Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

   I got a price on the tiny holes from the laser guys in Simi Valley.
   $250 minimum set up charge. Too much for me for R&D.

   I talked to Klaus about how his Ellison has worked and he thought
   it was not bad but the venturi part of it restricted
   the airflow compared to his EFI setup on his O-200. I assume he has
   a custom throttle body on there now. He got more HP with the custom
   throttle body.

   Here are some pictures of the Ellison carb he took off.

   Klaus also mentioned that the exact  time the fuel was squirted in
   was critical
   on a 2500 RPM aircraft engine (+/- 30 degrees) but he agreed with me
   that it matters
   not on a 7500 RPM engine. Another hidden advantage of the rotary.

   The next 3D is the mechanical low pressure fuel injection I am going to
   spend my R&D budget on. Both Hurant Karribian and I will be working
   on essentially
   the same thing.

   The pressure regulator soak in 100LL gasoline was successful. I
   could see no
   deterioration in the air pressure regulator plastic parts. Of course
   that
   is 100LL auto fuel with alcohol could be another matter.

   BTW I did some further test on JB Weld by thinning it with 25% acetone
   and it became very easy to pour. It set up but I can't vouch for the
   strength as I did not test it. With a welded in SS P-port tube
   we don't need the strength so sealing becomes its only function.

   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Couple of questions..

Instead of a sequence/pattern of holes, can a varying width slot be made
to work?  Might be essentially the same cost to cut, but maybe not...

OR!!!  How about this?  Instead of one tube with tiny holes, how about
two tubes - one which slips inside the other.  A series of larger holes
(of shape yet to be imagined) in each.  Depending on how the holes are
oriented to each other controls the mixture.  The holes could be pretty
large (easy to drill).  Rotating one tube inside the other restricts the
amount of fuel from 0-100%..  I'm pretty excited about that idea...  I
want patent rights on this one.  Hah!  :)

On the MAF sensor you picked up:  I can't remember of those use a heated
mesh to measure flow, or just a (couple of) wire(s)..  I wonder how much
obstruction there..


Matt-

I was going to vary the depth of the slot as the feed hole in the spacer is
a limited diameter. The feed hole dia. is .0625 so the Teflon slot
width is also .0625. Now if you can get a mill smaller than
that we could vary both the width and the depth.
A thin slitting saw could also be used to cut the slot.

One drawback to laser punched holes is they leave a bit of flash
around the edges. If you have one tube inside another that might
be a problem. Also, as Bill Jepson pointed out, the hole sides are tapered.
In a wall of .020" thick the inner hole dia could be .008 but the outside
diameter of the same hole would be .014. Not a good thing I suspect.

The mass air flow sensor had two heated wires in a bridge circuit I think.
The obstruction is considerable but then again the cross sectional area
is over kill.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.