Paul this may be a separate topic.
If you have a single rotor engine is there a rule of thumb to predict
the
magnitude of a torque peak or do you need a dyno run for the data? I'm
also
looking for a drive for a single rotor, but my goal is to reduce the
output
speed from about 7750 to about 6000. Not an off-the-shelf ratio. Can
you
put gears like this in an off-the-shelf case or do you need a new case?
The
alternative is to go to a twin-rotor and detune it. The weight
difference
between the single with reduction and detuned twin may not be that
different
in terms of weight, but it does push up cost and complexity of the
plumbing.
George W
Sounds like a custom box.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
George,
Why would you need a 1.29:1 ratio the prop speed is limited to about
2,800
so if your taking the single to 7750 rpm for take-off you need a 2.76:1
ratio. Better to use the 2.85 and spin the prop at 2700 rpm. I'm
guessing
you want 7750 rpm for take-off HP. The single can produce between 115
to
125 hp at 7500 rpm with PP - how much HP do you need? A single can
produce
100 hp without PP.
In regard to weight, the difference is about 100 lbs( maybe more), and
more
still if you use a light weight PSRU like Richard Sohn.
George ( down under)
OK, I'll come clean. I need a reduction for a ducted fan system that is
tip-speed sensitive. There is no direct correlation here between the
type
of fan I working on and and a free air prop. Its one of those designs
where
if it works, whee! And if it doesn't, you'll never hear about it. If a
single rotor is the equivalent of a three cylinder engine, do the FAA
recip
torque safety factors apply? I seem to remember running across them
while
research ing drive-shafts (which I'm not using).
George W
George,
One of the builders, Perry Mick I think, did a lot of work on ducted fans
on
his Long-eze direct drive, it looked great, but he eventually gave-up. If
I
remember correctly their only efficient to 100 knots. I think the main
problem was drag on the duct itself, inlet restrictions, leading duct edge
design - over 100knots a free propeller was more efficient, without the
complexity.
However you may have something else again?
George (down under)
What I have in mind is a spin-off from something that was done about12-14
years ago. I know what the original did and am working on a demonstration
unit about 85% of the power of the original. Not a large diameter fan
system, high solidity, cascade blading. Will play with it using a stator
stage and without. The rotor is actually pretty easy, the inlets and
variable exhaust nozzle are going to be the fun part. I'm tip speed limited
because of noise considerations, particularly with a stator stage. If you
put the stator too close to the fan you get a siren (which lengthens the
duct) At some point, you realize why the more advanced fan systems
projected in the 70's using recips and Wankels used reduction units, they
were aimed at complying with stringent noise regulations. Incidentally, a
pre-rotator stage can superficially look attractive for such an application,
but the clinker is that they are effective in only a narrow range of flow
(80-100%). I had to dig around a bit on this, finally found the data in an
industrial fan paper from India posted on the web. I notice that the ducted
fan design team at Prague University also dropped this idea. Most of the
"ducted fans" built by people like us are actually shrouded props, a
different bird with a different application. I'd like to be able to use the
same rotor in a tractor or pusher layout. The cooling issues are
interesting. In the pusher mode, I'm looking at ejector pumping with the
muffler and radiator more distant from the engine. It is tempting to
integrate the radiator system behind the engine in the tractor mode using
donut or lozenge-shaped rads with an insulated hole in the center to run the
exhaust pipe with the muffler aft of the rads. With a fairing, the rads are
partially rammed from the fan and pumped with the exhaust. Am shooting for
350 lbs of thrust with 85 hp at STP. It may be possible to supply mildly
supercharged induction air from behind the fan, but it may not be worth the
extra plumbing. You get a temperature rise across the fan of 8-10 F degrees
if it's done right. This actually lowers the density of the charge a bit
unless you heat sink the intake.
Thanks for the tip on the book, Paul (Compact Head Exchangers), I was able
to snag a 3rd Edition through
www.abebooks.com for a reasonable price.
Going to take a while to plow through the math and tables, though.
George W.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.