Subject: a boat guy trying to learn something
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/15/2007, 8:20 AM
To: AARotary Engine

Paul,

Yes for PICAXE.  There is so much more than can be done with that
technology than with a single-solution mechanical effort.

Before you tally my vote, remember, I’m not one of the flyers.  I’m just
a boat guy trying to learn something and stay out from under foot here.
A problem unlikely to be encountered in the air is cavitation.  When my
prop meets the air, I am in immediate need of a governor.  With PICAXE,
the solution is to supply RPM data to a few added lines of code.

If all you need is to mix fuel to air within a narrow range, then the
mechanical has real appeal, but the addition of even one other function
quickly clarifies which technology is accurate, flexible and able to
cope with change.

Vehicle manufactures use electronics not because mechanical fabrication
is beyond them.  Legislation aside, autos can no longer be repaired
without a computer; they compensate for their own ills so well, the
failings are masked.  Most can “fake it” for 100,000 miles, easy.

I once thought that simple devices are more stable, but I have come to
understand (against my intuition) that it is complex mechanisms that are
better balanced.  A bacterium is very fragile compared to a bird.

Complexity is intimidating from the outside; however, if you can hang on
long enough to reach a basic understanding, the possibilities open
proportionately.  But then, everyone must decide for themselves; life is
already pretty complex for most people—especially smart ones.  There are
a lot of wonderful, worthwhile things I will never get around to doing,
even if I had the courage to try it all.

*Grant Johnson*


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.